Borrow
The not-so-secret ingredient behind the popularity of BNPL
Why is BNPL succeeding where previous easy credit products failed? Could the answer be low friction and light regulation?
The not-so-secret ingredient behind the popularity of BNPL
Why is BNPL succeeding where previous easy credit products failed? Could the answer be low friction and light regulation?
Buy now, pay later (BNPL) has taken Australian consumers by storm in recent years, but why now?
Speaking to nestegg, ClearScore managing director Steve Smyth said that products like these tend to come in waves.
He pointed to the past successes of store cards, but emphasised the low friction of modern app-based BNPL platforms as a point of difference.
“I think that’s really what’s different from past waves. It’s all about low friction,” he said.
While traditional credit cards are often superior or equal to BNPL apps in terms of friction during use, they’re much-higher friction when it comes to getting one on short notice.
Mr Smyth noted that many consumers are predisposed to shop on credit due to the convenience it offers in regard to stalling payments. Moreover, the immediacy of access to credit that BNPL apps like Afterpay provide is a key ingredient when it comes to explaining their success and popularity.
“The flexibility of being able to buy stuff is a very strong need for most people because most people are not wealthy enough to just have reams of cash to buy what they want,” he said, pointing to stats around financial hardship.
Figures released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) in 2020 suggested that 19 per cent of Australian households were unable to raise $2,000 within a week.
For those excluded by the existing credit system, BNPL apps like Afterpay are a compelling solution to this problem.
Mr Smyth said that the appeal of low friction isn’t limited to just consumers, but also businesses looking to take advantage of new spending trends.
“With the rise of e-commerce, the ability of Afterpay and others to offer relatively simple mechanisms for checkouts enabled people to pay by just filling out the form to sign up for an Afterpay account now and then pay off in full instalments [and] was much easier for retailers,” he said.
Finally, Mr Smyth acknowledged that the existing regulations around credit in Australia are also a big part of why BNPL apps like Afterpay have taken off.
According to one report by Margeta, Australia is at the front of the pack when it comes to BNPL adoption.
The report noted that 72 per cent of consumers increased their use of BNPL over the past 12 months, and that apps like Afterpay were more popular among Australian consumers than their US and UK-based counterparts.
Mr Smyth argued that this popularity is partly owed to local regulations governing credit.
While BNPL companies charge customers in the form of late and account fees, the fact they don’t charge interest means they’re not technically considered credit cards under local legislation like the National Consumer Credit Protection Act.
With BNPL’s biggest competitors like credit cards and personal loans only able to offer a relatively high-friction experience because of local regulatory requirements, Mr Smyth framed this imbalance “a recipe for why it’s taken off”.
“Regulations in Australia make accessing credit if you’re part of that half of the population that doesn’t have to have a lot of savings so very difficult because you have to have income and expense verification that proves you can actually afford the loan,” he explained.
Looking to the future, Mr Smyth expects a convergence between the upstarts of the BNPL niche and more-established payments processing players.
Pointing to recent moves by Zip Pay, he suggested that the future of BNPL is one where they essentially act as credit cards built on an alternative business model.
At the same time, Mr Smyth noted that many “credit card companies are coming up with credit card products with zero interest and monthly fees”.
According to him, the final result of this trend is likely going to be a flooding of the market.
“You’ve got to believe there’ll be consolidation as competitors find it tougher over time, but I think you’ll see convergence as well, which is that they’ll start off with a suite of financial products that makes them more look like a regular lender,” he said.
About the author
About the author
Credit card
Westpac flexes into BNPL with zero-interest digital credit card
Another big Australian bank is looking to earn its stripes among BNPL consumers with a new digital credit card. ...Read more
Credit card
How lockdown changed Aussies’ financial habits for the better
Evidence continues to mount suggesting that lockdowns might have helped Aussies break bad spending habits and improve their credit score. ...Read more
Credit card
ANZ credit cards to get interest-free ‘instalments’ in 2022
Visa and ANZ are partnering in a bid to make standard credit card payments as flexible as buy now, pay later. ...Read more
Credit card
Zip inks Indian expansion
One of the biggest names in BNPL is investing in India as it looks to grow beyond Australia’s maturing market. ...Read more
Credit card
Credit cards continue to lose out to BNPL among Australians
The pandemic has only entrenched the popularity of buy now, pay later apps among Australians. ...Read more
Credit card
Suncorp team-up with Visa to put their spin on buy now, pay later
Suncorp’s PayLater will be available to customers from November. ...Read more
Credit card
Balance transfer credit cards explained
These days, paying off credit card debt seems to be a top financial priority for most Aussies. ...Read more
Credit card
30% of employees can’t be trusted with the company card, say SMBs
Just under a third of small-business employers say they can’t trust workers with the corporate credit card, according to a new report. ...Read more
How the post-lockdown period will influence property, what the soaring NFT market means, and defining financial wellness
Listen now
APRA’s mortgage crackdown, the power of DeFi and last-minute tax tips
Listen now
What to expect as the end of lockdown looms? Will the Stage 2 tax cuts boost your tax return? Where should investors be looking as the economy reopens?
Listen now
Could property prices inflate by another 20%? What’s happening in recent dividend announcements? Did your fund fail the YFYS test?
Listen now
RBA says BNPL 'no surcharge' rules distort competition
Read more
Australia’s banks may be more vulnerable to cyber attacks than you think
Read more
Investors are more open to net zero but less savvy on the risks
Read more
The more time I spend looking at my money, the further I feel from financial freedom
Read more
Credit card
Westpac flexes into BNPL with zero-interest digital credit card
Another big Australian bank is looking to earn its stripes among BNPL consumers with a new digital credit card. ...Read more
Credit card
How lockdown changed Aussies’ financial habits for the better
Evidence continues to mount suggesting that lockdowns might have helped Aussies break bad spending habits and improve their credit score. ...Read more
Credit card
ANZ credit cards to get interest-free ‘instalments’ in 2022
Visa and ANZ are partnering in a bid to make standard credit card payments as flexible as buy now, pay later. ...Read more
Credit card
Zip inks Indian expansion
One of the biggest names in BNPL is investing in India as it looks to grow beyond Australia’s maturing market. ...Read more
Credit card
Credit cards continue to lose out to BNPL among Australians
The pandemic has only entrenched the popularity of buy now, pay later apps among Australians. ...Read more
Credit card
Suncorp team-up with Visa to put their spin on buy now, pay later
Suncorp’s PayLater will be available to customers from November. ...Read more
Credit card
Balance transfer credit cards explained
These days, paying off credit card debt seems to be a top financial priority for most Aussies. ...Read more
Credit card
30% of employees can’t be trusted with the company card, say SMBs
Just under a third of small-business employers say they can’t trust workers with the corporate credit card, according to a new report. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
