Borrow
Controversial cashless welfare program continues for another 2 years
The Morrison government has announced an extension on the controversial cashless debit card scheme for a further two years.
Controversial cashless welfare program continues for another 2 years
The Morrison government has announced an extension on the controversial cashless debit card scheme for a further two years.
The Senate agreed to continue trials of the cashless debit card (CDC) despite critics labelling it as racist.
The CDC program quarantines up to 80 per cent of a welfare recipient’s payment on to a card, which cannot be used on products such as gambling or alcohol.
The government’s original plan was to make the card permanent in Ceduna in South Australia, the East Kimberley and Goldfields regions of WA, and the Bundaberg and Hervey Bay region of Queensland.
Instead, trials at these four sites will be extended for another two years.
Minister for Families and Social Services Anne Ruston said this was a positive step towards easing the social harm caused by problem alcohol, gambling and drug use and provides budgeting assistance and support in communities.
“The government is not interested in telling people where to spend their social security payments and has no issue with people having a beer or putting on a punt on from time to time. This is exactly why a percentage of payments are quarantined,” she explained in a statement.
“What this program does is reduce the amount of taxpayer-funded social security which is available to be spent on alcohol and gambling products and by doing so helps limit the ability for problem consumption to cause social harm for individuals, their families and communities.”
Pauline Hanson used her time in the Senate to declare that Australians on welfare have lost their rights spending their money how they like.
“That’s what this card is about. It’s not about a person’s rights,’’ Senator Hanson said.
“When you go onto this card, you basically lose your rights as well. If you go on a welfare system, you’ve lost your rights.”
Labor, Greens and some independent senators labelled the program racist in a series of speeches.
Senator Jacqui Lambie spoke about her own experiences living in poverty and on welfare, while attacking the Morrison government for not using the cards to help drug-affected Australians.
Ms Lambie outlined why she could no longer support the bill which she was involved with from the very start in a video on Twitter.
“I’ve visited every place, once, twice, some of them three times, and I’ve seen some of the results that this card has delivered in some of these areas.
“But it is hit and miss,” Ms Lambie explained.
She pointed out that under the initial plan, the government would provide rehab facilitates and access to jobs in return for using the cashless card.
“That was the carrot at the end of the stick. And quite frankly, all you’re getting and all I’ve seen is you getting the stick,” she continued.
“There’s no carrot, the card has been watered down and it is not delivering what was promised.”
The Law Council of Australia has also voiced concerns about the restrictive nature of the CDC and urges the Parliament to abandon any plans to make it an ongoing program.
Law Council president Pauline Wright said that serious concerns regarding the methodology of early CDC trial evaluations are enough of a red flag to warrant the release of further investigation.
“The Australian National Audit Office as well as academics have expressed grave concerns as to the methodology of these early evaluations,” Ms Wright said.
“While a further evaluation is underway, its findings have not yet been released, making it premature to establish the CDC as a permanent measure or to expand it.
“The bill also proposes to remove the need for independent evaluation, which will further undermine the community’s ability to know whether the CDC is effective in addressing harm to individuals or communities or has unintended consequences,” Ms Wright concluded.
About the author
About the author
Credit card
Afterpay v Zip: Which is better value?
The two biggest brands in BNPL may have more in common than you think. ...Read more
Credit card
BNPL to boom amid seasonal spending
There’s never been a better time to buy now, pay later than the holiday season. ...Read more
Credit card
Experts say BNPL data underutilised by credit sector
BNPL took off among Australian consumers so fast that credit bureaus are still trying to catch up. ...Read more
Credit card
Calls for online gambling ban intensify
A parliamentary committee has backed calls for a new ban on credit card gambling. ...Read more
Credit card
Afterpay looks to find foothold in subscriptions
Afterpay will let customers break their monthly bills into instalments from early next year. ...Read more
Credit card
Credit cards slip 4%, but BNPL isn’t the culprit
Traditional credit cards have continued to decline in popularity over the course of the pandemic. ...Read more
Credit card
BNPL isn’t the only reason to reconsider your credit card
An analysis of Australia’s credit card sector has revealed that many premium cards are charging almost 50 per cent more than the average in interest. ...Read more
Credit card
What the rest of the world can learn from Australia’s BNPL breakout
Australia has proved fertile ground for BNPL, but is it an anomaly or a sign of things to come? ...Read more
Wrapping up an eventful 2021
Listen now
What Omicron means for property, and are units right for first-time buyers? What is equity crowdfunding? Are industry super funds tapping into member funds to save their skins?
Listen now
Will housing affordability improve in 2022? Will buy now, pay later become the norm? Why are Aussies staying in failing super products?
Listen now
Who really benefits from crypto ETFs? How will the RBA respond to rising inflation? Could a mandate help address unpaid super?
Listen now
Credit card
Afterpay v Zip: Which is better value?
The two biggest brands in BNPL may have more in common than you think. ...Read more
Credit card
BNPL to boom amid seasonal spending
There’s never been a better time to buy now, pay later than the holiday season. ...Read more
Credit card
Experts say BNPL data underutilised by credit sector
BNPL took off among Australian consumers so fast that credit bureaus are still trying to catch up. ...Read more
Credit card
Calls for online gambling ban intensify
A parliamentary committee has backed calls for a new ban on credit card gambling. ...Read more
Credit card
Afterpay looks to find foothold in subscriptions
Afterpay will let customers break their monthly bills into instalments from early next year. ...Read more
Credit card
Credit cards slip 4%, but BNPL isn’t the culprit
Traditional credit cards have continued to decline in popularity over the course of the pandemic. ...Read more
Credit card
BNPL isn’t the only reason to reconsider your credit card
An analysis of Australia’s credit card sector has revealed that many premium cards are charging almost 50 per cent more than the average in interest. ...Read more
Credit card
What the rest of the world can learn from Australia’s BNPL breakout
Australia has proved fertile ground for BNPL, but is it an anomaly or a sign of things to come? ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
