Invest
‘Policing TikTok advice would inhibit innovation’
Jane Hume is adamant that curtailing finfluencers via legislation would be equivalent to creating a nanny state with “unworkable” rail guards that inhibit progress and innovation.

‘Policing TikTok advice would inhibit innovation’
Jane Hume is adamant that curtailing finfluencers via legislation would be equivalent to creating a nanny state with “unworkable” rail guards that inhibit progress and innovation.

Speaking at the AFA Evolve Conference, financial services minister Jane Hume reiterated her now-infamous view that finfluencers are just the latest iteration in a long line of consumers sharing views about financial markets, not unlike “taxi drivers giving stock tips”.
Playing down their significance on Tuesday, the minister argued against government intervention, noting that the real threat to advise comes from fraudulent members of the industry.
“Earlier this year, I made a comment about TikTok finance influencers or finfluencers, and I made it very clear, if they’re not authorised and registered, they are not financial advisers. They’re the equivalent of a taxi driver giving stock tips,” Ms Hume said.
“It goes without saying that if you make a financial decision that goes drastically wrong based on the musing of a taxi driver or a guy down at the pub or a 16-year-old on TikTok, it shouldn’t be up to the government or indeed the industry to bail you out.
“I stand by that because I am a Liberal; as a Liberal, we don’t believe in establishing unworkable rail guards that inhibit progress and innovation. I have absolutely no interest in perpetuating a nanny state culture, where we resort to banning things to save people from their own follies.”
Instead, she said it is essential that consumers have access to the right information from good financial advisers, before segueing into the cruciality of tough regulation in the advice industry.
Referencing pre-Hayne behaviour that perpetrated ongoing reputational damage to the industry, Ms Hume underlined that unlike finfluencers, it is unauthorised advisers that “undermine the financial adviser brand”.
“This market failure is really what the Financial Adviser Standards attempts to resolve,” she said.
“They signal to the consumer that if you come to me as an authorised, registered financial adviser on a publicly available register that my advice to you will be in your best interest… I am obliged to provide certain disclosures to you, I’ve passed an exam, I fulfilled specific education requirements and I can’t accept commissions or remunerations which would conflict with the duty I have to advise you.
“That’s why unauthorised advisers are the biggest risk to this industry.”
Earlier this year, survey results by MLC revealed that as many as 13 per cent of Aussies aged between 18 and 34 are regularly using platforms such as TikTok, Facebook and Instagram as a financial resource.
And while Ms Hume maintains her lukewarm view of finfluencers, RMIT University expert Dr Angel Zhong told ifa sister brand nestegg earlier this year that unmoderated investment advice provided in social media platforms could lead to herding behaviour in financial markets.
Calling for explicit measures warning vulnerable viewers about the reliability of financial advice on social media, Dr Zhong said “unverified investment advice is no different to fake news, which is frequently flagged by social media platforms that urge viewers to read with caution”.
About the author

About the author


Advice
Macquarie responds to ASIC's Federal Court proceedings
The bank has responded to civil penalty proceedings commenced by ASIC. ...Read more

Advice
Macquarie Bank taken to court by ASIC
The corporate regulator has taken action against the bank. ...Read more

Advice
ASIC's finfluencer warning a 'wake-up call'
The corporate regulator has published an information sheet on how the law applies to social media influencers or “finfluencers” and licensees who use them. ...Read more

Advice
Compensation scheme fails to protect Aussie investors
The FPA is concerned the government’s proposed CSLR model won’t provide adequate protection for Australian investors. ...Read more

Advice
ASIC says it’s ‘emotionally inappropriate’ to apologise to victims of Sterling collapse
The corporate regulator has conceded that it could have acted differently in response to concerns with the Sterling Group but has refused to apologise for the matter. ...Read more

Advice
Corporate regulator defends decision to not act earlier on Sterling collapse
The corporate regulator said it did not believe there was any “particular concern” to act on complaints regarding the Sterling Income Trust when it was first brought to its attention. ...Read more

Advice
Introducing nestegg’s new-look team
Momentum Media has bolstered its wealth portfolio, unveiling an expanded content team and adding a consumer brand that delivers Australians essential information to prepare for a successful financial ...Read more

Advice
ASIC announces review of select ‘finfluencers’
ASIC is undertaking a review of a select few “finfluencers” to understand how the financial services law applies to their activity. ...Read more

Wrapping up an eventful 2021
Listen now

What Omicron means for property, and are units right for first-time buyers? What is equity crowdfunding? Are industry super funds tapping into member funds to save their skins?
Listen now

Will housing affordability improve in 2022? Will buy now, pay later become the norm? Why are Aussies staying in failing super products?
Listen now

Who really benefits from crypto ETFs? How will the RBA respond to rising inflation? Could a mandate help address unpaid super?
Listen now

Advice
Macquarie responds to ASIC's Federal Court proceedings
The bank has responded to civil penalty proceedings commenced by ASIC. ...Read more

Advice
Macquarie Bank taken to court by ASIC
The corporate regulator has taken action against the bank. ...Read more

Advice
ASIC's finfluencer warning a 'wake-up call'
The corporate regulator has published an information sheet on how the law applies to social media influencers or “finfluencers” and licensees who use them. ...Read more

Advice
Compensation scheme fails to protect Aussie investors
The FPA is concerned the government’s proposed CSLR model won’t provide adequate protection for Australian investors. ...Read more

Advice
ASIC says it’s ‘emotionally inappropriate’ to apologise to victims of Sterling collapse
The corporate regulator has conceded that it could have acted differently in response to concerns with the Sterling Group but has refused to apologise for the matter. ...Read more

Advice
Corporate regulator defends decision to not act earlier on Sterling collapse
The corporate regulator said it did not believe there was any “particular concern” to act on complaints regarding the Sterling Income Trust when it was first brought to its attention. ...Read more

Advice
Introducing nestegg’s new-look team
Momentum Media has bolstered its wealth portfolio, unveiling an expanded content team and adding a consumer brand that delivers Australians essential information to prepare for a successful financial ...Read more

Advice
ASIC announces review of select ‘finfluencers’
ASIC is undertaking a review of a select few “finfluencers” to understand how the financial services law applies to their activity. ...Read more