subscribe to our newsletter sign up

The truth will out: Royal commission forces NAB to publish 'detrimental' document

Magnifying glass with people, royal commission, NAB

The royal commission is a public inquiry, and even the giants of Australia’s financial services aren’t immune, Commissioner Kenneth Hayne has reminded NAB.

In one of the more dramatic chapters of this round of hearings, NAB was forced to hand over a damaging letter, despite pleas to keep a document private in the name of “wider public interest”.

“The inquiry is a public inquiry. That’s the premise from which we begin, is it not?” Mr Hayne reminded NAB’s legal counsel, Neil Young on Tuesday.

Mr Young was calling for a non-publication direction of a letter from NAB directors to the corporate regulator, ASIC, in which the directors argued against a court-approved enforceable undertaking due to its error-disclosure breaches.

The error in question saw thousands of NAB and MLC customers pay fees for services they didn’t receive after they were transferred among different NAB super products.

Mr Young said that while it was undisputable that the letter required scrutiny from the royal commission, the publication of the letter “at large” would be to “the potential detriment to the public interest in ensuring that negotiations and discussions of this kind are conducted frankly and fairly”.

He said there would also be potential detriment flowing to NAB following the publication of the letter.

“The detriment to our client is that there would be unnecessary public revelation of the various concessions and compromises that my client was prepared to put forward in July 2016 in the context of this issue that had arisen with ASIC.”

However, Mr Hayne said that the royal commission had a duty to “strike a balance” between its role and maintaining NAB’s interests, and the interests of other institutions when dealing with the regulator.

With this in mind, he said Mr Young’s warnings that publication could “inhibit or chill” ASIC’s relationships with financial entities, wasn’t enough to keep the document private.

The royal commission continues to examine the contents and implications of the letter today.

You can follow our rolling coverage here.

The truth will out: Royal commission forces NAB to publish 'detrimental' document
nestegg logo
subscribe to our newsletter sign up
FROM THE WEB
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Anonymous - I agree. I think Mr Hodge was getting at the fact that the fees for someone who is invested in cash for the last 3 years were out of wack. Simply.......
Liberal at heart - Tony Abbott will go down in history as the man who wrecked the liberal party. The libs will definitely loose the next elections. Thanks Tony for your.......
john - everyone (and I mean everyone) should now just change to an industry super fund (obviously for performance sake) and be done with it. first do their.......
BornSkeptic - It's about time that Abbott the Wrecker and his band of selfish, thieving thugs were sent off to the knackery, they have cost this country so very.......