Retirement
Unions and independence: The super paradox
Unions exist to benefit members, but a requirement for union representation could have left Energy Super members $20 million worse-off, the royal commission has heard.
Unions and independence: The super paradox
Unions exist to benefit members, but a requirement for union representation could have left Energy Super members $20 million worse-off, the royal commission has heard.
Energy Super chair Scott Wilson told the royal commission on Friday of how a potential merger between Energy Super and Equip Super was scuppered due to conflicts over board make-up.
The benefits of this merger for members could have been as much as $20.5 million, KPMG analysis found. It also could have delivered savings for members of up to 0.15 per cent through enhanced scale.
However, Energy Super required a board featuring union representatives, while Equip Super preferred to build a “skills-based board” made up of member and employer representatives, with the remaining third determined through a skills test.
Speaking to the commission, Mr Wilson said he believed from the start the merger wouldn’t get across the line due to Equip Super’s sentiment towards union-nominated directors.
Ultimately, Energy Super and Equip Super reached a stalemate; the merger would only go forward provided Equip Super allowed the board to feature union-nominated directors.
Questioned on whether this barrier protected or damaged members’ best interests, Mr Wilson said the interests of super members and unions are “indistinguishable”.
“What do unions do around superannuation? We won it. We won it in the '80s through awards. So superannuation is very, very important to unions,” Mr Wilson said.
“It just so happens when we talk about superannuation funds that the interests of unions and the interests of members of the funds are so aligned as to be indistinguishable. It’s what we do.
“We look after members’ money through the accumulation and into retirement. If we can’t be guaranteed that an anti-union employer-based fund is going to allow to have union representation on their board going forward, what’s going to happen to our members in far north Queensland, what’s going to happen to our members in Cairns and Townsville? Who is going to service them?”
Equip Super went on to merge with the former Rio Tinto Staff Superannuation Fund. According to an Equip Super statement, this merger has reduced member fees and premiums by $12 million.
Nest Egg’s ongoing coverage of the royal commission continues here.
RELATED ARTICLES
Superannuation
Rest strengthens investment strategy with seasoned executive appointment
In a strategic move to bolster its investment strategy, Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has appointed Andy Moser as the Head of CIO Office. This newly created ...Read more
Superannuation
NGS Super strengthens leadership with appointment of new Chief Member Officer
In a strategic move to bolster its member growth and experience transformation, NGS Super has appointed Adam Parsons as the new Chief Member Officer (CMO). Effective from 1 June 2026, Parsons will ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super triumphs at Chant West Super Fund Awards with top honours
In a significant achievement for Aware Super, the fund has clinched top honours at the Chant West Super Fund Awards, securing both the Super Fund of the Year and Pension Fund of the Year titlesRead more
Superannuation
NGS Super rolls out enhanced member advice services with a focus on accessibility
In a significant move to make financial advice more accessible, NGS Super has unveiled an enhanced suite of member advice services, featuring a new digital advice platform. This initiative aims to ...Read more
Superannuation
US data centre investment highlights the benefits of decarbonisation and digitalisation
In a compelling demonstration of the global shift towards decarbonisation and digitalisation, Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has underscored the value created ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super bolsters support for financial advisers amid growing partnerships
In a strategic move to enhance its growth trajectory, Aware Super has announced a significant investment in bolstering support for financial advisers, aiming to deliver superior retirement outcomes ...Read more
Superannuation
TelstraSuper and Aware Super merge, creating a powerhouse with over $235 billion in funds
In a strategic move that underscores the growing trend of consolidation in the superannuation industry, TelstraSuper and Aware Super have successfully completed their merger, creating a formidable ...Read more
Superannuation
Parliamentary support heralds a fairer superannuation system for under-18s
In a significant development for Australia's superannuation landscape, Rest, one of the nation's largest profit-to-member super funds, has praised the recent cross-parliamentary support for extending ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest strengthens investment strategy with seasoned executive appointment
In a strategic move to bolster its investment strategy, Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has appointed Andy Moser as the Head of CIO Office. This newly created ...Read more
Superannuation
NGS Super strengthens leadership with appointment of new Chief Member Officer
In a strategic move to bolster its member growth and experience transformation, NGS Super has appointed Adam Parsons as the new Chief Member Officer (CMO). Effective from 1 June 2026, Parsons will ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super triumphs at Chant West Super Fund Awards with top honours
In a significant achievement for Aware Super, the fund has clinched top honours at the Chant West Super Fund Awards, securing both the Super Fund of the Year and Pension Fund of the Year titlesRead more
Superannuation
NGS Super rolls out enhanced member advice services with a focus on accessibility
In a significant move to make financial advice more accessible, NGS Super has unveiled an enhanced suite of member advice services, featuring a new digital advice platform. This initiative aims to ...Read more
Superannuation
US data centre investment highlights the benefits of decarbonisation and digitalisation
In a compelling demonstration of the global shift towards decarbonisation and digitalisation, Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has underscored the value created ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super bolsters support for financial advisers amid growing partnerships
In a strategic move to enhance its growth trajectory, Aware Super has announced a significant investment in bolstering support for financial advisers, aiming to deliver superior retirement outcomes ...Read more
Superannuation
TelstraSuper and Aware Super merge, creating a powerhouse with over $235 billion in funds
In a strategic move that underscores the growing trend of consolidation in the superannuation industry, TelstraSuper and Aware Super have successfully completed their merger, creating a formidable ...Read more
Superannuation
Parliamentary support heralds a fairer superannuation system for under-18s
In a significant development for Australia's superannuation landscape, Rest, one of the nation's largest profit-to-member super funds, has praised the recent cross-parliamentary support for extending ...Read more
