Invest
How much is the wagyu and shiraz case costing taxpayers?
ASIC has disclosed the preliminary legal bill for its responsible lending case against Westpac.
How much is the wagyu and shiraz case costing taxpayers?
ASIC has disclosed the preliminary legal bill for its responsible lending case against Westpac.
The case centred on Westpac’s use of an automatic process to approve hundreds of thousands of home loans, substituting would-be borrowers’ actual living expediter for a relatively low benchmark, the Household Expenditure Measure.
In his judgment last year, Justice Perram found that a customer’s current living expenses weren’t an important indicator of whether they could afford the loan, contending expenses could be cut if necessary.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has revealed that its proceedings against Westpac Group for alleged breaches of responsible lending have cost taxpayers at least $1.83 million.
The costs include expenses from a pre-litigation investigation of Westpac’s conduct, as well as charges associated with proceedings in the Federal Court and the regulator’s appeal to the Full Federal Court.
However, the costs exclude Westpac’s litigation expenses, which the court ordered ASIC to pay after its appeal was dismissed.
ASIC stated that Westpac is yet to disclose its expenses to the corporate regulator.
The litigation costs were revealed in a response to a question on notice from Liberal senator and chair of the parliamentary joint committee on corporations and financial services, James Paterson, from a public hearing held last month.
The public hearing was held prior to ASIC’s decision to accept the Full Federal Court’s judgement, which the regulator had considered appealing to the High Court.
Senator Paterson had questioned whether a move to take the matter to the High Court would be counterintuitive.
“As we’ve discussed in this case previously, it’s ASIC’s aspiration to have clarity in the law and that’s what you said the appeal could provide,” he said.
“Obviously, that clarity could also be provided by ASIC accepting the court’s ruling of what the law is.
“Now that you’ve appealed once and been unsuccessful, is it really wise for ASIC to create further uncertainty with another appeal?”
The regulator has since announced that in light of the Full Federal Court’s decision, it would review its updated regulatory guidance and consider the implications of the Federal Court’s decision on compliance practices.
ASIC issued its new guidance in December 2019, after holding two rounds of public consultation with industry stakeholders.
The principles-based guidance was designed to provide lenders with greater clarity and flexibility amid uncertainty off the back of scrutiny from the banking royal commission.
However, ASIC has stressed that prospective reforms of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act to further clarify the enforcement of responsible lending obligations is “ultimately a matter for the federal government and Parliament”.
About the author
About the author
Shares
‘Impact matters more to retail investors than returns’
One of Australia’s many retail investing apps is sharing some insights into how consumers actually use their platform. ...Read more
Shares
Rising rates set to kill ‘unicorn investments’
Shifting economic strategy post-COVID-19 will lead to rising interest rates, causing the death of “unicorn investments”, an industry expert predicts. ...Read more
Shares
The surprising poster child for ESG investing
Investors looking to have the most impact on the world should not simply follow ESG values, but instead focus on companies that will be needed in a “post-carbon world”. ...Read more
Shares
5 tips to turn down the noise and stay focused as an investor
A surge in financial information, opinions and a natural inclination to focus on the negatives is leading to poorer short-term outcomes for investors, which is impacting long-term results, an economis...Read more
Shares
Why investors should expect modest returns this financial year
Regardless of the investment type, the highs of the 2020-21 financial year are unlikely to be replicated over the next 12 months, an industry expert has warned investors. ...Read more
Shares
Are ETFs and REITs a way for young Australians to build their stake in the property market?
Fractional property isn’t the only low-cost route into Australia’s property market jockeying for attention from younger investors. ...Read more
Shares
Is ESG investing a bubble or the future?
Investors are having a change of preference, with climate risk becoming more prevalent than ever. But is this driving the next investing fad or is it the way of the future? ...Read more
Shares
Study reveals why younger adults are likely to indulge in risky investment behaviour
The risky behaviour associated with ‘meme stocks’ should not surprise markets as younger adults continue to indulge in riskier investment behaviour. ...Read more
The Olympic effect on property and equity investors; COVID-19 Disaster Payments and super
Listen now
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Shares
‘Impact matters more to retail investors than returns’
One of Australia’s many retail investing apps is sharing some insights into how consumers actually use their platform. ...Read more
Shares
Rising rates set to kill ‘unicorn investments’
Shifting economic strategy post-COVID-19 will lead to rising interest rates, causing the death of “unicorn investments”, an industry expert predicts. ...Read more
Shares
The surprising poster child for ESG investing
Investors looking to have the most impact on the world should not simply follow ESG values, but instead focus on companies that will be needed in a “post-carbon world”. ...Read more
Shares
5 tips to turn down the noise and stay focused as an investor
A surge in financial information, opinions and a natural inclination to focus on the negatives is leading to poorer short-term outcomes for investors, which is impacting long-term results, an economis...Read more
Shares
Why investors should expect modest returns this financial year
Regardless of the investment type, the highs of the 2020-21 financial year are unlikely to be replicated over the next 12 months, an industry expert has warned investors. ...Read more
Shares
Are ETFs and REITs a way for young Australians to build their stake in the property market?
Fractional property isn’t the only low-cost route into Australia’s property market jockeying for attention from younger investors. ...Read more
Shares
Is ESG investing a bubble or the future?
Investors are having a change of preference, with climate risk becoming more prevalent than ever. But is this driving the next investing fad or is it the way of the future? ...Read more
Shares
Study reveals why younger adults are likely to indulge in risky investment behaviour
The risky behaviour associated with ‘meme stocks’ should not surprise markets as younger adults continue to indulge in riskier investment behaviour. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
