Invest
Google won’t touch data for a decade if ACCC approves deal
The ACCC is seeking feedback on whether Google will use health data obtained by Fitbit to target ads to consumers, after the tech giant announced a purchase of the wearable devices company.
Google won’t touch data for a decade if ACCC approves deal
The ACCC is seeking feedback on whether Google will use health data obtained by Fitbit to target ads to consumers, after the tech giant announced a purchase of the wearable devices company.
Google has announced a nearly $3 billion ($2.1 billion US) plan to purchase Fitbit a year ago, but the sale has yet to be approved by Australian or European regulators.
Australia’s competition watchdog has raised concerns about enforcing the strict guidelines it set out upon the sale.
Under the guidelines, the ACCC would require Google to not use certain user data collected through Fitbit or its own wearable devices for Google’s advertising for at least 10 years.
They are also expecting Google to maintain access for third parties, such as health and fitness apps, to certain user data collected through Fitbit and Google wearable devices for 10 years, and maintain levels of interoperability between third-party wearables and Android smartphones for 10 years.
“Our decision to begin consultation should not be interpreted as a signal that the ACCC will ultimately accept the undertaking and approve the transaction,” ACCC chair Rod Sims said.
“Feedback from interested parties will assist us to decide whether the behavioural remedy proposed is capable of addressing our competition concerns regarding this transaction.”
However, a group of leading economists from Monash University found this proposal concerning enough to speak out against it.
Professor Chongwoo Choe, director of the Centre for Global Business (CGB), and associate professor Zhijun Chen, a coordinator for CGB’s Digital Economy Research Network, joined with a number of the world’s top competition economists to prepare an amicus brief to the European Competition Authority in the hope they could raise the alarm on behalf of unsuspecting global consumers.
“Sensitive health data held by Fitbit can be added to users’ personal profile Google aggregates from its other services, such as emails, maps and online searches,” Professor Choe said.
“While Google says it would not use Fitbit data for advertising purposes, this doesn’t rule out Google’s use of this data in other markets, such as healthcare.”
Associate Professor Chen said Google’s bid for Fitbit is consistent with its strategy to expand into healthcare, life sciences and insurance.
“By connecting Fitbit data with user data from Google’s Cloud Healthcare API, Google can build a more comprehensive patient profile and offer more personalised health care,” he said.
Associate Professor Chen says Google’s ambition is to protect its unique data empire, integrate functionalities and monetise information through its expanding digital arms.
This is evidenced through the Google Workspace (formerly G Suite) with a number of its popular free services – Gmail, Calendar, Maps, Chrome and News. Revenue from these platforms wasn’t directly sourced from the sale of advertisements, but through the collection of consumer demographic, interest and location data to better target advertisement placement.
“The Fitbit merger provides the chance for the European Commission and the ACCC to remain a frontrunner in the enforcement and guidance of merger policy in the digital era,” Associate Professor Chen said.
Professor Choe says Google’s proposed acquisition of Fitbit is not just about a gadget being brought into Google’s ecosystem, but one that involves highly sensitive data that is likely to harm consumers in health insurance, medical services and even labour markets.
“All too often, academics and policymakers look back and lament a failure to intervene more decisively and bemoan their hopeful reliance on remedies that just don’t work,” Professor Choe said.
About the author
About the author
Shares
Where to invest $1k and start growing your portfolio
Novice investors with a spare $1,000 in their bank accounts are advised to consider ETFs, as this asset type soars in popularity. ...Read more
Shares
AMP hits record low
Shares in financial wealth giant AMP have closed at a new record low, following the potential sale of AMP Capital to US-based Ares Management falling through. ...Read more
Shares
Aussie investors flock to social media to learn about trading
Aussie investors are increasingly turning to social media platforms for education on trading, as collaboration and reliance on a community become integral in the way traders learn. ...Read more
Shares
GameStop looks to cash in on surge by selling 3.5m shares
The GameStop saga continues as the retailer moves to capitalise on its newfound fame by offering up for sale 3.5 million of its shares. ...Read more
Shares
Expert warns against media-led stock frenzies as GameStop shares plummet to 7-week low
An expert has urged “extreme caution” when joining social media-led stock frenzies, after GameStop shares were rocked by its less than favourable financial results. ...Read more
Shares
GameStop fails to meet revenue estimates, shares seesaw
GameStop has failed to capitalise on the frenzy around the stock, missing its Q4 estimates, although it reported strong sales in early Q1. ...Read more
Shares
Why CBA’s BNPL launch won’t be the end of Afterpay
The big four bank’s arrival into the buy now, pay later sector is unlikely to have an impact on the established players, with the bank focusing on supply instead of consumer demand, an industry expe...Read more
Shares
How investors can practically incorporate more ESG into their portfolios
Six-year-olds and healthy food can be like mixing water with oil – they don’t really like to party together, and it can be a constant source of frustration. That said, the difference is that you h...Read more
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening to the low and middle income tax offset?
Listen now
Home values up 30% (or are they); NFTs taking the world by storm, and why Keating thinks Aussies will be ‘poor’ in retirement
Listen now
Raging floods, the tech stock bubble and the ongoing SG debate
Listen now
Meet the Manager with Trilogy’s Philip Ryan: RBA rates and property price growth
Listen now
Shares
Where to invest $1k and start growing your portfolio
Novice investors with a spare $1,000 in their bank accounts are advised to consider ETFs, as this asset type soars in popularity. ...Read more
Shares
AMP hits record low
Shares in financial wealth giant AMP have closed at a new record low, following the potential sale of AMP Capital to US-based Ares Management falling through. ...Read more
Shares
Aussie investors flock to social media to learn about trading
Aussie investors are increasingly turning to social media platforms for education on trading, as collaboration and reliance on a community become integral in the way traders learn. ...Read more
Shares
GameStop looks to cash in on surge by selling 3.5m shares
The GameStop saga continues as the retailer moves to capitalise on its newfound fame by offering up for sale 3.5 million of its shares. ...Read more
Shares
Expert warns against media-led stock frenzies as GameStop shares plummet to 7-week low
An expert has urged “extreme caution” when joining social media-led stock frenzies, after GameStop shares were rocked by its less than favourable financial results. ...Read more
Shares
GameStop fails to meet revenue estimates, shares seesaw
GameStop has failed to capitalise on the frenzy around the stock, missing its Q4 estimates, although it reported strong sales in early Q1. ...Read more
Shares
Why CBA’s BNPL launch won’t be the end of Afterpay
The big four bank’s arrival into the buy now, pay later sector is unlikely to have an impact on the established players, with the bank focusing on supply instead of consumer demand, an industry expe...Read more
Shares
How investors can practically incorporate more ESG into their portfolios
Six-year-olds and healthy food can be like mixing water with oil – they don’t really like to party together, and it can be a constant source of frustration. That said, the difference is that you h...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
