Invest
Portfolio manager relieved to dispose of 'problematic' Twitter
According to a portfolio manager, the social media platform has been falling short of potential for years while “underserved” riches have been handed to staff via stock-based compensation.
Portfolio manager relieved to dispose of 'problematic' Twitter
According to a portfolio manager, the social media platform has been falling short of potential for years while “underserved” riches have been handed to staff via stock-based compensation.
Co-portfolio manager for Forager Funds' International Shares Fund, Gareth Brow, has penned a candid piece, airing Twitter’s dirty laundry and his grave discontent with the platform’s management, and, seemingly, extending a hand to the platform’s new owner, Musk.
Under the title, “Twitter – the one that got away”, Mr Brown argued that the platform is grossly undervalued with a “gaping wide gulf” between fair value based on today’s management and what the value of the business would be under "ideal management and execution".
Twitter is a holding in the Forager International Shares Fund.
Last week, Mr Brown told media that Musk’s offer of US$54.20 a share was “probably a fair price for Twitter as it’s run today”. And while he feels that it underestimates Twitter as it “could and should be”, he is, in part, relieved.
“A problem has been taken off my hands for a decent premium, and at a time when opportunities elsewhere abound,” he said.
“Executing Twitter's difficult turnaround after years of falling short of potential while paying out immense, undeserved riches to staff via stock based compensation? That’s now somebody else’s problem,” Mr Brown added.
But Mr Brown also revealed his grave disappointment in Twitter’s board and declared it chiefly responsible for Twitter’s untapped potential.
Moreover, he slammed the board for doing little to “extract blood” from the new owner to pay the old owners for all that unutilised potential.
Turning to Musk, Mr Brown said that while the Tesla CEO has bought Twitter on a platform of delivering free speech to the world, “he’s going to make immense amounts of profit too”.
“Likely hundred of billions of dollars,” Mr Brown said.
“Unfortunately, our own investors will see almost none of it.”
But despite bearing a hint of resentment towards the fortune Musk is predicted to amass, Mr Brown said he is “very interested” in the new owner’s plans for the platform and for free speech.
“I prefer too much talk over too little,” Mr Brown added.
On Monday, Twitter confirmed it has agreed to be acquired by Elon Musk for approximately US$44 billion ($61.4 billion).
Twitter’s independent board chair, Bret Taylor, added that the proposed transaction will deliver a “substantial” cash premium and said it is the best path forward for stockholders.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Investment insights
Investors maintain cautious stance amid data uncertainty
Amidst the backdrop of a US government shutdown and lingering economic uncertainties, investors have adopted a neutral stance, as revealed by the latest State Street Institutional Investor IndicatorsRead more
Investment insights
State Street's 2026 global market outlook anticipates cautious growth with strategic investment shifts
State Street Investment Management, the world's fourth-largest asset manager, has released its much-anticipated 2026 Global Market Outlook (GMO) report titled "Forward with Focus." The report provides ...Read more
Investment insights
J.P. Morgan strategists highlight Australia as a key investment destination amidst global uncertainties
Amidst a backdrop of fluctuating energy prices, J.P. Morgan Private Bank strategists have identified Australia as a beacon of opportunity for global investors, particularly within its fixed income and ...Read more
Investment insights
HarbourVest Partners unveils new private equity benchmarks highlighting long-term outperformance
In a significant update for the private equity world, HarbourVest Partners, a leading global private markets investment firm, has released its quarterly private equity benchmarks, providing ...Read more
Investment insights
Mason Stevens strengthens UHNW offering through partnership with GloryHouse
In a strategic move set to bolster its position in the ultra-high-net-worth (UHNW) sector, Mason Stevens, a prominent name in Australia's wealth management landscape, has announced a partnership with ...Read more
Investment insights
Beyond the trophy: What the Women in Finance Awards 2025 signal for strategy, talent and ROI
Australia’s Women in Finance Awards have crowned their 2025 cohort, but the real story isn’t the stage—it’s the strategy. Recognition programs now function as market barometers, signalling which ...Read more
Investment insights
Orbis Investments challenges investors to rethink assumptions in 2026
In a bold move to reshape investor perspectives, Orbis Investments has released a new report titled "Six Courageous Questions for 2026," encouraging investors to critically evaluate their assumptions ...Read more
Investment insights
Rate relief on the horizon? How a November cut could reshape Australian balance sheets
With unemployment edging up to a multi-year high, markets are weighing whether the Reserve Bank will pivot to a rate cut as early as November. For CFOs and CEOs, the real question isn’t if a cut ...Read more
Investment insights
Investors maintain cautious stance amid data uncertainty
Amidst the backdrop of a US government shutdown and lingering economic uncertainties, investors have adopted a neutral stance, as revealed by the latest State Street Institutional Investor IndicatorsRead more
Investment insights
State Street's 2026 global market outlook anticipates cautious growth with strategic investment shifts
State Street Investment Management, the world's fourth-largest asset manager, has released its much-anticipated 2026 Global Market Outlook (GMO) report titled "Forward with Focus." The report provides ...Read more
Investment insights
J.P. Morgan strategists highlight Australia as a key investment destination amidst global uncertainties
Amidst a backdrop of fluctuating energy prices, J.P. Morgan Private Bank strategists have identified Australia as a beacon of opportunity for global investors, particularly within its fixed income and ...Read more
Investment insights
HarbourVest Partners unveils new private equity benchmarks highlighting long-term outperformance
In a significant update for the private equity world, HarbourVest Partners, a leading global private markets investment firm, has released its quarterly private equity benchmarks, providing ...Read more
Investment insights
Mason Stevens strengthens UHNW offering through partnership with GloryHouse
In a strategic move set to bolster its position in the ultra-high-net-worth (UHNW) sector, Mason Stevens, a prominent name in Australia's wealth management landscape, has announced a partnership with ...Read more
Investment insights
Beyond the trophy: What the Women in Finance Awards 2025 signal for strategy, talent and ROI
Australia’s Women in Finance Awards have crowned their 2025 cohort, but the real story isn’t the stage—it’s the strategy. Recognition programs now function as market barometers, signalling which ...Read more
Investment insights
Orbis Investments challenges investors to rethink assumptions in 2026
In a bold move to reshape investor perspectives, Orbis Investments has released a new report titled "Six Courageous Questions for 2026," encouraging investors to critically evaluate their assumptions ...Read more
Investment insights
Rate relief on the horizon? How a November cut could reshape Australian balance sheets
With unemployment edging up to a multi-year high, markets are weighing whether the Reserve Bank will pivot to a rate cut as early as November. For CFOs and CEOs, the real question isn’t if a cut ...Read more
