Save
Franking credits changes cop another lashing
One investment firm has said that, in its current form, the proposed Labor changes to the franking credits regime do not pass the fairness test for Australian investors.
Franking credits changes cop another lashing
One investment firm has said that, in its current form, the proposed Labor changes to the franking credits regime do not pass the fairness test for Australian investors.
At an event in Sydney today, Stephen Bruce from Perennial Value Management Limited said that while an economic argument could be made, the bottom line was that the proposal wasn’t up to scratch.
The proposal, announced over a year ago by shadow treasurer Chris Bowen, is to scrap cash refunds on excess dividend imputation credits with exceptions for pensioners.
“Our view is that you can make an economic argument that refunding franking credits should be stopped and wasn’t part of the original imputations system, but the bottom line is that the current proposals fail both the fairness test, as they clearly treat different classes of investors differently, and they are also likely to be circumvented by those with the largest balances anyhow,” Mr Bruce said.
Mr Bruce, the director portfolio manager for Perennial, said that while the majority of people would be unaffected, it was still unfair.
“The important point in this debate is that three-quarters of people will see no change; it’s the one-quarter that will be affected in a way we think is unfair,” he said.
It is this percentage of people affected that is currently the cause of debate amongst the two major parties leading into the election.
Grounds for debate
Labor claims that the policy is closing down a tax loophole that costs $8 billion a year and only generates more wealth for the already wealthy.
“Much of this goes to high-wealth individuals, with 80 per cent of the benefit accruing to the wealthiest 20 per cent of retirees.
“Labor does not think it is fair to spend $8 billion a year on a tax loophole that mainly benefits millionaires who don’t pay income tax – not when school standards are falling and hospital waiting lists are growing longer,” Labor said in a statement.
The Liberal Party, after a controversial and much-criticised inquiry into the proposal determined that the policy affected more than just the wealthy.
“The ALP’s policy will unfairly hit people of modest incomes who have already retired and who are unlikely to be able to return to the workforce to make up for the income they will lose,” said Liberal MP Tim Wilson, who chaired the inquiry.
Luckily for investors, it seemed that the proposals would not make it into legislation, Mr Bruce said.
“Fortunately at this stage at least, regardless of the election outcome, the senate crossbench would be unlikely to support the proposal, at least in its current form,” he said.
The real world impact
If the proposals did make it through then, it was unlikely to have a huge impact on dividends, which performed strongly without franking, Mr Bruce said.
“I've just highlighted how important dividends are to total return outcomes, and that doesn’t include franking credits.
“With the market trading on a dividend yield of 5 per cent excluding franking, that still stacks up very well compared to fixed income and term deposits.”
A potential solution would to be impose a cap on the credits, Mr Bruce said, which would protect the average balances.
“Maybe one solution is that we will end up with a regime where we do allow a refund of franking credits but with a cap on it, which protects the typical person with an average balance but stops the very wealthy from getting millions of dollars,” he said.
RELATED ARTICLES
Tax saving
Navigating tax laws for capital gains in 2023
The landscape of Australian tax laws surrounding capital gains is ever-changing, with 2023 being no exception. Read more
Tax saving
What you need to know about the tax implications of crypto
One million Aussies are now invested in crypto, but many have not thought about how these investments will affect them at tax time. Read more
Tax saving
Welfare overhaul could give recipients a leg-up
Australia’s Centrelink recipients who’ve been doing it tough are in for a potentially easier time if the federal government pursues ambitious reforms that could provide sturdier safety nets. Read more
Tax saving
Students should think twice before tapping into their super
Former students might want to think carefully before they look to take advantage of the federal government’s biggest first home buyer incentive. Read more
Tax saving
Advocates call for an end to tax cuts
Social services sector advocates have warned that further tax cuts may make solving Australia’s biggest challenges much harder. Read more
Tax saving
ATO and AUSTRAC may gain new phone-tapping powers
A proposed update to electronic surveillance legislation could see the ATO armed with new powers that would allow the agency to bug phones and intercept online communications. Read more
Tax saving
Over 2m Aussies asked the TPB for help during the last year
As the economy recovers, Australia’s tax regulator says it’s planning to put unregistered practitioners under the microscope. Read more
Tax saving
Will you pay higher taxes due to bracket creep?
Bracket creep will see Australians paying more tax on average, unless further cuts are introduced in the future. Read more
Tax saving
Navigating tax laws for capital gains in 2023
The landscape of Australian tax laws surrounding capital gains is ever-changing, with 2023 being no exception. Read more
Tax saving
What you need to know about the tax implications of crypto
One million Aussies are now invested in crypto, but many have not thought about how these investments will affect them at tax time. Read more
Tax saving
Welfare overhaul could give recipients a leg-up
Australia’s Centrelink recipients who’ve been doing it tough are in for a potentially easier time if the federal government pursues ambitious reforms that could provide sturdier safety nets. Read more
Tax saving
Students should think twice before tapping into their super
Former students might want to think carefully before they look to take advantage of the federal government’s biggest first home buyer incentive. Read more
Tax saving
Advocates call for an end to tax cuts
Social services sector advocates have warned that further tax cuts may make solving Australia’s biggest challenges much harder. Read more
Tax saving
ATO and AUSTRAC may gain new phone-tapping powers
A proposed update to electronic surveillance legislation could see the ATO armed with new powers that would allow the agency to bug phones and intercept online communications. Read more
Tax saving
Over 2m Aussies asked the TPB for help during the last year
As the economy recovers, Australia’s tax regulator says it’s planning to put unregistered practitioners under the microscope. Read more
Tax saving
Will you pay higher taxes due to bracket creep?
Bracket creep will see Australians paying more tax on average, unless further cuts are introduced in the future. Read more
More articles
OUR PLATFORMS AND BRANDS
- Accountants Daily
- Accounting Times
- Adviser Innovation
- Australian Aviation
- Broker Daily
- Cyber Daily
- Defence Connect
- Fintech Business
- HR Leader
- Independent Financial Adviser
- Investment Centre
- Investor Daily
- Lawyers Weekly
- Money Management
- Nestegg
- Property Buzz
- Real Estate Business
- Smart Property Investment
- SMSF Adviser
- Space Connect
- Super Review
- The Adviser
- Wellness Daily
- World of Aviation
EVENTS AND SUMMITS
- Accountants Daily 30 Under 30 Awards
- ACE25
- Adviser Innovation Summit
- Australian Accounting Awards
- Australian Aviation Awards
- Australian Broking Awards
- Australian Defence Industry Awards
- Australian Law Awards
- Australian Space Awards
- Australian Space Summit
- Better Business Summit & Awards
- Broker Daily Business Awards
- Corporate Counsel Summit & Awards
- Cyber Security Summit & Awards
- Defence Connect Budget Lunch
- Defence Connect DSR Summit
- Fund Manager of the Year Awards
- ifa Excellence Awards
- ifa Future Forum
- Investor Daily ESG Summit
- Lawyers Weekly 30 Under 30 Awards
- Lawyers Weekly Women in Law Forum
- New Broker Academy
- Partner of the Year Awards
- REB Awards
- Reinnovate
- SME Broker Bootcamp
- SMSF Adviser Technical Day
- Super Fund of the Year Awards
- Women in Finance Awards
- Women in Law Awards
- Accountants Daily Podcast Network
- Australian Aviation Podcast Network
- Broker Daily Podcast Network
- Defence Connect Podcast Network
- HR Leader Podcast Network
- REB Podcast Network
- Relative Return
- Space Connect Podcast
- The Adviser Podcast Network
- The ifa Show
- The Lawyers Weekly Show
- The Smart Property Investment Show
PODCASTS
LEARNING AND EDUCATION
MOMENTUM MARKETS NETWORK
LINKS
STAY CONNECTED
Make your nest egg grow. Register now for nestegg updates.