Save
Contentious franking credit figures explained
Shadow treasurer Chris Bowen has provided context to his costings of Labor’s much-debated plans to reform the franking credits regime.
Contentious franking credit figures explained
Shadow treasurer Chris Bowen has provided context to his costings of Labor’s much-debated plans to reform the franking credits regime.
The question of cost
Labor announced over a year ago that it plans to scrap cash refunds on excess dividend imputation credits, with exceptions for pensioners.
The costings of the policy have been a heated source of debate. On several occasions, Mr Bowen has used the comparison of a nurse and a retired shareholder to highlight the inequitable scenario in a bid to sell the proposal to end cash refunds for excess dividend imputation credits.
“A nurse who earns $67,000 a year, we charge $13,000 in tax. But a retired shareholder who has $67,000 in income, we charge her zero tax and then write her a cheque for $27,000. That is not OK,” Mr Bowen said.
However, tax experts – like Robyn Jacobson from Tax Banter – have pulled apart these numbers and found they don't stack up.
“Assuming that the income of $67,000 to which Mr Bowen refers is the taxable income – that is, the shareholder has the same taxable income as the nurse – then this includes the dividend grossed up for the franking credit, suggesting that the dividend (actual cash received) is $40,000 and the franking credit (notional assessable income) is $27,000,” she said.
“However, this means that the franking rate applying to the dividend is just over 40 per cent, which is not possible under the imputation rules.”
Further, the refundable amount doesn't add up on the basis of these figures.
“The income tax the shareholder pays on the taxable income of $67,000 – before the franking credit is applied – is $14,132, including the Medicare levy and the LMITO of $530 (same as the nurse),” said Ms Jacobson.
“Then the franking credit of $27,000 is applied, which reduces the tax payable to zero and produces an excess franking credit of $12,868. The amount refunded to the shareholder is the excess franking credit of $12,868, not the entire amount of the $27,000 franking credit,” she said.
Clarity from Bowen
Mr Bowen has since released a new set of figures that clarify context.
According to Mr Bowen’s new figures, the refundable tax offset, representing the refundable franking credit, is $28,700, not $27,000, based on a grossed-up dividend of $95,667 (i.e. cash dividend of $66,967.90). Using a yield of 5 per cent, this is a capital base of $1,339,333.
In simple terms: the new figures stack up better, and experts like Ms Jacobson accept they are more on message than the original set.
Calls for calm
Big-name fund managers, like Don Hamson of Plato Asset Management, have called on Australian investors to keep calm in the face of this reform.
“Franking credits are still around, and most people can still use them,” he said.
“Most people will still get the benefit of franking credits, even ones that will lose a little bit will only be about 10 per cent,” he added.
Tax saving
What you need to know about the tax implications of crypto
One million Aussies are now invested in crypto, but many have not thought about how these investments will affect them at tax time. ...Read more
Tax saving
Welfare overhaul could give recipients a leg-up
Australia’s Centrelink recipients who’ve been doing it tough are in for a potentially easier time if the federal government pursues ambitious reforms that could provide sturdier safety nets. ...Read more
Tax saving
Students should think twice before tapping into their super
Former students might want to think carefully before they look to take advantage of the federal government’s biggest first home buyer incentive. ...Read more
Tax saving
Advocates call for an end to tax cuts
Social services sector advocates have warned that further tax cuts may make solving Australia’s biggest challenges much harder. ...Read more
Tax saving
ATO and AUSTRAC may gain new phone-tapping powers
A proposed update to electronic surveillance legislation could see the ATO armed with new powers that would allow the agency to bug phones and intercept online communications. ...Read more
Tax saving
Over 2m Aussies asked the TPB for help during the last year
As the economy recovers, Australia’s tax regulator says it’s planning to put unregistered practitioners under the microscope. ...Read more
Tax saving
Will you pay higher taxes due to bracket creep?
Bracket creep will see Australians paying more tax on average, unless further cuts are introduced in the future. ...Read more
Tax saving
10 ways to reduce your tax bill
With the tax return deadline only one month away, these tips could help minimise your tax bill. ...Read more
Wrapping up an eventful 2021
Listen now
What Omicron means for property, and are units right for first-time buyers? What is equity crowdfunding? Are industry super funds tapping into member funds to save their skins?
Listen now
Will housing affordability improve in 2022? Will buy now, pay later become the norm? Why are Aussies staying in failing super products?
Listen now
Who really benefits from crypto ETFs? How will the RBA respond to rising inflation? Could a mandate help address unpaid super?
Listen now
Tax saving
What you need to know about the tax implications of crypto
One million Aussies are now invested in crypto, but many have not thought about how these investments will affect them at tax time. ...Read more
Tax saving
Welfare overhaul could give recipients a leg-up
Australia’s Centrelink recipients who’ve been doing it tough are in for a potentially easier time if the federal government pursues ambitious reforms that could provide sturdier safety nets. ...Read more
Tax saving
Students should think twice before tapping into their super
Former students might want to think carefully before they look to take advantage of the federal government’s biggest first home buyer incentive. ...Read more
Tax saving
Advocates call for an end to tax cuts
Social services sector advocates have warned that further tax cuts may make solving Australia’s biggest challenges much harder. ...Read more
Tax saving
ATO and AUSTRAC may gain new phone-tapping powers
A proposed update to electronic surveillance legislation could see the ATO armed with new powers that would allow the agency to bug phones and intercept online communications. ...Read more
Tax saving
Over 2m Aussies asked the TPB for help during the last year
As the economy recovers, Australia’s tax regulator says it’s planning to put unregistered practitioners under the microscope. ...Read more
Tax saving
Will you pay higher taxes due to bracket creep?
Bracket creep will see Australians paying more tax on average, unless further cuts are introduced in the future. ...Read more
Tax saving
10 ways to reduce your tax bill
With the tax return deadline only one month away, these tips could help minimise your tax bill. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
