Invest
Why it's time to forget 'active versus passive'
The endless debate between indexing and active management is the investment community's version of the 'climate wars' being waged in politics, says QIC – and it is just as unproductive.
Why it's time to forget 'active versus passive'
The endless debate between indexing and active management is the investment community's version of the 'climate wars' being waged in politics, says QIC – and it is just as unproductive.
Australian institutional investment firm QIC has weighed into the perennial 'active versus passive debate' in investment circles, likening the argument to the 'climate wars' in federal politics.
QIC, a primarily active fund manager servicing super funds and other institutional investors, argued that active and passive strategies are complementary rather than "at logger-heads".
In a new paper titled Active management: skill, breadth and flexibility drives outperformance across investment cycles, QIC said investors should consider changing market conditions when selecting investment strategies.
The paper also pointed out that active investing is more about quality than quantity, and fixed income active management rewards good management by companies.

QIC director for research and strategy Katrina King said, "We are passionate advocates for active investing, but that doesn’t mean that we turn up our noses at passive investing."
"It does mean, though, that based on findings from decades of investment research, there is compelling evidence to support the proposition that markets go through periods of inefficiency where they vary from fundamental value.
"By doing so, they create opportunities for active investors to outperform benchmarks by intelligently exploiting desired risks and avoiding undesired ones," Ms King said.
Stock market
Russell rebalance reshapes investment landscape amid SpaceX IPO buzz
As the world eagerly anticipates SpaceX's historic initial public offering today, a significant shift is quietly occurring in the financial markets, one that could have profound implications for both ...Read more
Stock market
Franklin Templeton expands active ETF suite with new global equity and income strategies
In a strategic move to broaden its investment offerings, Franklin Templeton has announced the launch of two new active exchange-traded funds (ETFs) on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX)Read more
Stock market
ASX companies make strides amidst federal budget chatter
In a week dominated by discussions surrounding the recently released FY27 federal budget, the financial landscape witnessed significant activity, particularly among ASX-listed companiesRead more
Stock market
ASX small caps report mixed results amid market optimism
The latest flurry of quarterly activities reports from ASX-listed small cap companies has provided a snapshot of the diverse and dynamic landscape of Australia's financial market. As April came to a ...Read more
Stock market
Adisyn Limited and Brazilian Critical Minerals make significant strides in their respective sectors
In a landscape where Australia's Information Technology sector often plays second fiddle to global giants, Adisyn Limited (ASX: AI1) is making waves with its innovative advancements in graphene ...Read more
Stock market
Australia's ASX 200 Energy Index surges amid Iran conflict
Australia's ASX 200 Energy Index has surged nearly 20% since the onset of the Iran conflict, marking its highest level in three months. This development positions Australia as the only developed ...Read more
Stock market
Webull launches Webull Connect, revolutionising access for Australian financial advisers
In a significant move that marks its entry into the Australian wealth management sector, Webull Securities (Australia) Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of the Nasdaq-listed Webull Corporation, has unveiled its ...Read more
Stock market
Future Generation Global boosts dividends with special payout, marking significant yield increase
Future Generation Global (ASX: FGG) has announced a significant boost to its dividend offerings for the year 2025, delighting shareholders with an increased fully franked full-year dividend and an ...Read more
Stock market
Russell rebalance reshapes investment landscape amid SpaceX IPO buzz
As the world eagerly anticipates SpaceX's historic initial public offering today, a significant shift is quietly occurring in the financial markets, one that could have profound implications for both ...Read more
Stock market
Franklin Templeton expands active ETF suite with new global equity and income strategies
In a strategic move to broaden its investment offerings, Franklin Templeton has announced the launch of two new active exchange-traded funds (ETFs) on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX)Read more
Stock market
ASX companies make strides amidst federal budget chatter
In a week dominated by discussions surrounding the recently released FY27 federal budget, the financial landscape witnessed significant activity, particularly among ASX-listed companiesRead more
Stock market
ASX small caps report mixed results amid market optimism
The latest flurry of quarterly activities reports from ASX-listed small cap companies has provided a snapshot of the diverse and dynamic landscape of Australia's financial market. As April came to a ...Read more
Stock market
Adisyn Limited and Brazilian Critical Minerals make significant strides in their respective sectors
In a landscape where Australia's Information Technology sector often plays second fiddle to global giants, Adisyn Limited (ASX: AI1) is making waves with its innovative advancements in graphene ...Read more
Stock market
Australia's ASX 200 Energy Index surges amid Iran conflict
Australia's ASX 200 Energy Index has surged nearly 20% since the onset of the Iran conflict, marking its highest level in three months. This development positions Australia as the only developed ...Read more
Stock market
Webull launches Webull Connect, revolutionising access for Australian financial advisers
In a significant move that marks its entry into the Australian wealth management sector, Webull Securities (Australia) Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of the Nasdaq-listed Webull Corporation, has unveiled its ...Read more
Stock market
Future Generation Global boosts dividends with special payout, marking significant yield increase
Future Generation Global (ASX: FGG) has announced a significant boost to its dividend offerings for the year 2025, delighting shareholders with an increased fully franked full-year dividend and an ...Read more