Invest
Is Morrison’s stimulus package just jobs for the boys?
The COVID-19 economic impact has hit women harder than men, yet men are the ones who will benefit most from Scott Morrison’s home renovation package, according to new research.
Is Morrison’s stimulus package just jobs for the boys?
The COVID-19 economic impact has hit women harder than men, yet men are the ones who will benefit most from Scott Morrison’s home renovation package, according to new research.
Research collated by the Australian Institute shows women have disproportionately lost their jobs and hours of work in the recession, yet the government’s latest package will be of little benefit to them.
“Between March and April, the number of women employed fell 5.3 per cent compared with 3.9 per cent for men. And for hours worked, the pattern was the same, with women losing 11.5 percent of their hours compared with the loss by men of 7.5 percent. It is clear that women are facing the brunt of the recession so far,” said Dr Richard Denniss, chief economist at The Australia Institute.
“But despite the clear evidence that women are disproportionately losing their jobs and incomes, the Morrison government is developing stimulus policies that disproportionately favour male-dominated industries.”
The Australia Institute has found that every $1 million spent on education creates 10.6 jobs for women, while every $1 million spent on construction creates only 0.2 jobs for women.
“If the government is serious about maximising the number of jobs it creates, then it needs to focus its stimulus spending on industries like education, health and tourism,” Mr Dennis noted.
In 2019, around 1.15 million Australians worked in the construction industry, which according to government data is about 9 per cent of the workforce.
The government also states that the construction industry generates $360 billion in revenue, producing around 9 per cent of Australia’s gross domestic product.
However, Mr Denniss argued that while it has benefits to the national economy, a better designed policy would’ve been fairer for both males and females.
“While the construction industry has a clear role to play in Australia’s economic recovery, spending taxpayer money on construction will do little to create jobs for the hundreds of thousands of women who have lost their jobs in the services sector.”
“Well-designed stimulus policy aims to create as many jobs as possible per million dollars spent, and it also aims to create jobs for people with the skills to work in the industries who have recently become unemployed,” he said.
Mr Denniss also states that the economic stimulus could target other areas, resulting in greater overall impact for unemployed people.
“The Prime Minister seems to like wearing a hard hat when he talks about job creation, but like the Prime Minister himself, the vast majority of Australians don’t wear hard hats to work each day. Australian policymakers need to focus our stimulus spending on the industries that create a lot of jobs, not the industries that look best in the background of a press conference,” he concluded.
Did you enjoy this article? You may also be interested in:
- JobKeeper savings could fund new home building stimulus
- Job losses worse since the great depression despite government stimulus
- 6 ways Australia can rebuild beyond the recession
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Economy
Inflation concerns grow as consumer price index rises, prompting potential interest rate hikes
The latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) data has sparked fresh concerns about inflation in Australia, with experts suggesting that further interest rate hikes may be on the horizon. The CPI, a key ...Read more
Economy
State Street economist comments on latest labour force data amid market anticipation
The latest labour force data, released today, has prompted a measured response from financial experts, with insights provided by Krishna Bhimavarapu, APAC Economist at State Street Investment ...Read more
Economy
RBA's interest rate hike impacts Australian employment landscape
The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has decided to increase interest rates by 25 basis points, raising the cash rate to 3.85%. This move, aimed at controlling inflation, has elicited responses from ...Read more
Economy
RBA’s latest rate hike sparks debate over economic impact
In a surprising move, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has increased the cash rate, signalling a significant shift in its monetary policy approach. This decision comes amid a backdrop of unexpected ...Read more
Economy
When inflation reopens the rate door: A broker-sector case study in defending margins, clients and share
Australia’s latest trimmed-mean inflation reading at 3.3% has revived the prospect of another Reserve Bank move and put lenders, brokers and borrowers back on a tightening footing. This case study ...Read more
Economy
Inflation rise dampens hopes for interest rate cuts as employment dynamics shift
In a development that has dashed hopes for an interest rate cut, Australia's Consumer Price Index (CPI) has surged back to 3.8%, erasing the progress made since October. This unexpected rise in ...Read more
Economy
Inflation surge poses challenges for small businesses and consumers
The latest inflation figures have sparked concern among Australian businesses and consumers alike, with the rising costs expected to influence the Reserve Bank of Australia's (RBA) upcoming interest ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Inflation concerns grow as consumer price index rises, prompting potential interest rate hikes
The latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) data has sparked fresh concerns about inflation in Australia, with experts suggesting that further interest rate hikes may be on the horizon. The CPI, a key ...Read more
Economy
State Street economist comments on latest labour force data amid market anticipation
The latest labour force data, released today, has prompted a measured response from financial experts, with insights provided by Krishna Bhimavarapu, APAC Economist at State Street Investment ...Read more
Economy
RBA's interest rate hike impacts Australian employment landscape
The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has decided to increase interest rates by 25 basis points, raising the cash rate to 3.85%. This move, aimed at controlling inflation, has elicited responses from ...Read more
Economy
RBA’s latest rate hike sparks debate over economic impact
In a surprising move, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has increased the cash rate, signalling a significant shift in its monetary policy approach. This decision comes amid a backdrop of unexpected ...Read more
Economy
When inflation reopens the rate door: A broker-sector case study in defending margins, clients and share
Australia’s latest trimmed-mean inflation reading at 3.3% has revived the prospect of another Reserve Bank move and put lenders, brokers and borrowers back on a tightening footing. This case study ...Read more
Economy
Inflation rise dampens hopes for interest rate cuts as employment dynamics shift
In a development that has dashed hopes for an interest rate cut, Australia's Consumer Price Index (CPI) has surged back to 3.8%, erasing the progress made since October. This unexpected rise in ...Read more
Economy
Inflation surge poses challenges for small businesses and consumers
The latest inflation figures have sparked concern among Australian businesses and consumers alike, with the rising costs expected to influence the Reserve Bank of Australia's (RBA) upcoming interest ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
