Invest
IGR criticised for failing to factor in capital gains
Concerns over future spending raised by the government’s recent intergenerational reports fail to scrutinise the growth and distribution of Australia’s overall wealth, experts say.
IGR criticised for failing to factor in capital gains
Concerns over future spending raised by the government’s recent intergenerational reports fail to scrutinise the growth and distribution of Australia’s overall wealth, experts say.
A new report by The Australia Institute has criticised the government’s latest intergenerational report, arguing that it overlooks the impact that capital gains will have on the wealth of Australians over time.
“It seemed bizarre that the government could talk about such things as fiscal ‘burdens’ and the call on taxpayers without mentioning $1.7 trillion in capital gains and, more importantly, who received that $1.7 trillion,” the report said.
Since the majority of wealth in Australia is currently held by those over the age of 55, David Richardson, senior research fellow at The Australia Institute, argued that it is older Australians who will benefit the most.
“In the coming decades, not only is the wealth of Australians likely to grow rapidly, but that wealth will almost certainly flow primarily to those aged over 55,” he said.
Mr Richardson admitted that rapid increases in wealth, like the ones Australia is expected to have over the next decade, are “a good problem to have”, but he warned that unless we reform our tax system, wealth generation is likely to have significant side effects.
“The benefits of growing wealth will come with significant costs in the form of inequality and economic inefficiency,” he warned.
Mr Richardson said that because Australia currently lacks in wealth taxes and collects relatively little from capital gains, government revenues have failed to keep up with the growing wealth of Australians.
As this dynamic continues, he foretold of the “enormous problems associated” with unequal distribution of higher and higher wealth holdings.
Mr Richardson said it was remarkable that the last five intergenerational reports produced by the Treasury had failed to examine or consider the rate of wealth growth in Australia and how it is distributed.
“How can you ask about intergenerational equity without considering wealth and the way it is, or isn’t, taxed?” the report said.
Mr Richardson argued that GDP alone is not a good measure of Australia’s capacity to pay for government services, and that including capital gains in income measures quickly “dispels” any concern about future fiscal burdens.
The report said that by 2060, the federal government’s current self-imposed spending cap of 23.9 per cent of GDP might be as low as 10.4 per cent once capital gains are factored in.
“The Australian government may keep choosing not to tax wealth and capital gains of our wealthiest people as thoroughly as it taxes the incomes of ordinary workers. However, such choices make it hard to argue that Australia ‘can’t afford’ to provide healthcare in the years to come to what will clearly be the wealthiest generation Australia has ever known,” he said.
RELATED ARTICLES
-
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
-
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
-
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
About the author
About the author
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
Headline inflation easing is good optics; balance sheets feel something different. With year‑on‑year CPI down to 3.4% in November from 3.8%, hopes for rate relief are rising — but policymakers remain ...Read more
Economy
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
Australia’s headline CPI edged down to 3.4% year-on-year in November, from 3.8%, easing immediate pressure but not eliminating the risk of further tightening. With services inflation sticky and ...Read more
Economy
Higher-for-longer, not higher forever: How Australia’s inflation ‘surprise’ is rewriting CFO playbooks for 2026
Australia’s latest inflation pulse eased but didn’t budge bank outlooks: near‑term rate cuts are still a long shot, with some houses flagging upside risk. That steadier‑for‑longer cash rate is pushing ...Read more
Economy
Australia's inflation illusion: the real challenge lies in pricing power and productivity
Headline inflation has cooled to 3.4% year-on-year, but the Reserve Bank’s caution—and a still‑hot housing backdrop—mean the rate threat hasn’t left the room. For boards, the next few quarters are ...Read more
Economy
When house prices lift, tills ring: A case study in turning Australia’s wealth effect into growth
Australia’s latest upswing in household wealth, anchored by higher dwelling values, is more than a feel‑good statistic—it is a profit and planning signal. The ABS notes property’s centrality to ...Read more
Economy
RBA's hawkish stance reflects inflation concerns, State Street economist comments
In a recent statement, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has signaled a hawkish stance on interest rates, drawing insights from financial experts about the implications for Australia's economic ...Read more
Economy
Navigating the inflation maze: How CFOs can outsmart economic hurdles in Australia
Fresh inflation data have cooled expectations of near-term rate cuts in Australia, intensifying pressure on margins, capital allocation and demand. Rather than wait for monetary relief that may not ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
Headline inflation easing is good optics; balance sheets feel something different. With year‑on‑year CPI down to 3.4% in November from 3.8%, hopes for rate relief are rising — but policymakers remain ...Read more
Economy
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
Australia’s headline CPI edged down to 3.4% year-on-year in November, from 3.8%, easing immediate pressure but not eliminating the risk of further tightening. With services inflation sticky and ...Read more
Economy
Higher-for-longer, not higher forever: How Australia’s inflation ‘surprise’ is rewriting CFO playbooks for 2026
Australia’s latest inflation pulse eased but didn’t budge bank outlooks: near‑term rate cuts are still a long shot, with some houses flagging upside risk. That steadier‑for‑longer cash rate is pushing ...Read more
Economy
Australia's inflation illusion: the real challenge lies in pricing power and productivity
Headline inflation has cooled to 3.4% year-on-year, but the Reserve Bank’s caution—and a still‑hot housing backdrop—mean the rate threat hasn’t left the room. For boards, the next few quarters are ...Read more
Economy
When house prices lift, tills ring: A case study in turning Australia’s wealth effect into growth
Australia’s latest upswing in household wealth, anchored by higher dwelling values, is more than a feel‑good statistic—it is a profit and planning signal. The ABS notes property’s centrality to ...Read more
Economy
RBA's hawkish stance reflects inflation concerns, State Street economist comments
In a recent statement, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has signaled a hawkish stance on interest rates, drawing insights from financial experts about the implications for Australia's economic ...Read more
Economy
Navigating the inflation maze: How CFOs can outsmart economic hurdles in Australia
Fresh inflation data have cooled expectations of near-term rate cuts in Australia, intensifying pressure on margins, capital allocation and demand. Rather than wait for monetary relief that may not ...Read more
