Invest
Does the RBA boast the right credentials to steer the economy?
With the Reserve Bank of Australia likely to face its first independent review in 40 years, experts believe this could be a chance to bridge the gap between monetary and fiscal policy, but also to boost the bank’s monetary policy credentials.
Does the RBA boast the right credentials to steer the economy?
With the Reserve Bank of Australia likely to face its first independent review in 40 years, experts believe this could be a chance to bridge the gap between monetary and fiscal policy, but also to boost the bank’s monetary policy credentials.
Last week, international think tank Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) called for a review into the RBA, noting its failure to meet key economic targets in recent years.
Just hours later, Treasurer Josh Frydenberg backed the OECD, noting he was open to a review, but one that would likely have to take place post-election.
“That is a real issue, and it’s something I will give consideration to in terms of looking at the RBA, looking at the monetary policy setting, and learning from the experience of this pandemic,” Mr Frydenberg told Sky News.
Commenting on the developments, economic policy program director at Grattan Institute Brendan Coates said there are several reasons warranting a review, including some of the more prominent central bank failures.
“Firstly, they probably haven’t done as well as they should have in the last few years, there are always benefits in hindsight, but an objective assessment of the Reserve Bank in the last few years is that it really hasn’t lived up to its objectives, it hasn’t met its targets,” Mr Coates said.
The most important target the RBA has failed to meet is inflation, essentially resulting in a decade of lost wages growth.
“Consistently low inflation basically means the economy is not running as hot as it could,” he said.
Noting that a review does not necessarily spell doom, Mr Coates highlighted the opportunities for change, including a good look at the bank’s governance structure and at the divide separating fiscal and monetary policy.
“The Reserve Bank board is an outlier. It has mainly been composed of business people who do not have a lot of expertise in monetary policy. That is actually very rare globally. Most central boards are made up of people who know monetary policy really well,” Mr Coates said.
Beyond the board, Mr Coates also sees challenges with the tool the RBA uses to manage the economy: interest rates.
“It raises the question, do central banks have the tools to manage the economy?” he said.
“That leads to questions about what role does fiscal policy play. Do we keep the independence between monetary and fiscal policy during this period?”
Noting that he does not necessarily want to see more government oversight of the RBA, what could be explored is means to allow fiscal policy to act more like monetary policy.
“Could you use more automatic stabilisers in the budget? Should the rate of unemployment benefits vary based on the state of unemployment in the economy?” he said.
The answers, Mr Coates hinted, could, in fact, lie in breaking the separation between fiscal and monetary policy, especially in times of crisis.
About the author
About the author
Economy
Growing optimism as lockdowns wind down and the NSW economy revs up
Consumer confidence has gone up for the sixth week in a row. ...Read more
Economy
Hiring practices are only the start for businesses looking to build diversity
The hiring process is becoming more diverse, but many Australian businesses remain mixed on internal inclusion efforts. ...Read more
Economy
NSW residents to receive $50 ‘stay and rediscover’ voucher
NSW residents will receive a $50 accommodation voucher to spend on accommodation anywhere in the state as the NSW government moves towards kick-starting the economy back into gear. ...Read more
Economy
Barbers weren’t the only big winners as NSW leaves lockdown
NSW’s hairdressers, luggage stores and massage parlours are said to be the biggest beneficiaries of pent-up demand so far. ...Read more
Economy
What do ‘inevitable’ cyber threats mean for investors and consumers?
Saying a major cyber attack on Australia’s financial system will happen is easy, but calculating the costs is hard. ...Read more
Economy
NSW to commence quarantine-free international travel on 1 November
New South Wales will open its gates to the world on 1 November. ...Read more
Economy
‘Skilled migrants are key for future economic growth’: Frydenberg
Projections about the size of the Australian economy are set to be redrafted, with the country now very unlikely to meet population growth targets tailored prior to the pandemic. ...Read more
Economy
Jobless rate rises to 4.6%
Employment fell by 138,000 during September following large drops in Victoria and NSW. ...Read more
How the post-lockdown period will influence property, what the soaring NFT market means, and defining financial wellness
Listen now
APRA’s mortgage crackdown, the power of DeFi and last-minute tax tips
Listen now
What to expect as the end of lockdown looms? Will the Stage 2 tax cuts boost your tax return? Where should investors be looking as the economy reopens?
Listen now
Could property prices inflate by another 20%? What’s happening in recent dividend announcements? Did your fund fail the YFYS test?
Listen now
RBA says BNPL 'no surcharge' rules distort competition
Read more
Australia’s banks may be more vulnerable to cyber attacks than you think
Read more
Investors are more open to net zero but less savvy on the risks
Read more
The more time I spend looking at my money, the further I feel from financial freedom
Read more
Economy
Growing optimism as lockdowns wind down and the NSW economy revs up
Consumer confidence has gone up for the sixth week in a row. ...Read more
Economy
Hiring practices are only the start for businesses looking to build diversity
The hiring process is becoming more diverse, but many Australian businesses remain mixed on internal inclusion efforts. ...Read more
Economy
NSW residents to receive $50 ‘stay and rediscover’ voucher
NSW residents will receive a $50 accommodation voucher to spend on accommodation anywhere in the state as the NSW government moves towards kick-starting the economy back into gear. ...Read more
Economy
Barbers weren’t the only big winners as NSW leaves lockdown
NSW’s hairdressers, luggage stores and massage parlours are said to be the biggest beneficiaries of pent-up demand so far. ...Read more
Economy
What do ‘inevitable’ cyber threats mean for investors and consumers?
Saying a major cyber attack on Australia’s financial system will happen is easy, but calculating the costs is hard. ...Read more
Economy
NSW to commence quarantine-free international travel on 1 November
New South Wales will open its gates to the world on 1 November. ...Read more
Economy
‘Skilled migrants are key for future economic growth’: Frydenberg
Projections about the size of the Australian economy are set to be redrafted, with the country now very unlikely to meet population growth targets tailored prior to the pandemic. ...Read more
Economy
Jobless rate rises to 4.6%
Employment fell by 138,000 during September following large drops in Victoria and NSW. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
