subscribe to our newsletter sign up

Early access to super could ‘erode’ asset base

Cash, money, dollars

Allowing early access to superannuation benefits could result in unhappy consequences and lead to future disadvantage for funds’ members, a technical expert has warned.

In light of the government’s consultation on the rules governing the early release of superannuation, NAB director of SMSF and investor behaviour Gemma Dale said that allowing the early release of superannuation for a wider range of circumstances could mean that individuals are disadvantaged in the future.

“The sole purpose test is there to provide for your retirement and so the early access restrictions were originally designed to support you in a scenario where you probably wouldn’t make it to retirement if you didn’t get early access to your super, such as life threatening conditions for example,” she explained.

“I think broadening the range of conditions or circumstances under which funds can be accesses does have the potential to erode that asset base and therefore while you help someone now, they may be circumstantially disadvantaged in the future, and maybe we need to look at alternatives for that.”

Ms Dale said she has seen examples under the current early access rules where individuals have accessed their superannuation and have been left in a worse position because of the ongoing nature of their condition. She also acknowledged the sensitivity and complexities associated with creating legislation that deals with mental health, and the importance of getting it right.

“I spoke to a man who withdrew his superannuation to pay for rehabilitation for his alcoholism, but he didn’t complete the rehabilitation program, and has continued to have a patchy relationship with alcohol since,” she said.

The man who is now in his mid to late 40s now has no superannuation, she said.

“So it didn't have the desired outcome in that it has not resolved the health issue that he had and he now has no superannuation to provide for his retirement, and his health is not going to allow him to work well into his 60s,” she said.

“So I appreciate the difficulty for government in trying to legislate for scenarios like this – it's really hard.”

Early access to super could ‘erode’ asset base
nestegg logo
Promoted Content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Anonymous - If the elder abuse is mainly perpetrated by the victim's own children, isn't the answer to educate and foster greater love and respect by children for their own parents?....
Brian Hor - One issue for which an SMSF will always be preferred over any APRA regulated fund large or small is estate planning, especially for modern blended.......
Dan Hadley - Hi David, Thank you for your comments and feedback. I agree that a more simplified system is warranted but often simple can mean misunderstood or open.......
David Porter - Everyone should pay tax.
Nobody wants to pay tax.
I know I dont want to pay but understand why I should.
What I want is for goverments everywhere to.......