Save
Taxpayer loses out to ATO in ‘awkward’ court case
A recent court case indicates the ATO may not be held to their communications if they were made in error, leaving taxpayers in an “awkward” position.
Taxpayer loses out to ATO in ‘awkward’ court case
A recent court case indicates the ATO may not be held to their communications if they were made in error, leaving taxpayers in an “awkward” position.
The High Court has refused a taxpayer’s application for special leave to appeal against the decision of a full bench of the Federal Court in Pintarich v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation.
The Federal Court’s ruling found that Mr Pintarich was liable for the entire amount of general interest charge (GIC) on income tax, despite an error in communication from a letter from the deputy commissioner stating that he was not.
The letter, issued under the signature block of the first deputy commissioner, purported to remit all GIC payable by the taxpayer except for a relatively small amount.
“Thank you for your promise to pay your outstanding account. We agree to accept a lump sum payment of $839,115.43 on or by 30 January 2015,” said the ATO. “This payout figure is inclusive of an estimated GIC amount calculated to 30 January 2015.”
Mr Pintarich then made the full payment by the due date but was later advised in a subsequent letter on 18 August 2015 that the amount paid did not include the entire amount of GIC accrued.
“We wish to advise you that the letter issued by the deputy commissioner of taxation dated 8 December 2014 titled ‘Payment Arrangement for your Income Tax Account Debt’ was issued in error. The outstanding amount of $839,115.43 in the letter did not include the entire amount of GIC, which had accrued on the entire amount of outstanding debt up to and including 8 December 2014,” the ATO letter said.
The court found that the error was made due to information input into a computer-based “template bulk issue letter” by an ATO officer, and that no decision had been made because there was no “mental process” of reaching a conclusion.
What does this mean for taxpayers?
The Tax Institute’s senior tax counsel, Professor Robert Deutsch, believes taxpayers will need to “tread carefully” with future offers of settlement, considering the number of automated letters issued by the ATO on a daily basis.
“My view is that the Tax Office should stick by their own unequivocal unambiguous offers of settlement and if it turns out that is an error, which clearly was the case here, they have to live by it,” said Professor Deutsch.
“In reverse, I’m hypothesising here, but if a taxpayer puts forward an unequivocal offer to pay an amount which the Tax Office then accepted, I’d be very surprised if the taxpayer was allowed to go back and say, ‘that was a mistake, my secretary sent that and I didn’t mean it’.”
Tax saving
South Australians now eligible for COVID-19 Disaster Payment
South Australians under lockdown are set to be supported by the COVID-19 Disaster Payment, the state government has confirmed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Broken tax system costs economy $50bn
Australia’s tax laws are costing the nation about $50 billion in compliance costs, while inefficient taxes are slowing down economic growth, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
Tax saving
Australia signs on for global trade floor
Australia is set to gain up to $3 billion in additional tax revenue after agreeing with world leaders to sign on to new rules as to where profits for multinationals should be taxed as well as a new mi...Read more
Tax saving
Aussies warned of overconfidence ahead of EOFY
Two-thirds of Australians are confident about grappling with the tax implications of the pandemic. Maybe too confident. ...Read more
Tax saving
Why investors could unknowingly be heading towards a CGT minefield
The calculation of a capital gain (or loss) should be simple. Unfortunately, it’s becoming more and more complicated, not because the information required to calculate the gain (or loss) has changed...Read more
Tax saving
How are Australians planning on spending their tax savings?
Essential bills, savings accounts, Christmas gifts and exchange-traded funds appear to be the big winners from the latest round of tax cuts, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Tax saving
First in the world: SA imposes EV tax
The South Australian government is the first government in the world to introduce an electronic vehicles tax following an announcement by the treasury. ...Read more
Tax saving
5 tips as tax deadline looms
Australians are being warned that they have just two weeks left to get their finances in order if they have not posted a tax return yet. ...Read more
The Olympic effect on property and equity investors; COVID-19 Disaster Payments and super
Listen now
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Tax saving
South Australians now eligible for COVID-19 Disaster Payment
South Australians under lockdown are set to be supported by the COVID-19 Disaster Payment, the state government has confirmed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Broken tax system costs economy $50bn
Australia’s tax laws are costing the nation about $50 billion in compliance costs, while inefficient taxes are slowing down economic growth, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
Tax saving
Australia signs on for global trade floor
Australia is set to gain up to $3 billion in additional tax revenue after agreeing with world leaders to sign on to new rules as to where profits for multinationals should be taxed as well as a new mi...Read more
Tax saving
Aussies warned of overconfidence ahead of EOFY
Two-thirds of Australians are confident about grappling with the tax implications of the pandemic. Maybe too confident. ...Read more
Tax saving
Why investors could unknowingly be heading towards a CGT minefield
The calculation of a capital gain (or loss) should be simple. Unfortunately, it’s becoming more and more complicated, not because the information required to calculate the gain (or loss) has changed...Read more
Tax saving
How are Australians planning on spending their tax savings?
Essential bills, savings accounts, Christmas gifts and exchange-traded funds appear to be the big winners from the latest round of tax cuts, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Tax saving
First in the world: SA imposes EV tax
The South Australian government is the first government in the world to introduce an electronic vehicles tax following an announcement by the treasury. ...Read more
Tax saving
5 tips as tax deadline looms
Australians are being warned that they have just two weeks left to get their finances in order if they have not posted a tax return yet. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
