Retirement
Could the Super Home Buyer Scheme ‘torpedo’ Aussie super savings?
Industry Super Australia has argued that the scheme would force funds to hold more cash.
Could the Super Home Buyer Scheme ‘torpedo’ Aussie super savings?
Industry Super Australia has argued that the scheme would force funds to hold more cash.
New modelling from Industry Super Australia has suggested that the Coalition’s proposed Super Home Buyer Scheme would increase the liquidity requirements of super funds and subsequently lead to lower returns.
ISA argued that the scheme would force funds to hold more cash and invertedly invest less in long-term growth-oriented assets.
“Even those Australians that don’t use their super to buy a house will be left tens of thousands of dollars worse off because of the government’s scheme,” said ISA chief executive Bernie Dean.
“Not only will throwing super into the housing market jack up prices and make houses less affordable, but all Australian workers will also be worse off because of lower investment returns.”
During the Liberal Party’s campaign launch last Sunday, Prime Minister Scott Morrison pointed out that New Zealand and a number of other countries already have policies in place that allow people to use their retirement savings to help them buy their first home.
However, analysis by ISA suggested that a balanced option under New Zealand’s retirement savings scheme, KiwiSaver, delivered returns roughly 1 per cent per annum lower than a balanced MySuper fund over both five and 10 years.
Additionally, the KiwiSaver balanced option held about 13.5 per cent less in growth assets than its Australian counterpart.
AMP Capital chief economist Shane Oliver told InvestorDaily that, while the Super Home Buyer Scheme may inflict a short-term impact, the money withdrawn would likely be balanced by funds deposited back into the super system once a sale is made.
The scheme allows first home buyers to withdraw 40 per cent of their super up to a maximum of $50,000 to put towards the purchase of a first home, but the buyer is obliged to return the money, including any associated capital gains, when that home is sold.
As such, Dr Oliver estimated that liquidity issues could potentially persist for up to eight years before money starts flowing back in.
“I suspect it will even out over time because, if someone buys a property and accesses their super when they’re 30, and then they want to trade over and get a bigger property 10 years later, then the money will come back in,” Dr Oliver said.
He also noted that it was difficult to estimate the full impact of the scheme because it was unclear how many people would actually end up taking advantage of it.
The scheme received a mixed response from industry stakeholders upon its announcement, with opponents arguing that it undermined the purpose of the super system and would lead to higher house prices.
RELATED ARTICLES
Superannuation
Aware Super elevates tech leadership with strategic appointment of Richard Exton
Aware Super, one of Australia's largest industry super funds, has announced a pivotal appointment to its executive team, underscoring the growing importance of technology, data, and artificial ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest appoints Marina Pasika as interim head of private markets
Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has announced the appointment of Marina Pasika as the Interim Head of Private Markets. This decision comes as the fund embarks ...Read more
Superannuation
Payday Super bill introduces new challenges for SMBs, reveals Employment Hero CEO
The introduction of the Payday Super bill to the Australian Parliament has sparked a significant response from the business community, particularly among small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs)Read more
Superannuation
Rest urges Parliament to expedite payday super legislation
In a significant move towards enhancing retirement outcomes for Australian workers, Rest, one of the country's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has expressed strong support for the ...Read more
Superannuation
Recalibrated super performance test aims to enhance accountability and investment opportunities
In a move that signals a shift rather than a cessation, Australia's government has announced a targeted review of the superannuation performance test. This recalibration, prompted by the latest ...Read more
Superannuation
Super performance test faces a fork balancing member value productive investment and regulatory trust
APRA’s latest superannuation performance test results have reignited a high‑stakes debate: does the test optimise member value or unintentionally curb long‑term investment in housing, infrastructure ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super unveils innovative digital tool to boost retirees' financial confidence
Aware Super has unveiled a groundbreaking digital advice tool, Retirement Manager, designed to empower retirees by addressing their most pressing financial concerns. Developed in collaboration with ...Read more
Superannuation
APRA's super shake-up: Balancing accountability and innovation in the next round
Australia’s performance test has forced long-overdue transparency in super and accelerated consolidation. But as the regime broadens, its blunt edges are colliding with investment complexity, ESG ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super elevates tech leadership with strategic appointment of Richard Exton
Aware Super, one of Australia's largest industry super funds, has announced a pivotal appointment to its executive team, underscoring the growing importance of technology, data, and artificial ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest appoints Marina Pasika as interim head of private markets
Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has announced the appointment of Marina Pasika as the Interim Head of Private Markets. This decision comes as the fund embarks ...Read more
Superannuation
Payday Super bill introduces new challenges for SMBs, reveals Employment Hero CEO
The introduction of the Payday Super bill to the Australian Parliament has sparked a significant response from the business community, particularly among small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs)Read more
Superannuation
Rest urges Parliament to expedite payday super legislation
In a significant move towards enhancing retirement outcomes for Australian workers, Rest, one of the country's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has expressed strong support for the ...Read more
Superannuation
Recalibrated super performance test aims to enhance accountability and investment opportunities
In a move that signals a shift rather than a cessation, Australia's government has announced a targeted review of the superannuation performance test. This recalibration, prompted by the latest ...Read more
Superannuation
Super performance test faces a fork balancing member value productive investment and regulatory trust
APRA’s latest superannuation performance test results have reignited a high‑stakes debate: does the test optimise member value or unintentionally curb long‑term investment in housing, infrastructure ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super unveils innovative digital tool to boost retirees' financial confidence
Aware Super has unveiled a groundbreaking digital advice tool, Retirement Manager, designed to empower retirees by addressing their most pressing financial concerns. Developed in collaboration with ...Read more
Superannuation
APRA's super shake-up: Balancing accountability and innovation in the next round
Australia’s performance test has forced long-overdue transparency in super and accelerated consolidation. But as the regime broadens, its blunt edges are colliding with investment complexity, ESG ...Read more
