Retirement
Is the government misleading consumers when it comes to retirement?
Industry Super Australia has accused the Morrison government of misleading consumers when it comes to financial outcomes in retirement.
Is the government misleading consumers when it comes to retirement?
Industry Super Australia has accused the Morrison government of misleading consumers when it comes to financial outcomes in retirement.
As part of the Retirement Income Covenant starting from 1 July 2022, the government is seeking to further develop the retirement outcomes in Australia’s superannuation framework and address the findings of the Retirement Income Review.
As part of this move, it has asked super funds to develop a strategy to make it easier for members to take money out of their super in retirement.
Drawing on research released during the Retirement Income Review, the Morrison government’s Retirement Income Covenant paper highlighted that $1 in every $3 in the super system will be passed down to the next generation by 2060.
“This raises the question as to whether the answer to lifting the retirement incomes of Australians is more superannuation savings or better guidance about how to maximise their superannuation savings during their retirement,” Treasurer Josh Frydenberg previously said.
As such, the paper argues that retirees should be encouraged to spend their superannuation instead of handing down a large portion of their nest egg to their families.
However, the Industry Super Australia (ISA) has come out swinging, questioning the government’s maths and arguing that most retirees outlive their super.
“Using HILDA data [Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia] show that 80 per cent of people aged 60 and over and 90 per cent of people aged 80 and over who died in the period 2014 to 2018 had no super at all in the period of up to four years before death,” the ISA said in its submission to government.
Dispelling the government’s concerns about older Australians building up large super balances, the group stated that of those currently aged 80 and above, only 5 per cent have a balance of $110,000 or more in their superannuation.
In a separate submission, the ASFA drew attention to data from the Australian Taxation Office, which revealed that around 1.7 million Australians aged 70 and over have no superannuation, or in other words, over 60 per cent of those aged 70 and over have no super.
There’s not a one-size-fits-all approach to retirement
In a nutshell, the government believes retirees have too much super, while industry funds claim they don’t have enough.
Adding to the debate, Super Consumers Australia believes current retirement targets are out of reach for typical Aussies, leaving them disengaged with their super.
As such, director Xavier O’Halloran has urged the government to acknowledge the different retirement strategies Australians need.
According to Super Consumers, Australians fall into one of three distinct cohorts of retirement thinkers – engaged delegates (25 per cent), engaged DIY (37 per cent) and the disengaged (38 per cent).
With each group said to be practicing a different approach to their retirement, Mr O’Halloran concluded that Aussies need more specific support.
“We do a lot more to support people during their working lives to find the best products for their super with
quality filters and comparable independent guidance about the quality of products. We need to give the same assistance to people planning for retirement,” he added.
The ISA agreed, highlighting the importance of strong financial default products for members with lower engagement.
“It has long been ISA’s position that in a compulsory superannuation system with poor financial literacy, most members should be able to rely on default settings that protect their interests without recourse to personal advice,” they state.
‘Self-interested voices in this debate’
According to Super Consumers Australia’s submission, self-interested voices are driving the debate instead of focusing on what is best for retirees.
“At the moment, we’re seeing people switch off due to fear when confronted by unrealistic and frankly unnecessary retirement savings targets,” Mr O’Halloran said.
“There are some self-interested voices in this debate quoting the need for a million dollars in savings. It makes an attractive headline, but this isn’t what the majority of Australians who are just looking to maintain their standard of living in retirement need to hear.”
About the author
About the author
Retirement Planning
Australia ranks 7th on global retirement index
Australia occupies the seventh place on the Natixis Global Retirement Index, behind Switzerland, Norway, Ireland, the Netherlands and New Zealand. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
What is an annuity and how does it work?
Having enough income for retirement is important. If you’re looking for an alternative source of income when you’re retired, an annuity may be the answer. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Are you retiring with more than you need?
A lack of knowledge about retirement options as well as outdated models mean many Australians are retiring with more than they need, an industry expert has revealed. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Structural reforms required as women retire in poverty
Older women are continuing to suffer from financial hardship, as key structural issues continue to see women go backwards in terms of wealth compared with men, an industry expert has revealed. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Why it will now cost more to retire
The cost of retiring just increased, with surging fuel costs and the rising price of food and healthcare negatively impacting a retiree’s bottom line. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
What is Financial Independence, Retire Early (FIRE) movement?
Do you want to achieve financial independence and retire early? The followers of FIRE movement say it’s achievable. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Financial victims shunned by changes to last resort compensation scheme
Proposed changes to the federal government’s compensation scheme of last resort will leave “devastated victims out in the cold”, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Decade funding delay sees ‘dire’ warning for aged care sector
A failure to build on the ideas outlined in the aged care royal commission is set to push an already breaking system into a ‘dire situation’ in just 10 years’ time, new research has warned. ...Read more
How the post-lockdown period will influence property, what the soaring NFT market means, and defining financial wellness
Listen now
APRA’s mortgage crackdown, the power of DeFi and last-minute tax tips
Listen now
What to expect as the end of lockdown looms? Will the Stage 2 tax cuts boost your tax return? Where should investors be looking as the economy reopens?
Listen now
Could property prices inflate by another 20%? What’s happening in recent dividend announcements? Did your fund fail the YFYS test?
Listen now
RBA says BNPL 'no surcharge' rules distort competition
Read more
Australia’s banks may be more vulnerable to cyber attacks than you think
Read more
Investors are more open to net zero but less savvy on the risks
Read more
The more time I spend looking at my money, the further I feel from financial freedom
Read more
Retirement Planning
Australia ranks 7th on global retirement index
Australia occupies the seventh place on the Natixis Global Retirement Index, behind Switzerland, Norway, Ireland, the Netherlands and New Zealand. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
What is an annuity and how does it work?
Having enough income for retirement is important. If you’re looking for an alternative source of income when you’re retired, an annuity may be the answer. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Are you retiring with more than you need?
A lack of knowledge about retirement options as well as outdated models mean many Australians are retiring with more than they need, an industry expert has revealed. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Structural reforms required as women retire in poverty
Older women are continuing to suffer from financial hardship, as key structural issues continue to see women go backwards in terms of wealth compared with men, an industry expert has revealed. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Why it will now cost more to retire
The cost of retiring just increased, with surging fuel costs and the rising price of food and healthcare negatively impacting a retiree’s bottom line. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
What is Financial Independence, Retire Early (FIRE) movement?
Do you want to achieve financial independence and retire early? The followers of FIRE movement say it’s achievable. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Financial victims shunned by changes to last resort compensation scheme
Proposed changes to the federal government’s compensation scheme of last resort will leave “devastated victims out in the cold”, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
Retirement Planning
Decade funding delay sees ‘dire’ warning for aged care sector
A failure to build on the ideas outlined in the aged care royal commission is set to push an already breaking system into a ‘dire situation’ in just 10 years’ time, new research has warned. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
