Invest
‘A product of abuse’: guarantors stung by poor bank processes
A mother’s love nearly led to homelessness after an elderly woman agreed to become guarantor without fully understanding the ramifications, the royal commission has heard.
‘A product of abuse’: guarantors stung by poor bank processes
A mother’s love nearly led to homelessness after an elderly woman agreed to become guarantor without fully understanding the ramifications, the royal commission has heard.

Carolyn Flanagan told the royal commission on Monday that she did not receive legal advice prior to signing a guarantor contract with Westpac for her daughter’s business loan.
That’s despite the banking code of conduct requiring that lenders advise would-be guarantors to seek independent advice prior to agreeing. When her daughter’s loan fell into arrears, the bank sought to repossess her home, although ultimately agreed to defer the repayment until after Ms Flanagan’s death.
Ms Flanagan, who admitted her memory is vague, said, “I would have signed anything, love, for her [daughter], in hindsight.
“I have to be honest about that. If you can’t help your children, who can you help?”

Nevertheless, she was adamant that if she had been told to seek legal advice she would have “walked out of that bank and gone”.
Difficult to say no
Legal Aid NSW’s senior solicitor, Dana Beiglari, has been representing Ms Flanagan since she began receiving eviction notices. She told the commission Ms Flanagan’s situation was not uncommon.
“In our case work experience at Legal Aid, it’s generally older people, so older parents who are using their homes as security for business loans for the benefit of a third party, who’s usually a son or daughter,” she said.
“Those people come to us for advice at the point where the bank is threatening to sell their home.”
Ms Beiglari said her clients often cite familial pressures as triggers for both agreeing to becoming guarantor and for eschewing independent advice.
“It’s very rare for clients to understand that their Centrelink pension payments may be reduced or cut off completely if the guarantee is called upon, due to the effect of the gifting rules that Centrelink has, and finally, a significant implication is the emotional toll that the stress and stress that this may have on the family unit,” she said.
“It could cause a relationship breakdown between the parent and the child which can be devastating for a parent, particularly in their old age.”
Ms Beiglari said her clients often have limited recollection of the circumstances of the agreement, may have difficulty communicating.
“I would say that nearly all of the cases that I have seen at Legal Aid, the client did not understand the detail of the financial arrangement that they were signing up to,” she said.
‘Guarantors offering up their guarantee without understanding the risks’
Philip Khoury, the independent reviewer who conducted a review of the Code of Banking Practice in 2016 and 2017, told the commission loan guarantors can be victims of abuse.
As part of the review, Mr Khoury analysed the protections for guarantors and found there were large risks associated with the practice.
Responding to questioning around the particular issues raised, Mr Khoury said, “Really, guarantors offering up their guarantee without understanding the risks.
“In the extreme end, this could be a product of abuse, elder abuse, familial abuse. In fact, even the guidelines that the banks have put together for this alert bank staff to the possibility of coercion in obtaining guarantees for someone else’s loan. So, this was clearly an issue.”
He said it was clear some would-be guarantors were potentially getting themselves into “highly risky” positions as their goodwill blinded them to the risks and realities.

Property
North platform adds household reporting feature to boost adviser efficiency
AMP's North platform has launched consolidated household reporting across multiple client accounts, helping financial advisers streamline their client review processes. Read more

Property
What Adds The Most Value To Properties?
Wondering how to up the value of your property? Properties are worth a lot of money in general, but there’s always a way to maximise value. The good news is that most of the things you can do to ...Read more

Property
Centuria reports strong growth in alternative real estate sectors for FY24
Centuria Capital Group has reported significant growth in alternative real estate sectors for the 2024 financial year, driving stable performance and increased guidance for FY25. Read more

Property
How to leverage equity in your home for investment or renovation
Home equity, the value of your property minus any debts owed, is a powerful financial resource many homeowners in Australia can utilize to further their financial goals. Whether you're looking to ...Read more

Property
Exploring REITs: Real estate investment without buying property
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) offer a compelling investment alternative for those interested in the real estate market but may not want to endure the complexities and capital requirements of ...Read more

Property
Retirement communities: a pivotal element in meeting Australia's housing targets
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) has recommended that retirement communities should be considered a vital part in the Australian Government's initiative to fulfill the Housing Australia Future Fund ...Read more

Property
Australians adjust financial strategies amid changing property market dynamics
The 2023 calendar year saw Australian borrowers acquiring a total of $300.9 billion in new loans for property purchases, marking a 12.7% decrease from the previous year. Read more

Property
Split home loans unlocking doors for Aussie buyers
Australians are teaming up to dive into the real estate market and seize the advantages of home ownership, with the trend of split home loans surging as family and friends unite to buy properties ...Read more

Property
North platform adds household reporting feature to boost adviser efficiency
AMP's North platform has launched consolidated household reporting across multiple client accounts, helping financial advisers streamline their client review processes. Read more

Property
What Adds The Most Value To Properties?
Wondering how to up the value of your property? Properties are worth a lot of money in general, but there’s always a way to maximise value. The good news is that most of the things you can do to ...Read more

Property
Centuria reports strong growth in alternative real estate sectors for FY24
Centuria Capital Group has reported significant growth in alternative real estate sectors for the 2024 financial year, driving stable performance and increased guidance for FY25. Read more

Property
How to leverage equity in your home for investment or renovation
Home equity, the value of your property minus any debts owed, is a powerful financial resource many homeowners in Australia can utilize to further their financial goals. Whether you're looking to ...Read more

Property
Exploring REITs: Real estate investment without buying property
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) offer a compelling investment alternative for those interested in the real estate market but may not want to endure the complexities and capital requirements of ...Read more

Property
Retirement communities: a pivotal element in meeting Australia's housing targets
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) has recommended that retirement communities should be considered a vital part in the Australian Government's initiative to fulfill the Housing Australia Future Fund ...Read more

Property
Australians adjust financial strategies amid changing property market dynamics
The 2023 calendar year saw Australian borrowers acquiring a total of $300.9 billion in new loans for property purchases, marking a 12.7% decrease from the previous year. Read more

Property
Split home loans unlocking doors for Aussie buyers
Australians are teaming up to dive into the real estate market and seize the advantages of home ownership, with the trend of split home loans surging as family and friends unite to buy properties ...Read more