Retirement
Friends forever: the ‘particular issues’ of inheriting from friends
It may not be common for friends to inherit before family, but it does happen and comes with its “own particular issues”, a solicitor has said.
Friends forever: the ‘particular issues’ of inheriting from friends
It may not be common for friends to inherit before family, but it does happen and comes with its “own particular issues”, a solicitor has said.

Townsends Business and Corporate Lawyers solicitor Julie Hartley explained that there are a number of hoops to jump through to establish and prove the true intentions of the testator and protect from will disputes.
She gave the example of Megan, a wealthy widow who wants to leave her estate to her closest friend, Jonathan. She also wants to leave a small bequest of $50,000 to her brother Andy, with whom she’s not close.
Megan and her brother own a property together and split the income 50/50. Megan has also been giving her brother $1,000 a month for the last five years.
Her will nominates Jonathan as her executor, but Ms Hartley warned there are several things of which Megan and Jonathan need to be aware.

1. The will could be challenged under the family provisions law
This means Andy could argue he is eligible for a larger portion of her estate as Megan hasn’t “adequately looked after him” in the will.
Ms Hartley explained: “If the court found that Andy was not adequately provided for under Megan’s will, the court could increase the amount Andy is to receive from the estate, thereby reducing Jonathan’s entitlement.”
Generally only current, former and de facto spouses, children, and those who were “wholly or partly dependent” on the deceased can make a claim under the Family Provision law.
Siblings don’t generally fit into these categories, but due to the $1,000 Megan gave Andy a month, he could potentially make a case.
However, whether Andy was reliant on his sister can only be determined on an individual basis.
“Would the fact that the $50,000 gift amounts to only four years’ worth of the money Megan had been regularly giving her brother be sufficient to demonstrate he was not adequately provided for under the will?” Ms Hartley questioned.
What to do?
Outside of stopping her payments to her brother, Megan and Jonathan’s options are limited.
However, Megan and her estate planner could review the will with Andy’s circumstances in mind and determine whether her provision was reasonable.
It could also eventuate that if Megan and her brother had planned to sell the property, Megan could make clear that that her $1,000 payments to Andy were an advance to him from his 50 per cent share of the sale proceeds. As such, those grants weren’t technically gifts, but loans.
“Documentation could be drawn up now, depending on how conciliatory Andy is willing to be, to confirm or formalise that arrangement, which may have the effect of undermining his ability to make a family provision claim,” Ms Hartley said.
2. Andy could say Jonathan had “undue influence” over Megan
While Megan and Jonathan don’t have a romantic relationship, they are close friends. Andy could therefore argue the will was created to benefit Jonathan due to his influence over Megan.
Should the court rule in Andy’s favour, Megan would have died without a valid will and her brother would most likely be regarded as her effective next-of-kin and receive her estate.
What to do?
Ms Hartley explained that undue influence occurs when a will doesn’t express the deceased’s real intentions as a result of influence and leads to the detriment of other parties.
“It can be extremely difficult to establish as, for example in this scenario, it would fall on Andy to prove undue influence in circumstances where Megan would no longer be available to testify in court about her reasoning and motivations behind her bequests,” the solicitor said.
“Other witnesses (such as her doctors, healthcare providers, family members, lawyers, etc.) would need to testify about their knowledge of the relationship between Megan and Jonathan to help the court determine whether Megan was the victim of undue influence on Jonathan’s part.”
An estate planning lawyer would also be useful in proving Megan understood her will when it was explained to her, without Jonathan being present, and there was no evidence of undue influence from Jonathan.

Retirement Planning
Majority of Australians anxious about retirement as super knowledge gaps persist, report finds
A new study by Aware Super has revealed that a significant majority of Australians aged 45 and over are feeling anxious about retirement, with nearly nine in ten respondents concerned they will run ...Read more

Retirement Planning
AMP’s MyNorth Lifetime boosts financial security and retirement income
AMP has reported that its MyNorth Lifetime retirement income solution is delivering significant financial benefits to retirees, with an average uplift of 50% in total income. Read more

Retirement Planning
Retirement living sector calls for planning reforms amid declining construction confidence
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) is urging governments to streamline planning systems to boost housing supply, following a decline in confidence in age-friendly construction activity. Read more

Retirement Planning
New laws to boost women's retirement savings through paid parental leave
The Australian Parliament has passed new legislation that will see superannuation guarantee contributions paid on the Commonwealth Government's Paid Parental Leave (PPL) scheme. Read more

Retirement Planning
Planning systems under scrutiny as Australia's ageing population grows
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) has called for governments to address planning system shortfalls in preparation for Australia's ageing population, following the release of new data from the ...Read more

Retirement Planning
Retirement Living Council calls for focus on seniors' housing as population ages
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) has urged governments across Australia to prioritise age-friendly housing solutions in response to new data revealing an ageing population. Read more

Retirement Planning
Macquarie University study reveals benefits of guaranteed income in retirement
A new study by Macquarie University's School of Psychological Sciences has found that mental health, enjoyment, and financial security are key benefits of incorporating guaranteed income and annuities ...Read more

Retirement Planning
Retirement villages offer affordable housing amid market crisis, study finds
Retirement villages are providing a significantly more affordable housing option for older Australians compared to the traditional property market, according to new data released today. Read more

Retirement Planning
Majority of Australians anxious about retirement as super knowledge gaps persist, report finds
A new study by Aware Super has revealed that a significant majority of Australians aged 45 and over are feeling anxious about retirement, with nearly nine in ten respondents concerned they will run ...Read more

Retirement Planning
AMP’s MyNorth Lifetime boosts financial security and retirement income
AMP has reported that its MyNorth Lifetime retirement income solution is delivering significant financial benefits to retirees, with an average uplift of 50% in total income. Read more

Retirement Planning
Retirement living sector calls for planning reforms amid declining construction confidence
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) is urging governments to streamline planning systems to boost housing supply, following a decline in confidence in age-friendly construction activity. Read more

Retirement Planning
New laws to boost women's retirement savings through paid parental leave
The Australian Parliament has passed new legislation that will see superannuation guarantee contributions paid on the Commonwealth Government's Paid Parental Leave (PPL) scheme. Read more

Retirement Planning
Planning systems under scrutiny as Australia's ageing population grows
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) has called for governments to address planning system shortfalls in preparation for Australia's ageing population, following the release of new data from the ...Read more

Retirement Planning
Retirement Living Council calls for focus on seniors' housing as population ages
The Retirement Living Council (RLC) has urged governments across Australia to prioritise age-friendly housing solutions in response to new data revealing an ageing population. Read more

Retirement Planning
Macquarie University study reveals benefits of guaranteed income in retirement
A new study by Macquarie University's School of Psychological Sciences has found that mental health, enjoyment, and financial security are key benefits of incorporating guaranteed income and annuities ...Read more

Retirement Planning
Retirement villages offer affordable housing amid market crisis, study finds
Retirement villages are providing a significantly more affordable housing option for older Australians compared to the traditional property market, according to new data released today. Read more