Invest
Do our regulators need regulating?
Revelations and confirmations of corporate misconduct have been a near-daily occurrence in the past month, leading politicians from different stripes to call for scrutiny of the regulators.
Do our regulators need regulating?
Revelations and confirmations of corporate misconduct have been a near-daily occurrence in the past month, leading politicians from different stripes to call for scrutiny of the regulators.
Responding to questioning on whether the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) require bolstering given the royal commission’s revelations, Treasurer Scott Morrison emphasised that APRA’s “damning” inquiry into the Commonwealth Bank of Australia began prior to the royal commission.
The report, which uncovered systemic governance issues at Australia’s largest bank, was established last year following allegations of anti-money laundering and counter terrorism financing breaches.
“I should stress, what we're talking about today is a result of something that began last August, well before the royal commission,” Mr Morrison said.
“These were matters the government acted immediately on, through APRA, to put in a very high-powered inquiry which has now reported back. Here it is. The report is back now. And the action that is now being taken by the CBA is happening now.”
To the University of Western Australia’s senior lecturer of law, Andrew Schmulow, the fact that no CEOs have “been toppled” despite the royal commission’s revelations indicates a lack of willpower on the part of the regulators to prosecute.
Writing for The Conversation, the academic said: “APRA already has the power under the Banking Act to remove someone from a bank board and install its own nominee.
“The recently enacted Banking Executive Accountability Regime has given APRA more power to remove directors and install new ones.
“So ASIC and APRA are not bedevilled by a lack of power, but by a lack of willpower.”
In addition to no “toppled” execs, APRA’s inquiry mandated that the Commonwealth Bank accept an enforceable undertaking to develop and submit a remedial action plan, appoint an APRA-approved reviewer to ensure the remedial plan is carried through, and provide a report to APRA on how APRA’s inquiry is reflected in the bank’s remuneration structures and outcomes.
The bank will also be required to add an additional $1 billion to its operational risk capital.
ASIC’s ‘softly-softly’ approach needs reconsidering
While APRA has been the source of more recent debate, the concerns around ASIC’s strength and performance have persisted throughout the royal commission’s duration.
Most recently, Senator Rex Patrick called for senior ASIC officials to consider their ongoing tenure.
Speaking this week, the NXT politician said: “Senior officials who are given responsibility and authority for public purpose must be held to account when that public purpose is not fulfilled.”
Noting that current ASIC chair, James Shipton has only been at the helm for three months, he said other ASIC commissioners bear significant responsibility for the “financial horrors” revealed in the royal commission.
He pointed the finger at deputy chair Peter Kell, and commissioners John Price and Cathie Armour who have all been with ASIC for at least five years.
Noting these tenures, Mr Patrick said: “The terms of these commissioners have included plenty of public warnings and whistleblowing about misconduct in the banking sector, and indeed warnings from within ASIC itself.
“Yet more often than not the response of ASIC is to shoot the messenger on behalf of the banks.”
He blasted ASIC for its “softly-softly” approach to regulation marked by a reluctance to pursue strong legal action.
Evidence given by the executive leader of ASIC’s financial advisers team Louise Macaulay revealed that ASIC had criminally prosecuted just one Australian Financial Services Licensee in the last 10 years.
"For far too long there has been a great reluctance for senior executives in both the private and public sectors to accept personal responsibility for failures of performance and governance,” Mr Patrick said, calling for long-serving commissioners to review their own performance and positions.
‘What were the regulators doing?’
Mr Patrick’s sentiments echo those put forward by former Prime Minister Tony Abbott last week.
Speaking to Macquarie Media, the politician blamed ASIC for the scandals exposed in the royal commission.
“What were the regulators doing to allow all this to be happening? That’s the thing that keeps occurring to me every time I read fresh revelations,” he said.
“My fear is that at the end of this royal commission, we will have yet another level of regulation imposed on the banks when, frankly, what should happen is, I suspect, all the existing regulators should be sacked and people who are much more vigilant and much less complacent go in their place."
It’s worth noting that the 2014 budget, which Mr Abbott oversaw, triggered cuts of $120 million to ASIC’s funding over four years.
The chair at the time, Greg Medcraft warned that the cuts would mean ASIC’s capacity to carry out its duties would be “substantially reduced” and that the trade-off would be that its “proactive surveillance will substantially reduce”.
Two years later, funding was restored under Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s government.
However, it’s not just politicians taking fire at ASIC.
‘We have a much bigger concern’
The Institute of Public Accountants’ (IPA) CEO Andrew Conway said ASIC is doing a better job of government revenue-raising than actual enforcement.
The IPA noted that ASIC received $349 million in appropriation revenue in 2016-17 and had $392.46 million in expenses - which means a deficit of more than $43.5 million - while raising $920.24 million for the Commonwealth in fees and charges.
Given that the government’s Charging Framework requires that ASIC has an alignment of expenses and revenue, Mr Conway observed: “Even though ASIC is making significant income for government, it is not even able to cover its own costs from the budget it receives from government.
“This also means that ASIC is raising substantially more revenue than its operational costs, which appears to go against the government’s own Charging Framework.”
Referring to its submission to Treasury last year on ASIC’s fees-for-service industry funding model, Mr Conway said: “We have a much bigger concern if a new funding model is only focused on government revenue without equipping the corporate regulator to do its job adequately.”
Spending
How much are you wasting on unused subscriptions?
Australians are continuing to pay for subscriptions they are not using, costing households up to $2,000 a year, new banking figures have revealed. ...Read more
Spending
Viagogo under the microscope for ‘ripping off’ consumers
Viagogo is under investigation by Fair Trading after ticket scalpers have been accused of raking in excessive profits through the ticketing site. ...Read more
Spending
Consumer spending defies lockdown
Statewide lockdowns have not hampered consumer spending, with the latest government data showing Aussies are continuing to spend more on their credit cards. ...Read more
Spending
How a cartel is dictating how much you pay at the pump
Talks among members of the OPEC cartel and allied oil producing countries have broken down, which is leading to skyrocketing oil prices, meaning everyone pays more for petrol, a government body has re...Read more
Spending
Have you noticed the price of your mobile plan increasing?
The consumer watchdog has revealed that the three main telecommunication providers have recently raised prices, meaning millions of Australians are now paying more for mobile services. ...Read more
Spending
Victoria’s lockdowns dampen retail spending
The latest COVID-19 outbreak in Victoria has dented national retail figures, as the economy continues to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Spending
It should be easier to fix your phone, Productivity Commission finds
The Productivity Commission has found that it should be easier for Australians to get their smartphone repaired and has recommended changes that include ‘super complaints’ to be reported to watchd...Read more
Spending
You can win free flights for a year, but there’s a major catch
In a bid to keep Australia’s domestic aviation afloat, Qantas is offering free flights for a year for 10 families of four who get the COVID-19 jab, even though the failed vaccine rollout means only ...Read more
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Are property prices set to crash? Should you jump on board the fintok craze? And how to prepare for this tax time
Listen now
Spending
How much are you wasting on unused subscriptions?
Australians are continuing to pay for subscriptions they are not using, costing households up to $2,000 a year, new banking figures have revealed. ...Read more
Spending
Viagogo under the microscope for ‘ripping off’ consumers
Viagogo is under investigation by Fair Trading after ticket scalpers have been accused of raking in excessive profits through the ticketing site. ...Read more
Spending
Consumer spending defies lockdown
Statewide lockdowns have not hampered consumer spending, with the latest government data showing Aussies are continuing to spend more on their credit cards. ...Read more
Spending
How a cartel is dictating how much you pay at the pump
Talks among members of the OPEC cartel and allied oil producing countries have broken down, which is leading to skyrocketing oil prices, meaning everyone pays more for petrol, a government body has re...Read more
Spending
Have you noticed the price of your mobile plan increasing?
The consumer watchdog has revealed that the three main telecommunication providers have recently raised prices, meaning millions of Australians are now paying more for mobile services. ...Read more
Spending
Victoria’s lockdowns dampen retail spending
The latest COVID-19 outbreak in Victoria has dented national retail figures, as the economy continues to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Spending
It should be easier to fix your phone, Productivity Commission finds
The Productivity Commission has found that it should be easier for Australians to get their smartphone repaired and has recommended changes that include ‘super complaints’ to be reported to watchd...Read more
Spending
You can win free flights for a year, but there’s a major catch
In a bid to keep Australia’s domestic aviation afloat, Qantas is offering free flights for a year for 10 families of four who get the COVID-19 jab, even though the failed vaccine rollout means only ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
