Invest
Consumer advocates hit back at self-regulated BNPL code of practice
The long-awaited buy now, pay later code of practice is set to come into effect from 1 March, but industry experts remain sceptical of the self-enforced rules.
Consumer advocates hit back at self-regulated BNPL code of practice
The long-awaited buy now, pay later code of practice is set to come into effect from 1 March, but industry experts remain sceptical of the self-enforced rules.
The code that will govern the BNPL sector was drawn up by the Australian Finance Industry Association (AFIA) and a group of members in the BNPL space.
While final details are expected to be released later this week, a report surfacing in the Australian Financial Review hinted the code could bring in a requirement for credit checks for any transactions surpassing $2,000.
The code is expected to announce these credit checks will be done via the provider’s own system, with no requirements to use external data to ensure a consumer can pay back their bills.
The code is expected to prevent providers from offering BNPL products to minors, and will mandate anti-money laundering identity checks.
However, consumer industry groups, including CHOICE, Financial Rights Legal Centre, Financial Counselling Australia and Consumer Action Legal Centre have called for regulation of the sector to mirror that seen in the UK.
The British government said new laws would require buy now, pay later providers to conduct affordability checks before lending to customers, which may affect the product’s key attributes of convenience and simplicity.
While highlighting that self-enforced rules are a good first step, CHOICE’s director of campaigns and communications Erin Turner said any self-regulation of the BNPL will not be enough to fix the issues in relation to higher fees, inappropriate lending and pushing marketing.
“The buy now, pay later sector is now selling debt for dental treatments, solar panels and other large purchases. It is credit in everything but name, so the consumer protection laws for credit should apply in full, not a weak industry code,” Ms Turner said.
“The code will see businesses that fail to comply with basic standards face ‘naming and shaming’ rather than the penalties or legal action other lenders face for significant breaches of consumer credit protections. This sets an inappropriately low bar for a growing industry.”
CHOICE also pointed out that while BNPL does not charge interest, the late fees can be just as expensive as a credit card, and the retailer fees of 3 to 6 per cent are passed onto consumers.
They also highlighted research from ASIC, which found that one in five people had missed payments on their BNPL debt.
Worryingly, one in five people had also gone without essential items, such as food, in order to make a payment.
“BNPL providers run a mile at the mention of the word ‘credit’, telling their customers the service is all about better budgeting. What they tell retailers, however, is much closer to the truth – that BNPL encourages people to spend more,” Financial Counselling Australia chief executive Fiona Guthrie said.
“If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it is a duck. We should ditch ideology and recognise that BNPL is credit and should be regulated like other credit. If we fail to act, more and more Australians will be harmed.”
About the author
About the author
Spending
How much are you wasting on unused subscriptions?
Australians are continuing to pay for subscriptions they are not using, costing households up to $2,000 a year, new banking figures have revealed. ...Read more
Spending
Viagogo under the microscope for ‘ripping off’ consumers
Viagogo is under investigation by Fair Trading after ticket scalpers have been accused of raking in excessive profits through the ticketing site. ...Read more
Spending
Consumer spending defies lockdown
Statewide lockdowns have not hampered consumer spending, with the latest government data showing Aussies are continuing to spend more on their credit cards. ...Read more
Spending
How a cartel is dictating how much you pay at the pump
Talks among members of the OPEC cartel and allied oil producing countries have broken down, which is leading to skyrocketing oil prices, meaning everyone pays more for petrol, a government body has re...Read more
Spending
Have you noticed the price of your mobile plan increasing?
The consumer watchdog has revealed that the three main telecommunication providers have recently raised prices, meaning millions of Australians are now paying more for mobile services. ...Read more
Spending
Victoria’s lockdowns dampen retail spending
The latest COVID-19 outbreak in Victoria has dented national retail figures, as the economy continues to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Spending
It should be easier to fix your phone, Productivity Commission finds
The Productivity Commission has found that it should be easier for Australians to get their smartphone repaired and has recommended changes that include ‘super complaints’ to be reported to watchd...Read more
Spending
You can win free flights for a year, but there’s a major catch
In a bid to keep Australia’s domestic aviation afloat, Qantas is offering free flights for a year for 10 families of four who get the COVID-19 jab, even though the failed vaccine rollout means only ...Read more
The Olympic effect on property and equity investors; COVID-19 Disaster Payments and super
Listen now
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Spending
How much are you wasting on unused subscriptions?
Australians are continuing to pay for subscriptions they are not using, costing households up to $2,000 a year, new banking figures have revealed. ...Read more
Spending
Viagogo under the microscope for ‘ripping off’ consumers
Viagogo is under investigation by Fair Trading after ticket scalpers have been accused of raking in excessive profits through the ticketing site. ...Read more
Spending
Consumer spending defies lockdown
Statewide lockdowns have not hampered consumer spending, with the latest government data showing Aussies are continuing to spend more on their credit cards. ...Read more
Spending
How a cartel is dictating how much you pay at the pump
Talks among members of the OPEC cartel and allied oil producing countries have broken down, which is leading to skyrocketing oil prices, meaning everyone pays more for petrol, a government body has re...Read more
Spending
Have you noticed the price of your mobile plan increasing?
The consumer watchdog has revealed that the three main telecommunication providers have recently raised prices, meaning millions of Australians are now paying more for mobile services. ...Read more
Spending
Victoria’s lockdowns dampen retail spending
The latest COVID-19 outbreak in Victoria has dented national retail figures, as the economy continues to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. ...Read more
Spending
It should be easier to fix your phone, Productivity Commission finds
The Productivity Commission has found that it should be easier for Australians to get their smartphone repaired and has recommended changes that include ‘super complaints’ to be reported to watchd...Read more
Spending
You can win free flights for a year, but there’s a major catch
In a bid to keep Australia’s domestic aviation afloat, Qantas is offering free flights for a year for 10 families of four who get the COVID-19 jab, even though the failed vaccine rollout means only ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
