Invest
ACCC accuses Peters Ice Cream of freezing out the competition
One of Australia’s largest ice cream suppliers has allegedly engaged in conduct which hinders or prevents competition for the supply of single-wrapped ice creams to petrol and convenience retailers.
ACCC accuses Peters Ice Cream of freezing out the competition
One of Australia’s largest ice cream suppliers has allegedly engaged in conduct which hinders or prevents competition for the supply of single-wrapped ice creams to petrol and convenience retailers.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has accused Australasian Food Group, which trades under Peters Ice Cream, as engaging in anti-competitive dealings to stop other companies from selling ice cream.
Peters, which is best known for brands including Drumstick, Billabong, Frosty Fruits and Maxibon, is one of two major suppliers of single-wrapped ice cream in Australia, which hold roughly 95 per cent of the market.
The competition watchdog has launched Federal Court action against Peters, alleging that between 2014 and 2019 Peters engaged in exclusive dealing by entering into an agreement with food delivery company PFD Food Services to distribute its single-wrapped ice creams across the country.
It is alleged that Peters entered into exclusive dealings which occur when one person trading with another imposes some restrictions on the other’s freedom to choose with whom, in what, or where they deal. Exclusive dealing is against the law only when it has the purpose or effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition.
During the term of the distribution agreement, PFD made requests to distribute competing ice cream products to petrol and convenience retailers nationally, but these requests were rejected by Peters.
The ACCC also said that it was not commercially viable for new entrants to incur the cost of establishing their own distribution network to distribute single-wrapped ice creams nationally.
“We allege that, as a result of the agreement and Peters’ conduct, other ice cream suppliers had no commercially viable way of distributing their single serve ice creams to national petrol and convenience retailers,” ACCC chair Rod Sims said.
“Our case is that the distribution agreement and Peters’ conduct effectively raised barriers of entry, which hindered or prevented potential new entry into the market to supply single serve ice cream products to petrol and convenience retailers.”
The Australasian Food Group (AFG), trading as Peters, has denied the allegations in a written statement, saying it intends to “vigorously defend” any court proceedings.
Full statement from Australasian Food Group:
AFG notes today’s announcement by the ACCC and intends to vigorously defend any proceedings. AFG has confidence in its position and the arguments that support it.
For many years, there have been an extensive number of commercially viable distribution options available for the delivery of ice cream products around Australia to petrol and convenience retailers.
It is our position that other manufacturers have not been prevented from supplying their products to retailers by virtue of AFG’s distribution arrangements with PFD.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Spending
Household Spending Pops, Rate Hike Looms: A CFO Playbook from an Australian Retail Case
Fresh ABS data shows household outlays running hotter than expected, particularly in services—stoking calls for an RBA move as early as February. For operators, the macro headline is simple; the ...Read more
Spending
State Street economist comments on softer-than-expected CPI data
In light of the latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) data release, Krishna Bhimavarapu, APAC Economist at State Street Investment Management, has provided insight into the implications for the Australian ...Read more
Spending
Moneysmart study reveals Gen Z women more concerned about finances than men
A new research conducted by ASIC’s Moneysmart has unveiled the heightened levels of stress and concern regarding finances and the cost of living among Australian Gen Z women compared to their male ...Read more
Spending
The cost of politeness: Aussies out of pocket by $1,350 due to 'awkward tax'
It's the time of year when Australians dive into their pockets for festive events and gatherings, yet a recent study by PayPal suggests that many are too polite, or perhaps too embarrassed, to ask for ...Read more
Spending
Aussies can ‘NAB Now Pay Later’ with the last major bank to embrace BNPL
NAB has become the latest bank to enter the BNPL market. Read more
Spending
Aussie households spent $368 a week on transport after petrol price surge
Fuel costs have increased by 40 per cent over the past year, a new report from the Australian Automobile Association has revealed. Read more
Spending
Voters say reducing the cost of living should be the government’s top priority
Aussies have ranked high cost of living as the top issue that needs to be addressed by the next government. Read more
Spending
Bodies back Labor’s commitment to stronger BNPL regulation
All parties should commit to stronger regulations for the BNPL sector, according to Financial Counselling Australia. Read more
Spending
Household Spending Pops, Rate Hike Looms: A CFO Playbook from an Australian Retail Case
Fresh ABS data shows household outlays running hotter than expected, particularly in services—stoking calls for an RBA move as early as February. For operators, the macro headline is simple; the ...Read more
Spending
State Street economist comments on softer-than-expected CPI data
In light of the latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) data release, Krishna Bhimavarapu, APAC Economist at State Street Investment Management, has provided insight into the implications for the Australian ...Read more
Spending
Moneysmart study reveals Gen Z women more concerned about finances than men
A new research conducted by ASIC’s Moneysmart has unveiled the heightened levels of stress and concern regarding finances and the cost of living among Australian Gen Z women compared to their male ...Read more
Spending
The cost of politeness: Aussies out of pocket by $1,350 due to 'awkward tax'
It's the time of year when Australians dive into their pockets for festive events and gatherings, yet a recent study by PayPal suggests that many are too polite, or perhaps too embarrassed, to ask for ...Read more
Spending
Aussies can ‘NAB Now Pay Later’ with the last major bank to embrace BNPL
NAB has become the latest bank to enter the BNPL market. Read more
Spending
Aussie households spent $368 a week on transport after petrol price surge
Fuel costs have increased by 40 per cent over the past year, a new report from the Australian Automobile Association has revealed. Read more
Spending
Voters say reducing the cost of living should be the government’s top priority
Aussies have ranked high cost of living as the top issue that needs to be addressed by the next government. Read more
Spending
Bodies back Labor’s commitment to stronger BNPL regulation
All parties should commit to stronger regulations for the BNPL sector, according to Financial Counselling Australia. Read more
