Invest
Why you can’t be a slave to a property tax deduction
A tax expert has warned property investors about the lure of solely prioritising tax deductions on rental property purchases through the use of an interest-only loan, especially in locations suffering from slow economies.
Why you can’t be a slave to a property tax deduction
A tax expert has warned property investors about the lure of solely prioritising tax deductions on rental property purchases through the use of an interest-only loan, especially in locations suffering from slow economies.
Cheryl Mallett, a fellow of the Institute of Public Accountants (IPA), a chartered tax adviser and partner at Darwin’s Vita Gustafson & Associates, has expressed her “very strong view” that “if you can only afford to pay interest-only on a loan, then you really have to start thinking about whether you can afford to buy that rental property”.
She said that the idea that “tax-deductible is king of everything” has led to a lot of issues in Darwin and Northern Queensland’s eastern seaboard towns including Townsville and Mackay.
The chartered tax adviser has explained that a lot of people were advised initially that they should just get their loan under an interest-only payment instead of principal and interest.
Noting the lure of paying less tax as “biting hard” in struggling economic areas, Ms Mallett said: “What’s happening now, particularly in Queensland, Northern Queensland in particular, and Darwin, our economies have slowed right down, so now we’ve got the situation where people have only paid interest because that means the whole payment is tax-deductible, as opposed to principal and interest where a portion of it is private because it is paying off the principal.”
In practical terms, the effect the tax adviser has seen stemming from such advice has been that investors have got, for example, “a $300,000 house with a $500,000 loan against it, and they are in a lot of financial difficulty”.
Arguing that “you shouldn’t be a slave to a tax deduction”, Ms Mallett said that people are now going to her and signifying a need to sell their rentals because the banks are now moving to make everybody shift to principal and interest loans.
“So then we’ve got the clients whose repayments are going up, their property is worth less, and they are saying, ‘Well, I need to sell it, but I can’t even get enough money to pay off the loan’.
“If they sell the property, they could find themselves in a position where they are still paying off the loan but they’ve got no property, no asset for one thing, and they’ve got no rent coming in to help pay it.
“They are in a very dire state.”
Offering up some encouragement for anyone in the position where their property value has gone down and they are in an interest-only mortgage situation where the loan value now outstrips the property’s value, Ms Mallett said: “If you can ride it out, ride it out.”
She argued: “Don’t crystallise the loss.
“The property market will come back, it’s come back forever in history, so if you can afford it, please ride it out.
“Don’t sell and crystallise your loss because that means you’ll never get it back, there’s no chance of you being able to ride on the wave of the property boom or increase in values.
“And it will happen in the future.”
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Property
New investment platform Arkus allows Australians to invest in property for just $1
In a groundbreaking move to democratise investment in property-backed mortgage funds, GPS Investment Fund Limited has launched Arkus™, a retail investment platform designed to make investing ...Read more
Property
Help to Buy goes live: What 40,000 new buyers mean for banks, builders and the bottom line
Australia’s Help to Buy has opened, lowering the deposit hurdle to 2 per cent and aiming to support up to 40,000 households over four years. That single policy lever will reverberate through mortgage ...Read more
Property
Australia’s mortgage knife‑fight: investors, first‑home buyers and the new rules of lender competition
The mortgage market is staying hot even as rate relief remains elusive, with investors and first‑home buyers chasing scarce stock and lenders fighting for share on price, speed and digital experienceRead more
Property
Breaking Australia’s three‑property ceiling: the finance‑first playbook for scalable portfolios
Most Australian investors don’t stall at three properties because they run out of ambition — they run out of borrowing capacity. The ceiling is a finance constraint disguised as an asset problem. The ...Read more
Property
Gen Z's secret weapon: Why their homebuying spree could flip Australia's housing market
A surprising share of younger Australians are preparing to buy despite affordability headwinds. One in three Gen Z Australians intend to purchase within a few years and 32 per cent say escaping rent ...Read more
Property
Tasmania’s pet-positive pivot: What landlords, BTR operators and insurers need to do now
Tasmania will soon require landlords to allow pets unless they can prove a valid reason to refuse. This is more than a tenancy tweak; it is a structural signal that the balance of power in rental ...Read more
Property
NSW underquoting crackdown: the compliance reset creating both cost and competitive edge
NSW is moving to sharply increase penalties for misleading price guides, including fines linked to agent commissions and maximum penalties up to $110,000. Behind the headlines sits a more ...Read more
Property
ANZ’s mortgage growth, profit slump: why volume without margin won’t pay the dividends
ANZ lifted home-lending volumes, yet profits fell under the weight of regulatory and restructuring costs—an object lesson in the futility of growth that doesn’t convert to margin and productivityRead more
Property
New investment platform Arkus allows Australians to invest in property for just $1
In a groundbreaking move to democratise investment in property-backed mortgage funds, GPS Investment Fund Limited has launched Arkus™, a retail investment platform designed to make investing ...Read more
Property
Help to Buy goes live: What 40,000 new buyers mean for banks, builders and the bottom line
Australia’s Help to Buy has opened, lowering the deposit hurdle to 2 per cent and aiming to support up to 40,000 households over four years. That single policy lever will reverberate through mortgage ...Read more
Property
Australia’s mortgage knife‑fight: investors, first‑home buyers and the new rules of lender competition
The mortgage market is staying hot even as rate relief remains elusive, with investors and first‑home buyers chasing scarce stock and lenders fighting for share on price, speed and digital experienceRead more
Property
Breaking Australia’s three‑property ceiling: the finance‑first playbook for scalable portfolios
Most Australian investors don’t stall at three properties because they run out of ambition — they run out of borrowing capacity. The ceiling is a finance constraint disguised as an asset problem. The ...Read more
Property
Gen Z's secret weapon: Why their homebuying spree could flip Australia's housing market
A surprising share of younger Australians are preparing to buy despite affordability headwinds. One in three Gen Z Australians intend to purchase within a few years and 32 per cent say escaping rent ...Read more
Property
Tasmania’s pet-positive pivot: What landlords, BTR operators and insurers need to do now
Tasmania will soon require landlords to allow pets unless they can prove a valid reason to refuse. This is more than a tenancy tweak; it is a structural signal that the balance of power in rental ...Read more
Property
NSW underquoting crackdown: the compliance reset creating both cost and competitive edge
NSW is moving to sharply increase penalties for misleading price guides, including fines linked to agent commissions and maximum penalties up to $110,000. Behind the headlines sits a more ...Read more
Property
ANZ’s mortgage growth, profit slump: why volume without margin won’t pay the dividends
ANZ lifted home-lending volumes, yet profits fell under the weight of regulatory and restructuring costs—an object lesson in the futility of growth that doesn’t convert to margin and productivityRead more
