Invest
Proposed tax reforms tipped to stall portfolio growth
Labor’s proposed reforms to the dividend imputation system could stifle investors from pursuing growth assets, a portfolio manager has warned.

Proposed tax reforms tipped to stall portfolio growth
Labor’s proposed reforms to the dividend imputation system could stifle investors from pursuing growth assets, a portfolio manager has warned.

Kate Howitt, portfolio manager at Fidelity Australian Opportunities Fund, has warned that Labor's proposed reforms that will put an end to the dividend imputation system, which currently allows cash refunds for franking credits, will have significant ramifications for the every day investor.
“Frank dividends means we keep getting cash back to us [investors] that we can then use to re-deploy into smaller and more innovative growth companies. I call this the ‘Robin Hood’ argument for franking. Franking forces the ‘rich’ to give to us, that we can then give to the ‘poor’,” she said.
“If you provide an economic incentive for those large, cash generative companies to give the cash back to shareholders, then shareholders can reinvest in small companies that have great growth prospects but don’t have the capital that they need to grow."
Ms Howitt advocated the current franking system as an effective incentive for investors to engage with growth assets and expand their wealth in the accessible, listed environment of the equity market.
She cited the current trends on the US capital markets, in terms of de-equitisation, corporate buy backs, high corporate debt levels and the loss of innovation to other non-market environments as a warning of the potential future for Aussie markets should dividends be taken out of the hands of every day shareholders.
“You have this dynamic building in the US where because of the double taxation on dividends, corporates are buying back their own shares and de-equitising. So, equity markets are shrinking. Because it’s not coming in dividends to investors, investors have less that they can use to then buy smaller companies,” Ms Howitt said.
“So, smaller companies are finding the listed environment harder and, therefore, there’s more going into non-market environments. Hence, the innovation in the US is happening increasingly in an unlisted sphere, which, of course, is great if you’re a sophisticated high-net-worth individual who can do an allocation into the non-market area, but if you’re more the mainstream investor and just wanting to get your exposure to growth assets through listed equity markets, life is getting tougher because you’re just getting these over levered, older style companies and less of the innovation coming through, as it’s happening off market.”
Her concerns come as those in the SMSF community and other financial experts have suggested that the changes are unlikely to affect the target demographic of wealthy Australians.
According to prominent economist Saul Eslake,“There are things that Labor could do to modify its proposal that would help deal with the people who might genuinely be adversely affected that you wouldn't want to be.”
His words mirror those of director of Tactical Super Deanne Firth, who told Nest Egg's sister publication SMSF Adviser that the policy is an “attack on SMSFs” as it would impact a third of all self-managed funds.
“While it is being touted as a loophole enjoyed by the wealthy, this proposal hurts self-funded retirees in SMSFs the most – retail super funds still qualify to offset their tax using imputation credits as their net tax position is positive – not due to a member by member allocation but because pooled overall, they have a positive tax position. So, the policy is a tax on the use of a particular structure, an SMSF,” Ms Firth said.
Her apprehensions are due to the fact that, although the opposition has confirmed pensioners and SMSFs with at least one pensioner or allowance recipient before 28 March 2018 will be exempt from the changes, the move will likely affect many self-funded retirees of modest wealth.
This is because the plans will likely have the greatest impact on those heavily invested in Australian shares and do not receive full or part pensions or allowances, including pension phase SMSF members. This demographic is not confined to the rich.
“The bigger issue from an economic point of view is that you need to retain the franking regime overall," concluded Ms Howitt.
"That’s what would be a really retrograde step for longer-term economic prospects for the country."
For more information on the what the changes to franking credits mean for the individual investor or their impact on SMSF members, click here.

Property
Poor wage growth could impede home price growth
With wages growth at record-low levels, a property expert has warned that continuing low and flat wages could impede home price growth. ...Read more

Property
Negotiating a lower interest rate on your property loan
The banks are customer hungry, meaning they’re willing to offer increased discounts to new customers and apply these discounts to existing customer loans, a mortgage broker has said. ...Read more

Property
How to determine the real value of a property
With various factors affecting market value and pricing, can one truly predict what buyers will pay for properties? ...Read more

Property
House prices tipped to soar 20% in 2 years: Westpac
House prices in Sydney are tipped to grow by 20 per cent over the next two years, and by 18 per cent in Melbourne, as a leading economist predicts strong economic growth following the rollout of the C...Read more

Property
5 tips to unearth the next property hotspots
A property expert has bullishly claimed that property hotspots are a “complete myth” that almost guarantees buyers will pay top dollar, and has instead urged buyers to seek out the “warm spots...Read more

Property
Top 10 inland rural towns to invest in
While it’s become apparent that regional housing markets have stolen the spotlight, having outpaced their capital city counterparts in 2020, new research has shown that inland rural towns have also ...Read more

Property
Where to buy under $300k
A positively geared property with high capital growth potential does not necessarily need to carry an astronomical price tag, an expert has said, with new market entrants able to land a home for under...Read more

Property
‘Great Australian dream’ of owning a home lives on amid COVID
Most Australian investors and home buyers were largely undeterred by the events of 2020, remaining eager to push through with their investment plans, a new survey has found. ...Read more

Property
Poor wage growth could impede home price growth
With wages growth at record-low levels, a property expert has warned that continuing low and flat wages could impede home price growth. ...Read more

Property
Negotiating a lower interest rate on your property loan
The banks are customer hungry, meaning they’re willing to offer increased discounts to new customers and apply these discounts to existing customer loans, a mortgage broker has said. ...Read more

Property
How to determine the real value of a property
With various factors affecting market value and pricing, can one truly predict what buyers will pay for properties? ...Read more

Property
House prices tipped to soar 20% in 2 years: Westpac
House prices in Sydney are tipped to grow by 20 per cent over the next two years, and by 18 per cent in Melbourne, as a leading economist predicts strong economic growth following the rollout of the C...Read more

Property
5 tips to unearth the next property hotspots
A property expert has bullishly claimed that property hotspots are a “complete myth” that almost guarantees buyers will pay top dollar, and has instead urged buyers to seek out the “warm spots...Read more

Property
Top 10 inland rural towns to invest in
While it’s become apparent that regional housing markets have stolen the spotlight, having outpaced their capital city counterparts in 2020, new research has shown that inland rural towns have also ...Read more

Property
Where to buy under $300k
A positively geared property with high capital growth potential does not necessarily need to carry an astronomical price tag, an expert has said, with new market entrants able to land a home for under...Read more

Property
‘Great Australian dream’ of owning a home lives on amid COVID
Most Australian investors and home buyers were largely undeterred by the events of 2020, remaining eager to push through with their investment plans, a new survey has found. ...Read more