Invest
A return to double dividend taxation a 'really regressive step': Keating Treasury official
Invest
A return to double dividend taxation a 'really regressive step': Keating Treasury official
It would be a “really regressive step to go back to double taxation of dividends”, a former Treasury official from the Hawke-Keating government has said.
A return to double dividend taxation a 'really regressive step': Keating Treasury official
It would be a “really regressive step to go back to double taxation of dividends”, a former Treasury official from the Hawke-Keating government has said.
Speaking at a Chi-X media briefing on Monday, Dr David Morgan AO, chairman of the alternative exchange, said when it comes to efficiency of capital markets, he’s a “big supporter” of the dividend imputation regime.
Mr Morgan was senior deputy secretary of the federal Treasury during the Hawke-Keating government, in which period the original dividend imputation reforms were introduced.
These rules meant company shares avoided the double taxation first paid by the corporation and then by the shareholder.
“I was very closely involved in it, I was defensive about it but it is my most certain knowledge that that grew the efficiency of capital markets in Australia.
“Rather than profitable companies just being able to sit on these piles of profits and not face the discipline of the market when they wanted to do M&A [mergers and acquisitions] there was a big incentive to pay that out to shareholders.”
That pay-out in turn could be reinvested in the market, bringing fresh capital in and improving the efficiency of capital markets.
He called it “the purest form of imputation” in the OECD world, with no other country providing full dividend imputation.
Speaking on Labor’s recent proposal to bring the dividend imputation system back to Keating-era arrangements, he questioned whether Australia could perform with a system “a little less pure than what we have”.
“Do we have to be that extreme? No, but it would be a really regressive step to go back to double taxation of dividends.”
Commenting on claims that the dividend imputation debate has highlighted Australian investors’ proclivity to being overweight in equities, he said it’s difficult to pinpoint the “right” allocation of equities, just as it’s tricky to determine what the right exchange rate is.
“But you know what the wrong one is,” he argued, pointing to instances where the AUD was $1.07 against the USD, or when it was $0.47 against the USD.
Nevertheless: “It's not clear to me that there is anything out of line in terms of allocation to equities.”
CEO at Chi-X, Vic Jokovic added: “Interestingly, if you pick up the paper you'll see that we're also very overweight in property and SMSFs are heavily in cash, so it seems we're overweight in everything.”
FIIG Securities’ education and research director Elizabeth Moran last week told Nest Egg the proposed changes could prompt investors to look outside Aussie shares and their attached franking credits.
“By removing the refund, investors are going to be forced to reassess their holdings and without the additional income they have to make a decision more attuned to the risk or the return of the underlying investment,” she said
“I certainly think, particularly with hybrids, when you remove the franking credit they really are not worth investing in for those investors that can’t get franking credits.”
Continuing, she suggested that removing the capacity to receive a refund could “even up the playing field” by encouraging investors to look outside of just shares and franking credits.
“We actually think it is going to help remove what some of the distortions in the market, certainly towards higher risk equities,” she said.
Senior financial planner at Omniwealth Andrew Zbik agreed that Aussie investors are overweight in shares.
He said: “There is no doubt in my mind and experience that the dividend imputation credit system has skewed Australian investors to have an overweight allocation to Australia shares.
“Australian shares are defined as a ‘growth’ asset and are susceptible to greater volatility compared to property and fixed income assets.
“The chase for yield has been attracting many Australian investors for two decades. But the consequences of a lack of diversification have been demonstrated in the last year.”
He argued that regardless of the outcome of the policy debate, it serves as a reminder that investors’ decisions should not be fuelled by tax policy.
Property
Strict cap on short-term rentals delayed following criticism
Following widespread criticism from councils and online rental companies, the introduction of NSW’s planned holiday rental code of conduct has been pushed back by three months. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne becomes Australia’s 2nd most affordable rental market
While most capital cities saw house rents soar to new record highs over the first quarter of 2021, Melbourne continued to lag behind – becoming the second most affordable capital city to rent in Aus...Read more
Property
Why home buyers are now more open to high-priced properties
Buyers are more likely to spend more to secure a property as their preferences shift towards bigger spaces with higher price tags, recent data has shown. ...Read more
Property
Government brushes aside RBA’s debt blowout warning
The government said it is not concerned about the RBA’s warning that the financial system could be rocked if there’s a debt blowout, in fact it is “very pleased” that confidence levels are lea...Read more
Property
Have first home buyers been pushed out of the market?
Latest figures have shown a monthly decline of over 3 per cent in first home buyer activity, but levels still remain at their highest since 2009. ...Read more
Property
‘Optimistic borrowers’ could endanger housing market, RBA says
The Reserve Bank of Australia has issued a caution, noting that optimistic borrowers could lead to a deterioration in the quality of lending, increasing the risk in the housing market. ...Read more
Property
6 out of 8 capital cities have hit record-high dwelling values
CoreLogic’s national home value index increased a further 2.8 per cent at the end of March, placing values 5.6 per cent above the previous market peak in October 2017. ...Read more
Property
Macro-prudential policies a matter of when, not if
The Reserve Bank of Australia has confirmed that it will keep a close eye on trends in housing borrowing given the rising housing prices and low interest rates, with market pundits confident tighter c...Read more
Home values up 30% (or are they); NFTs taking the world by storm, and why Keating thinks Aussies will be ‘poor’ in retirement
Listen now
Raging floods, the tech stock bubble and the ongoing SG debate
Listen now
Meet the Manager with Trilogy’s Philip Ryan: RBA rates and property price growth
Listen now
The continued property boom, ethical investing and engaging with your super fund
Listen now
Property
Strict cap on short-term rentals delayed following criticism
Following widespread criticism from councils and online rental companies, the introduction of NSW’s planned holiday rental code of conduct has been pushed back by three months. ...Read more
Property
Melbourne becomes Australia’s 2nd most affordable rental market
While most capital cities saw house rents soar to new record highs over the first quarter of 2021, Melbourne continued to lag behind – becoming the second most affordable capital city to rent in Aus...Read more
Property
Why home buyers are now more open to high-priced properties
Buyers are more likely to spend more to secure a property as their preferences shift towards bigger spaces with higher price tags, recent data has shown. ...Read more
Property
Government brushes aside RBA’s debt blowout warning
The government said it is not concerned about the RBA’s warning that the financial system could be rocked if there’s a debt blowout, in fact it is “very pleased” that confidence levels are lea...Read more
Property
Have first home buyers been pushed out of the market?
Latest figures have shown a monthly decline of over 3 per cent in first home buyer activity, but levels still remain at their highest since 2009. ...Read more
Property
‘Optimistic borrowers’ could endanger housing market, RBA says
The Reserve Bank of Australia has issued a caution, noting that optimistic borrowers could lead to a deterioration in the quality of lending, increasing the risk in the housing market. ...Read more
Property
6 out of 8 capital cities have hit record-high dwelling values
CoreLogic’s national home value index increased a further 2.8 per cent at the end of March, placing values 5.6 per cent above the previous market peak in October 2017. ...Read more
Property
Macro-prudential policies a matter of when, not if
The Reserve Bank of Australia has confirmed that it will keep a close eye on trends in housing borrowing given the rising housing prices and low interest rates, with market pundits confident tighter c...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
