Invest
What’s wrong with GST?
Australia’s tax system was ill-equipped to support a growing economy even before the COVID-19 crisis hit, which is why Australia’s GST system is in need of a complete overhaul, a consultancy firm has said.
What’s wrong with GST?
Australia’s tax system was ill-equipped to support a growing economy even before the COVID-19 crisis hit, which is why Australia’s GST system is in need of a complete overhaul, a consultancy firm has said.
The analysis is contained in a new report from consultancy giant PwC, How GST reform can help reboot prosperity for Australia, which flagged a number of structural factors, including an over-reliance on personal and corporate taxes, as contributing to Australia’s economic woes.
It argued that a more efficient tax system will be necessary for long-term economic recovery and budget repair “once the impacts on the economy of the pandemic have eased and reform of consumption tax is a clear option for investigation”.
According to the firm’s chief economist, Jeremy Thorpe, GST is “underperforming” in Australia.
He flagged that GST collections in 2018-19 as a proportion of all Commonwealth taxation revenue were at their lowest level since the levy was first introduced in 2001.
“Australia’s GST collections have also not kept pace with the overall rate of growth in the economy, in part because people are spending a higher proportion of their income on areas that are currently exempt, including housing, healthcare and education,” he added.
He then noted that “our GST rate of 10 per cent is one of the lowest among developed economies, and even at 12.5 per cent, would still be well below the OECD average of 19.3 per cent”.
In a properly structured reform package, Mr Thorpe said, “GST expansion should lead to higher economic growth.”
A revenue-neutral switch from less efficient taxes (principally income taxes) to consumption taxes can increase GDP, while a 1 per cent tax switch can generate somewhere in the order of 0.25 per cent to 1 per cent in extra GDP in the long run, the economist explained.
Also weighing in was PwC tax partner Paul Abbey, who considered that “the reality is that meaningful tax reform, including state and territory taxes, can only be achieved by tackling either the GST rate or its exemptions”.
He argued that GST reform could help reduce Australia’s reliance on personal income tax, “which is currently more than twice the OECD average”.
Acknowledging that discussions around GST changes have been “contentious to date”, PwC argued that reform can be possible without adversely impacting the overall equity of Australian communities.
The PwC report considered a number of scenarios as to how the GST system could be overhauled:
- A broadening of the GST base to cover five currently GST-exempt main categories – water and sewerage, childcare, health, education and food;
- An increase of the rate to 12.5 per cent without broadening the base;
- A broadening of the GST base and an increase of the GST rate to 12.5 per cent; and
- A tiered system to base current exemption items at 5 per cent, and increasing the rate on the current base to 12.5 per cent.
After modelling each scenario, PwC showed how revenue gains of $14 billion could be made by increasing the rate to 12.5 per cent but retaining the five main exemptions.
A revenue improvement of $40 billion could occur where the GST rate rises to 12.5 per cent and is coupled with a broadening of the base of goods and services covered.
About the author
About the author
Economy
COVID consequences ‘will come home to roost’
Markets are enjoying an easy ride despite the economic damage wrought by COVID-19, but “there will be a reckoning”. ...Read more
Economy
Global economy predicted to pause before soaring in 2021
2021 will provide investors the opportunity to cash in on private markets and businesses hurt, but not permanently damaged, by the pandemic as accommodating policies and pent-up demand drive global gr...Read more
Economy
5 predictions for the Australian economy in 2021
The Australian economy is tipped to be one of five nations to outshine, with a win on the health front likely to act as tailwind, a new report has revealed. ...Read more
Economy
Deloitte calls vaccine a ‘game changer’ as 77% of Aussies welcome jab
As many as three-quarters of Aussies are willing to be vaccinated once a new coronavirus vaccine becomes publicly available, new research has revealed, as Deloitte Access Economics calls the vaccine ...Read more
Economy
Markets react to Biden’s stimulus package
The US markets have reacted negatively to President-elect Joe Biden’s US$1.9 trillion ($2.44 trillion) bailout proposal, amid mass job losses as the US continues to struggle with the COVID-19 pandem...Read more
Economy
‘Aussies to keep economy ticking with $200bn in savings’
The government is counting on Aussies to use their savings to drive economic recovery once temporary support measures are wound back at the end of March. ...Read more
Economy
Business improves but COVID threat remains
The Australian economy continues to show signs of life, with businesses’ payment times improving despite recent outbreaks of COVID-19, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Economy
10 impacts the US ‘blue wave’ will have on investors
With the US Senate run-off falling to the Democrats, a new blue wave is spurring optimism for investors, a chief strategist has said. ...Read more
Economy
COVID consequences ‘will come home to roost’
Markets are enjoying an easy ride despite the economic damage wrought by COVID-19, but “there will be a reckoning”. ...Read more
Economy
Global economy predicted to pause before soaring in 2021
2021 will provide investors the opportunity to cash in on private markets and businesses hurt, but not permanently damaged, by the pandemic as accommodating policies and pent-up demand drive global gr...Read more
Economy
5 predictions for the Australian economy in 2021
The Australian economy is tipped to be one of five nations to outshine, with a win on the health front likely to act as tailwind, a new report has revealed. ...Read more
Economy
Deloitte calls vaccine a ‘game changer’ as 77% of Aussies welcome jab
As many as three-quarters of Aussies are willing to be vaccinated once a new coronavirus vaccine becomes publicly available, new research has revealed, as Deloitte Access Economics calls the vaccine ...Read more
Economy
Markets react to Biden’s stimulus package
The US markets have reacted negatively to President-elect Joe Biden’s US$1.9 trillion ($2.44 trillion) bailout proposal, amid mass job losses as the US continues to struggle with the COVID-19 pandem...Read more
Economy
‘Aussies to keep economy ticking with $200bn in savings’
The government is counting on Aussies to use their savings to drive economic recovery once temporary support measures are wound back at the end of March. ...Read more
Economy
Business improves but COVID threat remains
The Australian economy continues to show signs of life, with businesses’ payment times improving despite recent outbreaks of COVID-19, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Economy
10 impacts the US ‘blue wave’ will have on investors
With the US Senate run-off falling to the Democrats, a new blue wave is spurring optimism for investors, a chief strategist has said. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
