Invest
The unintended consequences of ESG investing
With investors continuing to focus on the benefits to the world by investing with an environmental, social and governance lens, a fund manager as highlighted the flipside for developing world economies.
The unintended consequences of ESG investing
With investors continuing to focus on the benefits to the world by investing with an environmental, social and governance lens, a fund manager as highlighted the flipside for developing world economies.
During a sustainability investment briefing, portfolio manager Alex Duffy highlighted the impact on poorer nations if the price of coal was to increase for environmental outcomes.
Mr Duffy explained: “If you look at inflation, the Indian consumer price inflation basket is something like 30 per cent energy and 40 per cent food, and most energy is fossil fuel.
“So, you can imagine what happens to Indian consumer budgets, particularly at the bottom end of the population pyramid, in terms of the wealth demographic in India where the coal price starts going up.”
While the fund manager highlighted the environmental benefits, he said “there are very severe social implications from targets and environmental outcomes in fossil fuels”.
“It isn’t clear to me that debate is being had as readily as it should be. I don’t have an answer to it. But I like to call that out as something where it’s an unintended consequence,” Mr Duffy continued.
“There are parts of the world because of the different stages of economic development that don’t have a choice. So, the social side is an important consideration.”
While discussing the social implications of moving to a greener world, Fidelity noted there is no justification to building additional coal-fired plants.
“We can all have a reasonable view around the existing stock of energy and the ways we can transition that existing stock of energy,” said Fidelity’s global head of stewardship and sustainable investing, Jenn-Hui Tan.
“It’s very hard to see why you’d finance new construction of coal-fired power both from a financial and an ecological perspective.”
nestegg has previously discussed why investors shouldn’t exclude polluting sectors from their investment portfolio.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Economy
Australia's June quarter GDP growth driven by consumer and government spending
Australia's economy has shown unexpected resilience in the June 2025 quarter, with household and government consumption driving growth despite a significant decline in public investmentRead more
Economy
Australia's GDP surprise is real but operators should heed the growth mix warning light
Australia’s June-quarter growth beat expectations on the strength of household consumption and government spending, even as public investment sagged. The upside surprise signals resilience, but the ...Read more
Economy
Households carried the quarter: what Australia’s upside GDP surprise means for strategy now
Australia’s economy expanded faster than expected in the June 2025 quarter, with GDP up 0.6 per cent quarter-on-quarter and 1.8 per cent year-on-year — the strongest pace in two years. The kicker ...Read more
Economy
Inflation dynamics in Australia: Electricity subsidies and labour market in focus
In a recent economic analysis, experts from State Street have highlighted significant developments in Australia's inflation landscape, attributing the changes primarily to the withdrawal of ...Read more
Economy
Australia's economic growth driven by consumer and government spending: A closer look at the June quarter
Australia's economy has delivered a surprising performance for the June 2025 quarter, surpassing expectations with a growth rate of 0.6% quarter-on-quarter and 1.8% year-on-year. This unexpected ...Read more
Economy
Australian and Korean leaders meet to unlock billions in new trade opportunities
In a significant effort to bolster economic ties and explore new avenues for investment, Australian and Korean leaders, alongside business executives and government officials, are gathering in Seoul ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s growth beat is real — but it’s the wrong kind for capacity
Australia’s economy outpaced forecasts in the June quarter as households opened wallets and government spending did the heavy lifting, even as public investment sagged. The signal for boardrooms: ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s growth is back—but it’s the wrong kind of strong
GDP surprised on the upside in the June quarter, powered by households and government outlays even as public investment slumped. The Reserve Bank stayed hawkish, signalling that sticky services ...Read more
Economy
Australia's June quarter GDP growth driven by consumer and government spending
Australia's economy has shown unexpected resilience in the June 2025 quarter, with household and government consumption driving growth despite a significant decline in public investmentRead more
Economy
Australia's GDP surprise is real but operators should heed the growth mix warning light
Australia’s June-quarter growth beat expectations on the strength of household consumption and government spending, even as public investment sagged. The upside surprise signals resilience, but the ...Read more
Economy
Households carried the quarter: what Australia’s upside GDP surprise means for strategy now
Australia’s economy expanded faster than expected in the June 2025 quarter, with GDP up 0.6 per cent quarter-on-quarter and 1.8 per cent year-on-year — the strongest pace in two years. The kicker ...Read more
Economy
Inflation dynamics in Australia: Electricity subsidies and labour market in focus
In a recent economic analysis, experts from State Street have highlighted significant developments in Australia's inflation landscape, attributing the changes primarily to the withdrawal of ...Read more
Economy
Australia's economic growth driven by consumer and government spending: A closer look at the June quarter
Australia's economy has delivered a surprising performance for the June 2025 quarter, surpassing expectations with a growth rate of 0.6% quarter-on-quarter and 1.8% year-on-year. This unexpected ...Read more
Economy
Australian and Korean leaders meet to unlock billions in new trade opportunities
In a significant effort to bolster economic ties and explore new avenues for investment, Australian and Korean leaders, alongside business executives and government officials, are gathering in Seoul ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s growth beat is real — but it’s the wrong kind for capacity
Australia’s economy outpaced forecasts in the June quarter as households opened wallets and government spending did the heavy lifting, even as public investment sagged. The signal for boardrooms: ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s growth is back—but it’s the wrong kind of strong
GDP surprised on the upside in the June quarter, powered by households and government outlays even as public investment slumped. The Reserve Bank stayed hawkish, signalling that sticky services ...Read more
