Invest
‘Right size, wrong shape’ stimulus package
The announcement of the Morrison government’s $17 billion stimulus has been met with some criticism as a think tank labeled it “the right size, but the wrong shape”.
‘Right size, wrong shape’ stimulus package
The announcement of the Morrison government’s $17 billion stimulus has been met with some criticism as a think tank labeled it “the right size, but the wrong shape”.
According to The Australian Institute, the package is the “right size initial response, but the shape is wrong”, with the most effective form of stimulus making up less than a quarter of the total package.
The Australian Institute senior economist Matt Grudnoff believes the cash splash should have been focused at consumers instead of businesses.
“The Prime Minister asserted $3 in every $4 dollars of stimulus would go to business – it should be the other way round. Common sense and recent history tells us that businesses don’t spend when their sales are falling.”
“The best way to help Australian businesses right now is to get cash through the cash registers. Businesses with plenty of customers don’t lay off staff.”
“The most effective part of the package is the $750 to welfare recipients. We know people living on the brink spend any extra money they receive on essentials, and this will support demand in the economy,” Mr Grudnoff said.
While The Australian Institute has questioned the stimulus package, KPMG’s chief economist Dr Bendan Rynne has praised the stimulus package.
“KPMG believes that the government stimulus package was comprehensive, well targeted and represented a circuit-breaker to ensure that Australia does not descend into a more acute and protracted economic downturn due to businesses and households losing confidence,” Dr Rynne said.
The firm estimates that, assuming it is implemented in an optimal and efficient manner, it could add slightly over $20 billion to GDP in the next two years.
The consulting firms suggests there are two caveats to this – first, in order for the “Delivering support for business investment” components of the stimulus package to be implemented and successful, small-to-medium businesses will need to invest slightly more than $30 billion in the Australian economy over the next two years. This is a significant ask, especially in an uncertain domestic and global business environment.
Second, the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic are unfolding in real time. If the pandemic turns out to be more acute and lasts longer than is currently anticipated, then the economic impacts may be significantly greater.
Overall, KPMG believes the economic impact will largely depend on consumer behaviour, which could be both a larger and prolonged risk than their modelling entalis.
“Despite evidence of households engaging in stockpiling behaviour that appears irrational and the recent heavy falls in financial markets, we believe the probability of the pandemic resulting in a full-blown panic scenario remains low.
“We anticipate governments have an opportunity to implement a range of policies that can assist with reducing uncertainty and minimise the chances of such a scenario materialising, as the Australian, US and UK governments did last week,” Dr Rynne concluded.
nestegg has previously reported the Coalition government's stimulus package.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Economy
Economist calls for July RBA rate cut following inflation data
An economist from State Street Global Advisors has called for the Reserve Bank of Australia to cut interest rates in July following today's Consumer Price Index data for June. Read more
Economy
GDP data prompts economist to predict faster RBA rate cuts
Australia's latest GDP growth data has come in significantly below expectations, prompting an economist to suggest the Reserve Bank may need to ease monetary policy more aggressively. Read more
Economy
Global markets face turbulent start amid tariff concerns, but outlook remains cautious
Global equity and bond markets have experienced a turbulent start to 2025, primarily due to concerns that a potential tariff-driven trade war could heighten inflation and recession risks. Read more
Economy
RBA may cut rates faster if GDP data disappoints, economists say
The Reserve Bank of Australia may cut interest rates more quickly if next week's GDP data disappoints, economists said following today's consumer price index data for May. Read more
Economy
RBA delivers widely expected rate cut as inflation optimism balances global uncertainty
The Reserve Bank of Australia has cut the cash rate by 25 basis points, delivering on widespread market expectations while signalling a clearer directional shift towards less restrictive monetary ...Read more
Economy
Economist warns strong jobs data may delay further RBA rate cuts
Strong employment growth in April has put expectations for multiple interest rate cuts at risk, though upcoming economic data may clarify the need for lower rates, according to State Street Global ...Read more
Economy
Australian inflation continues downward trend, nearing RBA target
The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) has reported that the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose 2.7 per cent in the year to August, down from 3.5 per cent in July and 3.8 per cent in June. Read more
Economy
UK markets poised for gains after election, global geopolitical risks remain
Chris Iggo, Chief Investment Officer at AXA Investment Managers, has provided an optimistic outlook for UK markets following the recent general election, while cautioning about ongoing global ...Read more
Economy
Economist calls for July RBA rate cut following inflation data
An economist from State Street Global Advisors has called for the Reserve Bank of Australia to cut interest rates in July following today's Consumer Price Index data for June. Read more
Economy
GDP data prompts economist to predict faster RBA rate cuts
Australia's latest GDP growth data has come in significantly below expectations, prompting an economist to suggest the Reserve Bank may need to ease monetary policy more aggressively. Read more
Economy
Global markets face turbulent start amid tariff concerns, but outlook remains cautious
Global equity and bond markets have experienced a turbulent start to 2025, primarily due to concerns that a potential tariff-driven trade war could heighten inflation and recession risks. Read more
Economy
RBA may cut rates faster if GDP data disappoints, economists say
The Reserve Bank of Australia may cut interest rates more quickly if next week's GDP data disappoints, economists said following today's consumer price index data for May. Read more
Economy
RBA delivers widely expected rate cut as inflation optimism balances global uncertainty
The Reserve Bank of Australia has cut the cash rate by 25 basis points, delivering on widespread market expectations while signalling a clearer directional shift towards less restrictive monetary ...Read more
Economy
Economist warns strong jobs data may delay further RBA rate cuts
Strong employment growth in April has put expectations for multiple interest rate cuts at risk, though upcoming economic data may clarify the need for lower rates, according to State Street Global ...Read more
Economy
Australian inflation continues downward trend, nearing RBA target
The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) has reported that the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose 2.7 per cent in the year to August, down from 3.5 per cent in July and 3.8 per cent in June. Read more
Economy
UK markets poised for gains after election, global geopolitical risks remain
Chris Iggo, Chief Investment Officer at AXA Investment Managers, has provided an optimistic outlook for UK markets following the recent general election, while cautioning about ongoing global ...Read more
