Most read
Pros and cons: Working in the gig economy...
Pros and cons: Working in the gig economy...
Latest Podcast
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening t...
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening t...
Resources
There is $17.5 billion in lost and unclaimed super across ...
There is $17.5 billion in lost and unclaimed super across ...
Invest
Low interest rates and QE won’t save the economy
As the RBA is widely tipped to lower the official cash rate to 0.5 per cent next month, its effectiveness has been questioned by a fund manager.
Low interest rates and QE won’t save the economy
As the RBA is widely tipped to lower the official cash rate to 0.5 per cent next month, its effectiveness has been questioned by a fund manager.
In November last year, Reserve Bank governor Dr Philip Lowe announced that the lower bound for the Australian cash rate was 0.25 per cent before a version of quantitative easing (QE) would be used.
Graham Cooke, insights manager at Finder, said QE will be on the cards if the rate cuts continue to be ineffective beyond the housing market.
“The RBA said they may look to alternative stimulus methods once the rate hits 0.25 per cent.
“We’re only two cuts away from that, and the three cuts of 2019 have failed to stimulate anything beyond the housing market,” Mr Cooke said.
According to Chris Bedingfield, principal at Quay Global Investors, introducing quantitative easing (QE) – which the central bank has alluded to following two rate reductions – is “doomed to fail”.
Leaning on lessons learnt from other countries, Mr Bedingfield said, “We know Japan has used QE since 2001 for little or no inflationary or stimulatory effect. Further, there appears to be little evidence it worked in the US, Europe or the UK.”
The idea that low interest rates and QE support asset prices sounds intuitively correct (i.e. “money printing”) but is not widely supported by observation or the operational realities of monetary policy.
“While many market commentators are predicting further interest rate cuts in 2020, we have serious doubts about the efficacy of this strategy.
“We only need to look at Japan, which moved to a zero interest rate policy in 1995, to see that it just doesn’t work – over the past 30 years, the Nikkei 225 Index has fallen 41 per cent,” Mr Bedingfield said.
Mr Bedingfield said QE has largely failed to deliver because functionally it operates as a private sector tax aimed at the banking system, the wealthy and anyone that holds a superannuation account.
“QE encourages the sale of low-risk low-yielding assets for even lower-yielding cash, resulting in lower net interest income to the private sector. Where does this income go? To the central bank on the other side of the trade, acquiring higher-yielding bonds for the lower-cost cash.
“In effect, the central bank is making an investment spread at the expense of the natural holders of bonds (including banks and superannuation accounts)
“In Australia, excess capital (profits) are remitted to the Treasury – in the same way that cash receipts from the Tax Office are remitted to the Treasury.”
“Investors seeking Aussie QE should be careful what they wish for – essentially, they are asking for the wider economy to be taxed.
Mr Bedingfield noted five myths about quantitative easing:
Myth 1 – QE is “money printing”, characterised as injecting cash into the economy.
The truth is that QE is nothing more than an asset swap between the central bank and the private sector. The swap is one form of monetary instrument (bonds) for another (cash).
Myth 2 – QE will inject new spending power into the economy.
Owners of bonds are natural savers – there is scant evidence to show swapping bonds for cash increases spending outcomes in the real economy.
Myth 3 – QE will force down long-term interest rates.
US history – and 10-year bond yields – actually shows that when QE commenced, long-term interest rates rose. And when QE ended, long-term interest rates fell.
Myth 4 – QE provides cash for banks to lend.
Banks do not need deposits or reserves to lend. They simply need enough regulatory capital (from shareholders) and a sufficient supply of credit-worthy borrowers to create a loan: and the loan creates the deposit. Therefore the mechanics of QE, which adds deposits and reserves in exchange for bonds, do not impact banks’ ability or willingness to extend loans.
Myth 5 – QE drives long-term share market performance.
The easy response to this myth is Japan. There, QE has been implemented for 20 years, and the equity market remains around 40 per cent below its 1989 peak. Supporters of QE (i.e. Bank of Japan) argue QE has not worked “yet” – but how much more time is needed?
About the author
About the author
Economy
Next step of COVID recovery begins with the budget, PM says
Prime Minister Scott Morrison has his sights set on a business-led economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, relying on deregulation to help grow Australian businesses. ...Read more
Economy
Frydenberg promises jobs and services budget
The federal Treasurer has announced the budget will put jobs at the forefront, with fiscal repair likely to be put on the backburner, as the country looks to recover from the first economic downturn i...Read more
Economy
6 reasons not to worry about inflation
Despite consumer expectation of strong inflation, a leading expert has noted six reasons why the world economy will not experience strong inflation growth, even with large government spending and reco...Read more
Economy
Labour market bounceback sees consumer confidence reach decade high
The end of JobKeeper and a botched vaccine rollout have not dented consumer sentiment, with strong labour market data leading to consumer confidence rising to levels not seen since the GFC recovery, a...Read more
Economy
Vaccine rollout delay could set back herd immunity by 12 months, costing billions
Australia’s delay in the vaccine rollout is tipped to cost the nation over $1.4 billion and see residents locked down for an additional 11.1 days, an industry expert has said. ...Read more
Economy
Economy may have just hit pre-COVID levels
The Australian economy is tipped to bounce back to its pre-pandemic level within weeks, according to the IMF. ...Read more
Economy
New Zealand reveals travel bubble arrangement with Australia
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has announced that the country will begin a quarantine-free travel bubble with Australia within a fortnight. ...Read more
Economy
RBA reveals April cash rate call
The Reserve Bank of Australia has made its April call on the official cash rate, following its decision to cut the rate to a record low in November. ...Read more
Is the market overheating; should ETFs take your fancy, and what’s happening to the low and middle income tax offset?
Listen now
Home values up 30% (or are they); NFTs taking the world by storm, and why Keating thinks Aussies will be ‘poor’ in retirement
Listen now
Raging floods, the tech stock bubble and the ongoing SG debate
Listen now
Meet the Manager with Trilogy’s Philip Ryan: RBA rates and property price growth
Listen now
Economy
Next step of COVID recovery begins with the budget, PM says
Prime Minister Scott Morrison has his sights set on a business-led economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, relying on deregulation to help grow Australian businesses. ...Read more
Economy
Frydenberg promises jobs and services budget
The federal Treasurer has announced the budget will put jobs at the forefront, with fiscal repair likely to be put on the backburner, as the country looks to recover from the first economic downturn i...Read more
Economy
6 reasons not to worry about inflation
Despite consumer expectation of strong inflation, a leading expert has noted six reasons why the world economy will not experience strong inflation growth, even with large government spending and reco...Read more
Economy
Labour market bounceback sees consumer confidence reach decade high
The end of JobKeeper and a botched vaccine rollout have not dented consumer sentiment, with strong labour market data leading to consumer confidence rising to levels not seen since the GFC recovery, a...Read more
Economy
Vaccine rollout delay could set back herd immunity by 12 months, costing billions
Australia’s delay in the vaccine rollout is tipped to cost the nation over $1.4 billion and see residents locked down for an additional 11.1 days, an industry expert has said. ...Read more
Economy
Economy may have just hit pre-COVID levels
The Australian economy is tipped to bounce back to its pre-pandemic level within weeks, according to the IMF. ...Read more
Economy
New Zealand reveals travel bubble arrangement with Australia
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has announced that the country will begin a quarantine-free travel bubble with Australia within a fortnight. ...Read more
Economy
RBA reveals April cash rate call
The Reserve Bank of Australia has made its April call on the official cash rate, following its decision to cut the rate to a record low in November. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
