Invest
‘Fancy spin and slick marketing’: Pre-budget speech fails to impress
Treasurer Josh Frydenberg has failed to commit to a strategy, walking away from an austerity budget on 11 May but again relying on businesses to do the heavy lifting, his pre-budget speech revealed.
‘Fancy spin and slick marketing’: Pre-budget speech fails to impress
Treasurer Josh Frydenberg has failed to commit to a strategy, walking away from an austerity budget on 11 May but again relying on businesses to do the heavy lifting, his pre-budget speech revealed.
Just two years ago, the government promised to deliver the first surplus in over a decade, declaring “today we’re bringing the budget back in black”.
Now the Treasurer is looking to abandon his low-debt austerity stance, instead trying to drive the economy into a position of strength through lowering the unemployment rate, strengthening wages and inflating Australia’s debt away.
He used his pre-budget remarks at the Australian Chamber of Commerce to announce the government’s changing tactics. However, he failed to announce any plan as to how the government will achieve its promises.
“Looking further ahead, our challenge once we recover from this crisis is to again rebuild our fiscal buffers,” Mr Frydenberg said.
“We have done it before and we will do it again.”
“But we won’t be undertaking any sharp pivots towards ‘austerity’.”
However, Mr Frydenberg stopped short of completely splashing the cash, instead putting the onus on the business sector to carry the recovery.
“Large-scale government support is no substitute for sustainable jobs in profitable firms” and that the government would instead focus on growing the economy in order to service its debt obligations.
His remarks were heavily criticised by opposition treasurer Jim Chalmers, who called the speech “fancy spin and slick marketing”.
“What really matters is all of that job insecurity, underemployment and stagnant wages,” Mr Chalmers said.
“This is the same guy who printed the ‘back in black’ mugs. These are the same people that said when debt was $200 billion, it was a disaster, but now it’s heading north of a trillion dollars is management, prudent and sensible.”
While highlighting that, on the surface, increasing employment and spending during a crisis is prudent management, he questioned the plan which failed to provide any further details as to how the government will get Australians into better-paying jobs.
“This treasurer thinks he can spin and grin his way to full employment when what we really need in the budget is a plan to achieve full employment.
“Now this speech once again is all about politics and not economics. What this speech is saying to the Australian people is there will still be austerity, there will still be budget cuts, but the Australian people have to wait till the other side of an election to find out what they might be.
“All this speech does is push budget nasties from this side of the election to the next side of the election.”
Mr Chalmers said he welcomes the recovery from the deepest recession Australia has had this century, but highlighted how the recovery is not even, with those on the bottom being pushed further behind.
“We still have almost 2 million Australians who can’t find a job or can’t find enough hours to support their loved ones,” Mr Chalmers said.
The opposition treasurer said the budget cannot be another missed opportunity to invest in Australia’s people and their employment, “with the Treasurer simply sprouting numbers without releasing details as to how he will improve Australia’s unemployment rate”.
“It needs to be an opportunity to make the necessary investments in employment to have an actual jobs plan and not just slick marketing spin.
“What we desperately need to see in this recovery is Australians able to get ahead, to find work, to find the hours they need so they are not left behind as we recover from this deep and damaging recession,” Mr Chalmers said.
RELATED ARTICLES
-
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
-
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
-
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
About the author
About the author
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
Headline inflation easing is good optics; balance sheets feel something different. With year‑on‑year CPI down to 3.4% in November from 3.8%, hopes for rate relief are rising — but policymakers remain ...Read more
Economy
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
Australia’s headline CPI edged down to 3.4% year-on-year in November, from 3.8%, easing immediate pressure but not eliminating the risk of further tightening. With services inflation sticky and ...Read more
Economy
Higher-for-longer, not higher forever: How Australia’s inflation ‘surprise’ is rewriting CFO playbooks for 2026
Australia’s latest inflation pulse eased but didn’t budge bank outlooks: near‑term rate cuts are still a long shot, with some houses flagging upside risk. That steadier‑for‑longer cash rate is pushing ...Read more
Economy
Australia's inflation illusion: the real challenge lies in pricing power and productivity
Headline inflation has cooled to 3.4% year-on-year, but the Reserve Bank’s caution—and a still‑hot housing backdrop—mean the rate threat hasn’t left the room. For boards, the next few quarters are ...Read more
Economy
When house prices lift, tills ring: A case study in turning Australia’s wealth effect into growth
Australia’s latest upswing in household wealth, anchored by higher dwelling values, is more than a feel‑good statistic—it is a profit and planning signal. The ABS notes property’s centrality to ...Read more
Economy
RBA's hawkish stance reflects inflation concerns, State Street economist comments
In a recent statement, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has signaled a hawkish stance on interest rates, drawing insights from financial experts about the implications for Australia's economic ...Read more
Economy
Navigating the inflation maze: How CFOs can outsmart economic hurdles in Australia
Fresh inflation data have cooled expectations of near-term rate cuts in Australia, intensifying pressure on margins, capital allocation and demand. Rather than wait for monetary relief that may not ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
Headline inflation easing is good optics; balance sheets feel something different. With year‑on‑year CPI down to 3.4% in November from 3.8%, hopes for rate relief are rising — but policymakers remain ...Read more
Economy
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
Australia’s headline CPI edged down to 3.4% year-on-year in November, from 3.8%, easing immediate pressure but not eliminating the risk of further tightening. With services inflation sticky and ...Read more
Economy
Higher-for-longer, not higher forever: How Australia’s inflation ‘surprise’ is rewriting CFO playbooks for 2026
Australia’s latest inflation pulse eased but didn’t budge bank outlooks: near‑term rate cuts are still a long shot, with some houses flagging upside risk. That steadier‑for‑longer cash rate is pushing ...Read more
Economy
Australia's inflation illusion: the real challenge lies in pricing power and productivity
Headline inflation has cooled to 3.4% year-on-year, but the Reserve Bank’s caution—and a still‑hot housing backdrop—mean the rate threat hasn’t left the room. For boards, the next few quarters are ...Read more
Economy
When house prices lift, tills ring: A case study in turning Australia’s wealth effect into growth
Australia’s latest upswing in household wealth, anchored by higher dwelling values, is more than a feel‑good statistic—it is a profit and planning signal. The ABS notes property’s centrality to ...Read more
Economy
RBA's hawkish stance reflects inflation concerns, State Street economist comments
In a recent statement, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has signaled a hawkish stance on interest rates, drawing insights from financial experts about the implications for Australia's economic ...Read more
Economy
Navigating the inflation maze: How CFOs can outsmart economic hurdles in Australia
Fresh inflation data have cooled expectations of near-term rate cuts in Australia, intensifying pressure on margins, capital allocation and demand. Rather than wait for monetary relief that may not ...Read more
