Invest
Does the central bank favour the rich?
Current monetary policy strategies, including slashing cash rates and quantitative easing, are inflating asset prices and creating a greater inequality gap, an industry expert has said.
Does the central bank favour the rich?
Current monetary policy strategies, including slashing cash rates and quantitative easing, are inflating asset prices and creating a greater inequality gap, an industry expert has said.
Monetary policies, including QE, work via central banks creating money to buy government bonds from banks. It is hoped that the banks will then lend this cash to the real economy.
As the central bank buys government bonds, demand increases and the price of these securities goes up. Subsequently the yield, or interest rate, on government bonds falls, slashing borrowing costs for households, businesses and the government.
During a recent Fidelity International media briefing, cross asset investment specialist Anthony Doyle told viewers how central banks through QE are simply raising the price of assets.
“One thing we do know is low interest rates and unconventional monetary policy tend to inflate financial assets and generally increase income inequality,” Mr Doyle said.
He noted those who have assets generally do well in this type of environment because the policy is designed to lift asset prices, which creates a bigger gap between the rich and poor.
“And if you think about the sectors and the types of workers that have been most impacted by the current crisis in terms of the lockdown measures that have been undertaken, it tends to be lower-skilled workers on lower incomes,” the analyst continued.
“Because the unemployment rate has risen, there is a lot of spare capacity in the economy, so they don’t necessarily get the wage increases to compensate for rising inflation either.”
“With this in mind, you see the increase in polarisation to the left and the right of politics.”
However, while explaining that economists are unaware of the real-world implications for such policies on the economy long-term, he notes central banks believe they need to act.
“Bear in mind central banks will articulate the reason they are undertaking these actions is because the counterfactual is so bad. If they didn’t do this, you’d have labour markets and unemployment rates much higher than they are,” Mr Doyle said.
The analyst also believes the independence of central banks and government action is likely to diminish, with the two working hand-in-hand to grow the economy.
“The RBA is making it clear that by buying government bonds at the three-year maturity and by having a set target in terms of the yield curve control, it isn’t monetary finance of the budget.
“For me, it isn’t direct finance of the budget, but it is indirect finance of the budget. They are saying we are keeping yields low so you can borrow and you should be borrowing to fill this gap that has been left by private investment and the private sector not going about its normal business because of the shutdowns you’ve enforced,” Mr Doyle noted.
The analyst came out in support of the government supporting the economy, noting they should fill the hole and borrow money at a record-low rate.
“I think you’re seeing this explicitly from Philip Lowe saying the government, states and territories have ready access to capital markets, they can borrow at historic low rates of interest, and public debt is entirely manageable and affordable.
“With this in mind, the RBA and the bond market, these low yields are a gift to governments. They should be borrowing, they should be expanding fiscally in order to support the Australian economy.”
“In terms of central bank independence, I think monetary and fiscal policy will work closer together in Australia and abroad,” Mr Doyle concluded.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Economy
RBA's interest rate hike impacts Australian employment landscape
The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has decided to increase interest rates by 25 basis points, raising the cash rate to 3.85%. This move, aimed at controlling inflation, has elicited responses from ...Read more
Economy
RBA’s latest rate hike sparks debate over economic impact
In a surprising move, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has increased the cash rate, signalling a significant shift in its monetary policy approach. This decision comes amid a backdrop of unexpected ...Read more
Economy
When inflation reopens the rate door: A broker-sector case study in defending margins, clients and share
Australia’s latest trimmed-mean inflation reading at 3.3% has revived the prospect of another Reserve Bank move and put lenders, brokers and borrowers back on a tightening footing. This case study ...Read more
Economy
Inflation rise dampens hopes for interest rate cuts as employment dynamics shift
In a development that has dashed hopes for an interest rate cut, Australia's Consumer Price Index (CPI) has surged back to 3.8%, erasing the progress made since October. This unexpected rise in ...Read more
Economy
Inflation surge poses challenges for small businesses and consumers
The latest inflation figures have sparked concern among Australian businesses and consumers alike, with the rising costs expected to influence the Reserve Bank of Australia's (RBA) upcoming interest ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
Headline inflation easing is good optics; balance sheets feel something different. With year‑on‑year CPI down to 3.4% in November from 3.8%, hopes for rate relief are rising — but policymakers remain ...Read more
Economy
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
Australia’s headline CPI edged down to 3.4% year-on-year in November, from 3.8%, easing immediate pressure but not eliminating the risk of further tightening. With services inflation sticky and ...Read more
Economy
RBA's interest rate hike impacts Australian employment landscape
The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has decided to increase interest rates by 25 basis points, raising the cash rate to 3.85%. This move, aimed at controlling inflation, has elicited responses from ...Read more
Economy
RBA’s latest rate hike sparks debate over economic impact
In a surprising move, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has increased the cash rate, signalling a significant shift in its monetary policy approach. This decision comes amid a backdrop of unexpected ...Read more
Economy
When inflation reopens the rate door: A broker-sector case study in defending margins, clients and share
Australia’s latest trimmed-mean inflation reading at 3.3% has revived the prospect of another Reserve Bank move and put lenders, brokers and borrowers back on a tightening footing. This case study ...Read more
Economy
Inflation rise dampens hopes for interest rate cuts as employment dynamics shift
In a development that has dashed hopes for an interest rate cut, Australia's Consumer Price Index (CPI) has surged back to 3.8%, erasing the progress made since October. This unexpected rise in ...Read more
Economy
Inflation surge poses challenges for small businesses and consumers
The latest inflation figures have sparked concern among Australian businesses and consumers alike, with the rising costs expected to influence the Reserve Bank of Australia's (RBA) upcoming interest ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s spending surprise raises the odds of a February rate move — here’s how to protect margin and momentum
Household outlays are running hotter than economists expected, with the latest ABS readings showing broad-based gains across services and goods. That resilience is exactly the kind of demand impulse ...Read more
Economy
Australia’s inflation cools to 3.4% — why the RBA’s next move still isn’t a lay‑up for business
Headline inflation easing is good optics; balance sheets feel something different. With year‑on‑year CPI down to 3.4% in November from 3.8%, hopes for rate relief are rising — but policymakers remain ...Read more
Economy
Inflation cools to 3.4% — but the RBA’s reaction function keeps businesses on a knife-edge
Australia’s headline CPI edged down to 3.4% year-on-year in November, from 3.8%, easing immediate pressure but not eliminating the risk of further tightening. With services inflation sticky and ...Read more
