Borrow
Closed v open mortgage: What’s more costly?
An open mortgage allows you to pay off your loan in full at any time without getting penalised. This absence of a penalty for knocking down a large debt early is what attracts many to choose an open mortgage.
Closed v open mortgage: What’s more costly?
A closed mortgage only allows a limited amount of additional payments before you get hit with a penalty. Likewise, you’ll be required to pay a fee if you break any of the loan’s terms.
Many people think that it’s best to choose an open mortgage if they plan to pay off their mortgage early. However, some experts believe that this way of choosing may be inaccurate and could even unnecessarily increase the total cost of the loan.
Which is more costly?
Either of the two types of mortgages can be more costly than the other – it all depends on your current and future financial circumstances.
Open mortgages may give borrowers more flexibility, as well as the freedom to pay off loans early, but it does so in exchange for higher interest payments. This means you’ll be paying a higher amount regularly in exchange for the possibility that you’ll have enough extra money to put towards your mortgage repayments.
Closed mortgages, on the other hand, may charge a penalty for extra payments and paying off the loan early, but they also offer some of the lowest interest rates.
You’ll be paying your lender less money on interest even if you’re locked in to pay for a longer term. But any break in the terms of the loan, such as exceeding the allowable prepayment limit, would mean additional payment due to penalties.
To determine which type will cost you more money, you’ll have to compute how much your repayments are likely to be and how the penalties will be calculated for a closed mortgage.
Lenders generally compute the penalty as three times your monthly interest rate.
For instance, if you have a $300,000 home loan (closed mortgage) with a 2.95 per cent interest rate for 25 years, you will pay a total of $221,250 in interest over the full term of the loan ($737.5 monthly).
If you have an open mortgage with a higher interest rate at 3.75 per cent, you will pay a total of $281,250 in interest ($937.5 monthly).
If you break your closed mortgage, your penalty will be $2,212.5 on top of your full payment. Despite this penalty, a closed mortgage would still save you more money in the long run.
However, this does not apply to all loans.
An open mortgage may still save you more money if you avail the right features.
It’s best to discuss your financial circumstances and future plans with a broker so they can give you advice that is more appropriate to your circumstances.
About the author

About the author


Loans
Beyond the mortgage: SME lending is where growth, margin and loyalty are shifting
SME credit is moving from branch desks to APIs, from collateral to cashflow, and from monoline lenders to embedded platforms. For banks, fintechs and brokers, this is not a side-bet—it’s where ...Read more

Loans
Debunking credit myths leads to big wins with transparent hardship design
New research from Arca’s CreditSmart initiative surfaces a stubborn problem: Australians under financial strain are avoiding hardship support because they fear lasting damage to their creditRead more

Loans
No-deposit home loans in Australia: The growth gambit that tests risk discipline
A new no-deposit mortgage has landed in Australia, promising to crack the hardest nut in housing—fronting a deposit—while raising old questions about risk and capital. For lenders, the product doubles ...Read more

Loans
Rate relief ignites a mortgage scramble — and a technology arms race
Australia’s rate easing has flipped mortgage demand from ‘defend and retain’ to ‘originate and grow’. Refinance waves and a rekindled purchase market are colliding with digitisation, broker dominance ...Read more

Loans
Trust is the moat: How brokers can win in an AI-accelerated, commoditised mortgage market
In an evolving mortgage landscape where algorithms are levelling the playing field, Australian mortgage brokers are finding that trust, rather than price or speed, is becoming their most valuable ...Read more

Loans
CreditSmart revolutionises hardship support and lenders risk missing out
Australians under cost‑of‑living pressure are sidestepping hardship help because they fear a permanent stain on their credit file. Arca’s CreditSmart initiative has thrust this misconception into the ...Read more

Loans
Australia’s 40‑year mortgage moment: affordability optics, lifetime cost, and the new risk calculus
Forty‑year home loans are shifting from niche to feature in Australia, led by challenger banks and mutuals courting first‑home buyers. The headline promise—lower monthly repayments—masks a material ...Read more

Loans
The mortgage-regret economy: Why borrower confusion is reshaping Australia’s home-loan playbook
Mortgage regret has become a measurable market force, driving record refinancing, rising arrears off a low base, and a scramble by lenders and brokers to redesign the borrower journey. With the ...Read more

Loans
Beyond the mortgage: SME lending is where growth, margin and loyalty are shifting
SME credit is moving from branch desks to APIs, from collateral to cashflow, and from monoline lenders to embedded platforms. For banks, fintechs and brokers, this is not a side-bet—it’s where ...Read more

Loans
Debunking credit myths leads to big wins with transparent hardship design
New research from Arca’s CreditSmart initiative surfaces a stubborn problem: Australians under financial strain are avoiding hardship support because they fear lasting damage to their creditRead more

Loans
No-deposit home loans in Australia: The growth gambit that tests risk discipline
A new no-deposit mortgage has landed in Australia, promising to crack the hardest nut in housing—fronting a deposit—while raising old questions about risk and capital. For lenders, the product doubles ...Read more

Loans
Rate relief ignites a mortgage scramble — and a technology arms race
Australia’s rate easing has flipped mortgage demand from ‘defend and retain’ to ‘originate and grow’. Refinance waves and a rekindled purchase market are colliding with digitisation, broker dominance ...Read more

Loans
Trust is the moat: How brokers can win in an AI-accelerated, commoditised mortgage market
In an evolving mortgage landscape where algorithms are levelling the playing field, Australian mortgage brokers are finding that trust, rather than price or speed, is becoming their most valuable ...Read more

Loans
CreditSmart revolutionises hardship support and lenders risk missing out
Australians under cost‑of‑living pressure are sidestepping hardship help because they fear a permanent stain on their credit file. Arca’s CreditSmart initiative has thrust this misconception into the ...Read more

Loans
Australia’s 40‑year mortgage moment: affordability optics, lifetime cost, and the new risk calculus
Forty‑year home loans are shifting from niche to feature in Australia, led by challenger banks and mutuals courting first‑home buyers. The headline promise—lower monthly repayments—masks a material ...Read more

Loans
The mortgage-regret economy: Why borrower confusion is reshaping Australia’s home-loan playbook
Mortgage regret has become a measurable market force, driving record refinancing, rising arrears off a low base, and a scramble by lenders and brokers to redesign the borrower journey. With the ...Read more