Retirement
Sector takes aim at ISA’s ‘distorted SMSF analysis’
The SMSF industry has hit back at analysis from Industry Super Australia, which argued that SMSF balances and limited recourse borrowing arrangements were driving up property prices.
Sector takes aim at ISA’s ‘distorted SMSF analysis’
The SMSF industry has hit back at analysis from Industry Super Australia, which argued that SMSF balances and limited recourse borrowing arrangements were driving up property prices.
Earlier this week, Industry Super Australia (ISA) released a seething analysis of SMSFs and took aim at low balance funds and the substantial growth in use of gearing strategies.
The paper referred to the $25.4 billion currently in LRBAs and accused SMSFs of driving up property prices through the use of LRBAs. LRBAs, or limited recourse borrowing arrangements, are where the fund borrows money to purchase an investment.
SMSF Association chief executive John Maroney said while there may be $12 billion currently invested in residential property through LRBAs, this has to be put in the context of the $6.05 trillion housing market as of June 2016.
“In other words, LRBAs only comprise 0.20 per cent of the housing market – hardly a figure to shake the market,” said Mr Maroney.
“This selective use of statistics to portray SMSFs as a ‘market mover’ in the residential property market is just one example of how the SMSF sector is being ‘unfairly targeted’ regarding property investment.”
The ISA analysis also criticised the high growth rate in SMSF borrowings from $497 million in June 2009 to $25.4 billion by June 2016.
“What they fail to add is that LRBAs still only make up 4 per cent of SMSF assets at $25.4 billion that they started from a small base in 2009, and a change in the way the ATO reported LRBA statistics in 2013, when the figure was revised from $2.6 billion to $8.3 billion, has distorted the statistical analysis,” explained Mr Maroney.
He also stressed that the ATO statistics being used in the analysis have been compiled from the SMSF annual return, which is a regulatory tool and can limit the quality of SMSF data on investment issues.
“Better information on LRBAs will be sourced from the 2017 SMSF Annual Return that requires more granular information from SMSFs on their LRBA investments,” he said.
The ISA analysis also received criticism from others in the SMSF industry, with chartered accountant Wayne Wanders stating that the ISA analysis “compares apples with oranges and provides false and misleading information”.
Mr Wanders was particularly critical of ISA’s analysis of performance returns between APRA-regulated funds and SMSFs.
“It would take Industry Super Australia less than five minutes of reading the glossary attached to the ATO publication on which this briefing note is based to determine that the returns reported by the ATO in its analysis of SMSF performance are net of member’s insurance premiums,” said Mr Wanders.
In the Industry Super Australia’s briefing note, Mr Wanders said they compare the performance of industry funds excluding insurance premiums paid by members, with SMSF performance including insurance premiums paid by members.
“This is either an example of poor research and analysis by Industry Super Australia, or a case of deliberate false and misleading reporting,” he said.
Self managed super fund
Superannuation guarantee to be paid on government paid parental leave, says ASFA
The Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia (ASFA) has hailed the government's decision to include Superannuation Guarantee payments with its Paid Parental Leave policy as a critical step ...Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF experts advise against hasty reactions to potential super tax changes
As the Australian Government proposes a new tax measure on superannuation earnings for balances exceeding $3 million, experts from the self-managed super funds (SMSF) sector are urging members not to ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Federal government announces changes to superannuation contribution caps
The Federal Government has announced changes to the superannuation contribution caps, impacting self-managed super funds (SMSFs) and their members from 1 July 2024. Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF Association calls for joint effort to tackle early super access
The SMSF Association is calling on a collaborative approach including the Government, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Rest Super members file class action over alleged insurance premium deductions
Shine Lawyers has initiated a class action lawsuit against Rest Superannuation (Rest), alleging the unlawful deduction of income protection insurance premiums from members' superannuation accounts. Read more
Self managed super fund
Debunking a superannuation tax myth: SMSF Association clarifies the impact on Aussie farms
In the ongoing debate about a proposed new tax targeting superannuation funds exceeding $3 million, the SMSF Association has stepped in to challenge claims from the Association of Superannuation Funds ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Is an SMSF right for you?
When it comes to planning for retirement, one of the most significant decisions Australians have to make is how to manage their superannuation. Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF growth continues after pandemic peak
The statistics have begun to change coming out of the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new findings from Australian Investment Exchange Limited (AUSIEX). Read more
Self managed super fund
Superannuation guarantee to be paid on government paid parental leave, says ASFA
The Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia (ASFA) has hailed the government's decision to include Superannuation Guarantee payments with its Paid Parental Leave policy as a critical step ...Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF experts advise against hasty reactions to potential super tax changes
As the Australian Government proposes a new tax measure on superannuation earnings for balances exceeding $3 million, experts from the self-managed super funds (SMSF) sector are urging members not to ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Federal government announces changes to superannuation contribution caps
The Federal Government has announced changes to the superannuation contribution caps, impacting self-managed super funds (SMSFs) and their members from 1 July 2024. Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF Association calls for joint effort to tackle early super access
The SMSF Association is calling on a collaborative approach including the Government, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Rest Super members file class action over alleged insurance premium deductions
Shine Lawyers has initiated a class action lawsuit against Rest Superannuation (Rest), alleging the unlawful deduction of income protection insurance premiums from members' superannuation accounts. Read more
Self managed super fund
Debunking a superannuation tax myth: SMSF Association clarifies the impact on Aussie farms
In the ongoing debate about a proposed new tax targeting superannuation funds exceeding $3 million, the SMSF Association has stepped in to challenge claims from the Association of Superannuation Funds ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Is an SMSF right for you?
When it comes to planning for retirement, one of the most significant decisions Australians have to make is how to manage their superannuation. Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF growth continues after pandemic peak
The statistics have begun to change coming out of the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new findings from Australian Investment Exchange Limited (AUSIEX). Read more