Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.

Is your SMSF scheme ‘too good to be true?’

Is your SMSF scheme ‘too good to be true?’

The Australian Taxation Office is warning SMSF trustees to be “wary” of dodgy retirement planning arrangements, saying if it “looks too good to be true, it usually is”.

According to ATO deputy commissioner, James O’Halloran, the ATO understands that most people try to do the right thing and “work hard” saving for retirement.

However, he added that this doesn’t excuse participation in an illegal arrangement.

He said: “If a taxpayer becomes involved in any illegal arrangement, even by accident, they may incur severe penalties, jeopardise their retirement savings and risk losing their rights as a trustee to manage their own fund.”


His warning comes as the ATO releases more information through its Super Scheme Smart program.

The program was built to provide taxpayers with relevant case studies and information about illegal arrangements, the risks that come with them and warning signs to watch out for.

 Mr O’Halloran said: “We are working hard to shut down illegal arrangements quickly, but the best defence for taxpayers and their advisers is to be aware.

“Promoters of the arrangements may overtly target SMSF trustees and self-funded retirees, including small business owners and those involved in property development with significant assets.”

Continuing, Mr O’Halloran said the arrangements could be “cleverly disguised” to give the pretence of legitimacy, while “paper shuffling” and claims that the program will significantly reduce, eliminate or even refund tax for the taxpayer are warning signs.

He explained: “Just because an arrangement is structured in a way which appears to satisfy certain regulatory rules does not mean it is legal.

“Such arrangements can put SMSFs at significant risk of breaching the superannuation regulatory rules as well as the taxation law.”

In the cross-hairs

The ATO pointed to arrangements involving SMSFs and related-party property development ventures as an area where “extreme care must be taken”.

Additionally, arrangements in which individuals deliberately exceed the non-concessional contributions cap in order to manipulate the taxable and non-taxable portions of their balance upon refund of the excess are of concern to the office.

Further, the ATO is watching for schemes in which a legal life interest is granted over a commercial property to an SMSF. They explained that this is because these schemes result “in the rental income from the property being diverted to the SMSF and taxed at lower rates while the individual or related entity retains legal ownership of the property”.

Dividend stripping, where profits are “stripped” from the company in a tax-free manner, and illegal treatment of personal services income have also been identified.

The ATO advised trustees to ensure that they are receiving “ethical professional advice when undertaking retirement planning” and said that preferably, retirees should ask for a second opinion from a “trusted and reputable expert, especially if you are in any doubt”.

If SMSF trustees think they may have been accidentally caught up in a dodgy scheme, the ATO calls on them to “speak up”.

“We do our best to shut down dodgy schemes but we need your co-operation. Reporting promoters will help us stop them from risking your and other peoples retirement savings.

“You’ve worked hard for many years so you can enjoy a great retirement. We want to help you protect your retirement nest egg. If you believe you have been lured into a scheme or approached about one, let us know,” the ATO concluded.

The scheme has been endorsed by the SMSF Association CEO, John Maroney. He said: We are highly supportive of the clarity that the ATO material provides on issues and risk areas that are causing concern for SMSF advisors and trustees alike.

“While we know the vast majority of SMSF members are trying to swim between the flags, it can be easy to be caught up in an illegal scheme without the right information or advice at hand.”

Mr Maroney said awareness and education are always the first step[s] in curbing illegal arrangements. 

It is encouraging to see an increasing number of industry wide initiatives like this that help protect SMSF members retirement savings and help them live a secure and dignified retirement.”

Is your SMSF scheme ‘too good to be true?’
Is your SMSF scheme ‘too good to be true?’
nestegg logo
subscribe to our newsletter sign up
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Anonymous - This is silly. Most countries would think 3 per cent was fantastically low. Further, who measures how much economic activity is being destroyed by.......
Anonymous - What a load of rot! What is he comparing the detriment to, and how much does the GFC effects factor into his farcical calculations? ....
Anonymous - In other words, sack advisers and cut costs. It's the financial version of #me too movement.....
Anonymous - If that's after tax pay then I'm screwed.....