Save
Grattan calls out ‘absurdly generous’ tax concessions
The dividend imputation debate has fuelled intense discussion over who classifies as wealthy in Australia, but it’s time for everyone to take a breath, Grattan researchers argue.
Grattan calls out ‘absurdly generous’ tax concessions
The dividend imputation debate has fuelled intense discussion over who classifies as wealthy in Australia, but it’s time for everyone to take a breath, Grattan researchers argue.
Grattan Institute researchers Brendan Coates and Danielle Wood have thrown cold water over Treasurer Scott Morrison’s claims that 54 per cent of people impacted by potential changes to dividend imputation law have taxable incomes of less than $18,200.
They also disputed claims that 86 per cent of all refunded franking credits make their way back to those with taxable incomes of less than $87,000 per annum.
“These claims are deeply misleading. Taxable income ignores the largest source of income for many wealthier retirees: tax-free superannuation,” the researchers said.
They provided the example of a self-funded retiree couple with $3.2 million in super who own their own home as well as $200,000 in Australian shares outside of superannuation.
Provided that this couple draws down $130,000 a year from superannuation and an additional $15,000 a year in income from dividends, their combined taxable income would be just $15,000 and they would not pay any income tax at all.
“And is the Treasurer seriously suggesting that 610,000 retirees actually get by on less than $18,200 a year, or nearly 20 per cent below the poverty line? If that were anywhere close to the real story, it would signal a full-blown retirement-incomes crisis,” Mr Coates and Ms Wood argued.
Continuing, they contended that Mr Morrison’s purported low-income earners are far from the poorest retirees, and few are even maximum-rate pensioners.
While some maximum-rate pensioner couples could potentially have taxable incomes below $18,200, the maximum-rate pension for a couple is $32,000 a year.
That means, they argued, one half of that couple receive dividends of up to $2,200 while garnering the full pension. As such, $660 would be the maximum price for them from Bill Shorten’s proposed policy.
“But most of those affected by Labor’s policy who declare taxable incomes of less than $18,200 a year are far from being low-income earners. They are either part-pensioners, or not receiving any pension at all. And they’re drawing much of their income from tax-free superannuation,” the researchers said.
“When we hear of a part-pensioner with a taxable income of less than $18,200 a year being hit by Labor’s plan, it is worth asking why they’re only receiving a part-pension in the first place,” they added, arguing that many part-pensioners are reasonably wealthy, given that the family home is excluded from the pension assets test.
The researchers claimed that Australia’s older generations have had a decade of “absurdly generous” superannuation tax concessions, and that’s why older households generally pay less income tax in real terms than their counterparts 20 years ago.
“The rise of these 'taxed-nots' coincides with the introduction of the Senior Australian Tax Offset in 2000, and tax-free super withdrawals in 2007.
“Generous super and other age-based tax breaks have been funded by deficits. The accumulating debt burden will disproportionately fall on younger households.”
Pointing to ABS figures, the Grattan Institute noted that the poorest half of retirees own less than 2 per cent of all shares, while the wealthiest 20 per cent own 86 per cent, so while 200,000 part pensioners and 14,000 maximum rate pensioners will take a hit, the vast majority of revenue will flow from wealthier retirees.
Tax saving
South Australians now eligible for COVID-19 Disaster Payment
South Australians under lockdown are set to be supported by the COVID-19 Disaster Payment, the state government has confirmed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Broken tax system costs economy $50bn
Australia’s tax laws are costing the nation about $50 billion in compliance costs, while inefficient taxes are slowing down economic growth, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
Tax saving
Australia signs on for global trade floor
Australia is set to gain up to $3 billion in additional tax revenue after agreeing with world leaders to sign on to new rules as to where profits for multinationals should be taxed as well as a new mi...Read more
Tax saving
Aussies warned of overconfidence ahead of EOFY
Two-thirds of Australians are confident about grappling with the tax implications of the pandemic. Maybe too confident. ...Read more
Tax saving
Why investors could unknowingly be heading towards a CGT minefield
The calculation of a capital gain (or loss) should be simple. Unfortunately, it’s becoming more and more complicated, not because the information required to calculate the gain (or loss) has changed...Read more
Tax saving
How are Australians planning on spending their tax savings?
Essential bills, savings accounts, Christmas gifts and exchange-traded funds appear to be the big winners from the latest round of tax cuts, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Tax saving
First in the world: SA imposes EV tax
The South Australian government is the first government in the world to introduce an electronic vehicles tax following an announcement by the treasury. ...Read more
Tax saving
5 tips as tax deadline looms
Australians are being warned that they have just two weeks left to get their finances in order if they have not posted a tax return yet. ...Read more
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Are property prices set to crash? Should you jump on board the fintok craze? And how to prepare for this tax time
Listen now
Tax saving
South Australians now eligible for COVID-19 Disaster Payment
South Australians under lockdown are set to be supported by the COVID-19 Disaster Payment, the state government has confirmed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Broken tax system costs economy $50bn
Australia’s tax laws are costing the nation about $50 billion in compliance costs, while inefficient taxes are slowing down economic growth, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
Tax saving
Australia signs on for global trade floor
Australia is set to gain up to $3 billion in additional tax revenue after agreeing with world leaders to sign on to new rules as to where profits for multinationals should be taxed as well as a new mi...Read more
Tax saving
Aussies warned of overconfidence ahead of EOFY
Two-thirds of Australians are confident about grappling with the tax implications of the pandemic. Maybe too confident. ...Read more
Tax saving
Why investors could unknowingly be heading towards a CGT minefield
The calculation of a capital gain (or loss) should be simple. Unfortunately, it’s becoming more and more complicated, not because the information required to calculate the gain (or loss) has changed...Read more
Tax saving
How are Australians planning on spending their tax savings?
Essential bills, savings accounts, Christmas gifts and exchange-traded funds appear to be the big winners from the latest round of tax cuts, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Tax saving
First in the world: SA imposes EV tax
The South Australian government is the first government in the world to introduce an electronic vehicles tax following an announcement by the treasury. ...Read more
Tax saving
5 tips as tax deadline looms
Australians are being warned that they have just two weeks left to get their finances in order if they have not posted a tax return yet. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
