Save
Just a ‘myth’: will dividend reform see investors double-taxed?
Two prominent politicians have locked horns over whether changes to dividend imputation policy would see investors taxed twice, with one Labor senator labelling concerns a “myth”.
Just a ‘myth’: will dividend reform see investors double-taxed?
Two prominent politicians have locked horns over whether changes to dividend imputation policy would see investors taxed twice, with one Labor senator labelling concerns a “myth”.
Labor senator for NSW Kristina Keneally has hit back at arguments against Labor’s proposed changes to dividend imputation credit arrangements, claiming the argument that the proposal will see some investors taxed twice is a “myth”.
Speaking at a Financial Services Council event on Wednesday, the politician said the argument that investors would suffer double taxation as a result of the denied cash refunds was “frankly … an absurd argument”.
“Labor introduced dividend imputation in 1987 because taxing income in the form of dividends was clearly double taxation, but people who don’t pay income tax are not taxed on their dividends either, and so refundability essentially means that no tax is paid on corporate profits in question,” she said.
“Let’s take this a step further. Imagine for a second a theoretical world in which every share in Australia is held by someone who paid no income tax. The company pays tax at the prevailing corporate rate, the company distributes dividends to its shareholders, who are all entitled to a tax refund for the franking credits, and the cash refund is paid to the shareholder.”
In this situation, the entire tax paid by the company is refunded to its shareholders – so effectively, the company has avoided taxation altogether, Ms Keneally said.
“Dividend imputation reform is a continuation of our willingness to make the tough decisions on budget repair, and seek a mandate to implement them.”
Minister for Revenue and Financial Services Kelly O’Dwyer, it’s fair to say, doesn’t share this view.
During a speech given to a Fairfax wealth summit on Wednesday, the minister referred to the proposed policy as double taxation on three separate instances.
Agreeing with Ms Keneally that the original 1987 policy was introduced to protect shareholders from double taxation, she argued that the Howard government’s amendments to the policy in 2000, which allowed those with low or zero taxable incomes to receive a cash refund instead of a tax-offsetting credit, were the final step in fully protecting investors from double taxation.
“People receiving dividend imputation credits could now use these credits to offset other forms of income, while people on lower taxable incomes received their tax credit back in the form of a tax refund – remembering that as shareholders they already paid company tax,” she said.
So, what is it?
The original 1987 legislation branded itself as the “biggest tax cut in Australian history”.
In a media statement, then-treasurer Paul Keating said, “Shareholders will not have to pay tax on dividends if the company has already paid tax on the profits. Instead, they will get an 'imputation credit' for the tax paid by the company.
“This means that shareholders on lower marginal tax rates will even get a net credit on their tax bill.”
According to the Australian Taxation Office, the general idea behind imputation and franking is to prevent double taxation, “that is, the taxation of profits when earned by a corporate tax entity, and again when a recipient receives a distribution”.
In a discussion paper released in 2015, the ATO characterised the 1987 policy as relieving double taxation, with the reformed system a means of making imputation credits “refundable for some taxpayers”.
It continued: “Refundability ensures that the final tax on company profits reflects each shareholder’s tax rate at the time that the profits are distributed. Arguably, this provides for greater neutrality between different types of investments and removes a penalty that would otherwise apply to shareholders who have a lower tax rate (for example, retiree shareholders on relatively low incomes).
“However, as noted above, domestic shareholders may receive higher returns on domestic shares compared to global rates of returns on equities, because of imputation. There are some revenue concerns with the refundability of imputation credits.”
These include the greater incentive for shareholders of closely-held companies to delay their distributions until they have a lower tax rate, in order to receive the refund of tax paid by the corporation.
Tax saving
Will you pay higher taxes due to bracket creep?
Bracket creep will see Australians paying more tax on average, unless further cuts are introduced in the future. ...Read more
Tax saving
10 ways to reduce your tax bill
With the tax return deadline only one month away, these tips could help minimise your tax bill. ...Read more
Tax saving
Sustainable tax conditions only way forward: OECD
The Australian economy had been on a 28-year winning streak of uninterrupted growth before the pandemic. However, despite a return to lockdowns, the OECD has predicted that winning ways can return sh...Read more
Tax saving
ATO issues warning over new gift card scam
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is warning victims of a new phone scam, where scammers are pretending to be the tax man and demanding payments for unpaid tax liabilities. ...Read more
Tax saving
EV uptake set to stall following tax changes
Special EV taxes introduced by state governments are creating a disincentive for Aussies to choose cleaner vehicles and slowing Australia’s overall transition to net zero, new data has revealed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Rooftop solar avoids ‘sun tax’ but still faces caps
Power companies will soon be able to charge Australians with rooftop solar panels a tax for exporting electricity to the grid, albeit the regulators have walked back from the most controversial parts ...Read more
Tax saving
South Australians now eligible for COVID-19 Disaster Payment
South Australians under lockdown are set to be supported by the COVID-19 Disaster Payment, the state government has confirmed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Broken tax system costs economy $50bn
Australia’s tax laws are costing the nation about $50 billion in compliance costs, while inefficient taxes are slowing down economic growth, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
APRA’s mortgage crackdown, the power of DeFi and last-minute tax tips
Listen now
What to expect as the end of lockdown looms? Will the Stage 2 tax cuts boost your tax return? Where should investors be looking as the economy reopens?
Listen now
Could property prices inflate by another 20%? What’s happening in recent dividend announcements? Did your fund fail the YFYS test?
Listen now
What does the NSW regional permit mean for property investors? Who really wins from the BHP-Woodside merger?
Listen now
Tax saving
Will you pay higher taxes due to bracket creep?
Bracket creep will see Australians paying more tax on average, unless further cuts are introduced in the future. ...Read more
Tax saving
10 ways to reduce your tax bill
With the tax return deadline only one month away, these tips could help minimise your tax bill. ...Read more
Tax saving
Sustainable tax conditions only way forward: OECD
The Australian economy had been on a 28-year winning streak of uninterrupted growth before the pandemic. However, despite a return to lockdowns, the OECD has predicted that winning ways can return sh...Read more
Tax saving
ATO issues warning over new gift card scam
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is warning victims of a new phone scam, where scammers are pretending to be the tax man and demanding payments for unpaid tax liabilities. ...Read more
Tax saving
EV uptake set to stall following tax changes
Special EV taxes introduced by state governments are creating a disincentive for Aussies to choose cleaner vehicles and slowing Australia’s overall transition to net zero, new data has revealed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Rooftop solar avoids ‘sun tax’ but still faces caps
Power companies will soon be able to charge Australians with rooftop solar panels a tax for exporting electricity to the grid, albeit the regulators have walked back from the most controversial parts ...Read more
Tax saving
South Australians now eligible for COVID-19 Disaster Payment
South Australians under lockdown are set to be supported by the COVID-19 Disaster Payment, the state government has confirmed. ...Read more
Tax saving
Broken tax system costs economy $50bn
Australia’s tax laws are costing the nation about $50 billion in compliance costs, while inefficient taxes are slowing down economic growth, an industry expert has warned. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
