Retirement
Withdrawing super could cost less than you think
The impact of early access to superannuation could be exaggerated, with most Australians still likely to experience a comfortable retirement despite digging into their nest egg, new research has found.
Withdrawing super could cost less than you think
The impact of early access to superannuation could be exaggerated, with most Australians still likely to experience a comfortable retirement despite digging into their nest egg, new research has found.
Research by the Grattan Institute has pointed out that retirement incomes will still fall for workers who withdraw their super early, but that cost will be offset by higher aged pensions.
The Grattan Institute said retirement income will fall for workers who have accessed their superannuation early, but this will be offset by a higher rate of government support.
“Someone earning the median wage of about $60,000 today can expect their total super income through retirement to fall by about $80,000 in today’s dollars,” said Grattan household finances director Brendan Coates.
“But their total retirement income would fall by only $24,000 in today’s dollars, or about $900 each year, because their lower super balance at retirement would be largely offset by larger pension payments.”
The Grattan Institute highlighted a higher aged pension would still cost the federal government less than extra super tax breaks that result from an increase to the super guarantee, and that increasing the guarantee now could reduce take-home pay for workers and increase the gender pay gap.
“System defaults like the rate compulsory super need to be set so they work for most Australians,” Mr Coates said. “And while around one in five Australians have accessed their super early, that leaves four in five that haven’t.
“[Policymakers] can only justify forcibly lowering someone’s living standards during their working life – by lifting compulsory super – if we are protecting them from even worse outcomes in retirement.”
However, under this model, lower-income earners would lose the same amount in accumulated super as middle-income earners but would also receive less extra aged pension compensation.
The Grattan Institute plans would offset this loss by increasing rental support and Newstart allowance for these workers.
“Of course, some low-income Australians remain at risk of poverty in retirement – especially those who rent – but struggle even more before they retire,” Mr Coates said. “And boosting Rent Assistance would do far more than higher compulsory super to help these vulnerable Australians, and without reducing their take-home pay before they retire as higher compulsory super would.”
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Are super funds all talk when it comes to climate change?
Superannuation funds have pledged to be net zero by 2050, but activists question whether these funds will deliver. ...Read more
Superannuation
Funds continue bright start to financial year
Super funds have continued their strong start to the financial year following a weak last quarter due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new research. ...Read more
Superannuation
Coalition rules out ‘adverse tax changes to super’ in budget
While senator Jane Hume said the government will stand by its election promise of no adverse changes to taxes in super, there will continue to be “necessary tinkering” within the regulatory setti...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee estimated to save budget $17bn
Replacing the superannuation guarantee and means tested age pension with a more generous publicly funded age pension would see budget costs rise by $17.3 billion, according to a recent report. ...Read more
Superannuation
How to increase members’ balances without hurting small businesses
The small business ombudsman has proposed holding the rate of superannuation at 9.5 per cent while changing tax regulations to help members rebuild their balances post the early access to superannuati...Read more
Superannuation
How the super freeze will hurt the economic recovery
Industry Super Australia has warned that infrastructure spending will be lost if the government withdraws from its previously legislated increase to the superannuation guarantee. ...Read more
Superannuation
Should home ownership be part of superannuation?
Liberal MPs have discussed the idea of overhauling the retirement system, with home ownership becoming the cornerstone of retirement under their proposal. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australian super remains the envy of Wall Street billionaire
As Australia debates the superannuation guarantee, a Wall Street billionaire has pointed out how the system helps with inequality, urging the United States to adopt a similar model. ...Read more
Superannuation
Are super funds all talk when it comes to climate change?
Superannuation funds have pledged to be net zero by 2050, but activists question whether these funds will deliver. ...Read more
Superannuation
Funds continue bright start to financial year
Super funds have continued their strong start to the financial year following a weak last quarter due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new research. ...Read more
Superannuation
Coalition rules out ‘adverse tax changes to super’ in budget
While senator Jane Hume said the government will stand by its election promise of no adverse changes to taxes in super, there will continue to be “necessary tinkering” within the regulatory setti...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee estimated to save budget $17bn
Replacing the superannuation guarantee and means tested age pension with a more generous publicly funded age pension would see budget costs rise by $17.3 billion, according to a recent report. ...Read more
Superannuation
How to increase members’ balances without hurting small businesses
The small business ombudsman has proposed holding the rate of superannuation at 9.5 per cent while changing tax regulations to help members rebuild their balances post the early access to superannuati...Read more
Superannuation
How the super freeze will hurt the economic recovery
Industry Super Australia has warned that infrastructure spending will be lost if the government withdraws from its previously legislated increase to the superannuation guarantee. ...Read more
Superannuation
Should home ownership be part of superannuation?
Liberal MPs have discussed the idea of overhauling the retirement system, with home ownership becoming the cornerstone of retirement under their proposal. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australian super remains the envy of Wall Street billionaire
As Australia debates the superannuation guarantee, a Wall Street billionaire has pointed out how the system helps with inequality, urging the United States to adopt a similar model. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
