Retirement
Why opt-in super proposal is a ‘secret tax’ on Aussie workers
A proposal to give workers the option to pick between a wage rise or a super contribution increase has been slammed by industry funds, branding it as “a secret tax” on workers.

Why opt-in super proposal is a ‘secret tax’ on Aussie workers
A proposal to give workers the option to pick between a wage rise or a super contribution increase has been slammed by industry funds, branding it as “a secret tax” on workers.

The Morrison government is reportedly weighing allowing workers to choose between putting money in their super or having more take-home pay.
Under the proposal, superannuation would be lifted up to 10 per cent on 1 July 2021, before workers are asked to decide between opting in for future superannuation increases or a rise in take-home pay.
However, Industry Super Australia (ISA) has labeled the proposal “a secret tax on Australians”, explaining that take-home pay is taxed at a higher rate than superannuation.
According to ISA, the move, reneging on the legislated super guarantee increases, could potentially cost workers billions.
“Wages are taxed at a higher rate than super contributions, leaving little for workers once the Tax Office takes its cut. ISA analysis shows that up to two-thirds of an increase could be lost in higher taxes and reductions in other government support payments,” ISA deputy chief executive Matthew Linden said.
“Removing the guarantee in the super guarantee to make it ‘optional’ is a recipe for higher taxes, lower lifetime incomes and a red tape nightmare for business.”
The industry funds have labeled the proposal an “underhanded plan” to make super optional, which would force workers to pay themselves a wage increase by sacrificing their retirement savings – leaving the average 30-year-old couple up to $200,000 less at retirement.
“This isn’t choice – it’s a sneaky tax grab that will leave people worse off and rip up one of the system’s founding principles,” Mr Liden continued.
The Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees (AIST) also weighed in on the issue, opining that the government looks “intent on undermining financial outcomes for Australians in retirement”.
“There is a broad understanding that unless we are compelled to save a portion of our wages, very few of us will have enough money for a financially secure retirement,” said AIST chief executive Eva Scheerlinck.
“There are lots of ways to deal with low wage growth, but forcing people to use their retirement savings to fund their own pay rise shouldn’t be one of them.”
About the author

About the author


Superannuation
Top 5 members satisfaction super funds revealed
The COVID-19 pandemic has seen superannuation satisfaction reach record highs, new research has revealed. ...Read more

Superannuation
New super laws divide industry groups
Your Future, Your Super legislations have reached Parliament, dividing opinions among key stakeholders. ...Read more

Superannuation
ISA applauds Minister Hume for opposing super for a home plan
The government has no immediate plans to allow Australians to access their superannuation to buy a home, Jane Hume has confirmed, despite ongoing calls from backbenchers. ...Read more

Superannuation
Your Future, Your Super hits Parliament
The controversial Your Future, Your Super reform package has been introduced to Parliament, paving the way for the continuation of the government’s fierce debate with the super sector. ...Read more

Superannuation
Super funds deliver slim January gains
Superannuation funds have made ‘a small but positive result’ at the start of 2021, although the pandemic still poses a significant risk to future returns, new research has revealed. ...Read more

Superannuation
Age pension to explode if super guarantee is ditched: ISA
Failing to lift the superannuation guarantee to 12 per cent will inflate Australia’s aged pension bill to $33 billion by 2058, and may lead to tax hikes to meet the bulging burden, new research has ...Read more

Superannuation
Why it’s the right idea but wrong time to lift the SG
As Australia surfaces from its first economic recession in almost three decades, the focus should be on creating new jobs instead of lifting the superannuation guarantee, an accounting body has said....Read more

Superannuation
‘RBA helping the government knock off’ super increase: Keating
Former Prime Minister Paul Keating has accused the Reserve Bank of Australia of laziness, opining that the bank is aiding the government in knocking off the legislated superannuation increase at the...Read more

Superannuation
Top 5 members satisfaction super funds revealed
The COVID-19 pandemic has seen superannuation satisfaction reach record highs, new research has revealed. ...Read more

Superannuation
New super laws divide industry groups
Your Future, Your Super legislations have reached Parliament, dividing opinions among key stakeholders. ...Read more

Superannuation
ISA applauds Minister Hume for opposing super for a home plan
The government has no immediate plans to allow Australians to access their superannuation to buy a home, Jane Hume has confirmed, despite ongoing calls from backbenchers. ...Read more

Superannuation
Your Future, Your Super hits Parliament
The controversial Your Future, Your Super reform package has been introduced to Parliament, paving the way for the continuation of the government’s fierce debate with the super sector. ...Read more

Superannuation
Super funds deliver slim January gains
Superannuation funds have made ‘a small but positive result’ at the start of 2021, although the pandemic still poses a significant risk to future returns, new research has revealed. ...Read more

Superannuation
Age pension to explode if super guarantee is ditched: ISA
Failing to lift the superannuation guarantee to 12 per cent will inflate Australia’s aged pension bill to $33 billion by 2058, and may lead to tax hikes to meet the bulging burden, new research has ...Read more

Superannuation
Why it’s the right idea but wrong time to lift the SG
As Australia surfaces from its first economic recession in almost three decades, the focus should be on creating new jobs instead of lifting the superannuation guarantee, an accounting body has said....Read more

Superannuation
‘RBA helping the government knock off’ super increase: Keating
Former Prime Minister Paul Keating has accused the Reserve Bank of Australia of laziness, opining that the bank is aiding the government in knocking off the legislated superannuation increase at the...Read more