Retirement
The First Home Super Saver Scheme isn’t a shortcut – it’s ‘a devil’s choice’
Retirement
The First Home Super Saver Scheme isn’t a shortcut – it’s ‘a devil’s choice’
The federal government’s First Home Super Saver Scheme has been lauded by industry advocates since its introduction, but some argue that the drawbacks are impossible to overlook.
The First Home Super Saver Scheme isn’t a shortcut – it’s ‘a devil’s choice’
The federal government’s First Home Super Saver Scheme has been lauded by industry advocates since its introduction, but some argue that the drawbacks are impossible to overlook.
Introduced back in 2017 and boosted in this year’s federal budget, the First Home Super Saver Scheme allows eligible first home buyers to withdraw up to $50,000 in voluntary super contributions early for the purpose of raising a deposit for a property.
According to Property Council chief executive Ken Morrison, while these schemes may be targeted at helping first home buyers bridge the deposit gap, the material reality is that they're asking the next generation of Australian homeowners to make a choice that previous generations didn’t have to consider.
On a fundamental level, this federal policy asks Australians to decide between having a stake in the property market now and reaping the benefits of their superannuation later.
According to Jim Stanford, an economist and director of the Centre for Future Work, the government has shown “a worrisome tendency" to treat Australians’ super accounts as an “all-purpose piggy bank which can be raided for any important reason”.
Mr Stanford also drew attention to the early release scheme, which allowed 3 million Australians to pull $36 billion from their retirement savings to help get through the hardship of the COVID lockdowns.
“They have now expanded the First Home scheme to allow $50,000 withdrawals. They even proposed allowing abused women to pull money from their super to help finance their escape from violent spouses.”
The latter was abandoned in March after public outrage.
The problems being addressed, Dr Stanford argued, are something the government should tackle through other measures, including adequate income support in the event of a pandemic, effective support for victims of domestic violence, and measures to make home ownership more affordable.
“Those are all legitimate public policy goals which government cannot shirk by simply suggesting that workers tap their own super accounts,” he said.
The First Home Super Saver Scheme is often portrayed as a crowd-pleasing fix to a thorny problem, but choosing between property and superannuation is no small ask.
Moreover, according to Mr Stanford, there is little evidence to suggest that allowing super withdrawal will fix the housing affordability problem. In fact, he opined, the funds being withdrawn “are trivial” compared to the escalation of property prices in Australia.
If anything, he said that having more liquid finance around could accelerate the rise in housing costs – making buying a home even less affordable.
“There are many things that government should be doing to address housing affordability, including removing the huge tax subsidies for property speculation in the current tax system, reforming land development policies to get more affordable housing units under construction, and financing the badly needed expansion of affordable non-market housing.
“Forcing Australians to choose between putting a roof over their heads and having a decent retirement is truly a devil’s choice. Australians shouldn’t be forced to make it,” Mr Stanford said, adding that early-release schemes are “a lifetime penalty”.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee rate rises to 12 per cent as parental leave changes take effect
The superannuation guarantee rate has increased from 11.5 per cent to 12 per cent from Tuesday, with super contributions also being added to Commonwealth Parental Leave Pay for the first time. Read more
Superannuation
Rest's Sustainable Growth option achieves highest sustainability classification
Rest superannuation fund has achieved the highest sustainability classification for its Sustainable Growth investment option from the Responsible Investment Association Australasia. Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super slashes admin fees for retirees by up to 25 per cent
Aware Super has reduced administration fees for members with a retirement income account by up to 25 per cent and lowered the maximum annual fee. Read more
Superannuation
SuperAPI co-founder criticises Labor's superannuation tax as 'sneaky tax on young people'
The co-founder of SuperAPI has labelled Labor's proposed tax on superannuation balances above $3 million as a "sneaky tax on young people, tomorrow" disguised as a policy targeting wealthy retirees ...Read more
Superannuation
Election policies could reshape Australia's superannuation landscape, expert warns
Competing superannuation policies from Australia's major political parties could have significant implications for investors and retirees, according to a financial expert. Read more
Superannuation
Industry leaders weigh in on concessional super tax as Budget confirms $55bn investment
Changes to the taxation of superannuation earnings and contributions have drawn mixed responses from financial and payroll sector leaders, as the Federal Budget confirms over $55 billion in ...Read more
Superannuation
Call for indexation on super tax cap as $3m threshold draws criticism
A senior executive in the superannuation technology sector has criticised the Federal Government for failing to index the proposed $3 million superannuation tax cap, arguing the measure will unfairly ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest members back calls for fairer superannuation rules ahead of Federal Budget
Rest has called on the Federal Government to implement superannuation reforms aimed at improving fairness across the system, after member survey results showed strong support for a range of proposed ...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee rate rises to 12 per cent as parental leave changes take effect
The superannuation guarantee rate has increased from 11.5 per cent to 12 per cent from Tuesday, with super contributions also being added to Commonwealth Parental Leave Pay for the first time. Read more
Superannuation
Rest's Sustainable Growth option achieves highest sustainability classification
Rest superannuation fund has achieved the highest sustainability classification for its Sustainable Growth investment option from the Responsible Investment Association Australasia. Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super slashes admin fees for retirees by up to 25 per cent
Aware Super has reduced administration fees for members with a retirement income account by up to 25 per cent and lowered the maximum annual fee. Read more
Superannuation
SuperAPI co-founder criticises Labor's superannuation tax as 'sneaky tax on young people'
The co-founder of SuperAPI has labelled Labor's proposed tax on superannuation balances above $3 million as a "sneaky tax on young people, tomorrow" disguised as a policy targeting wealthy retirees ...Read more
Superannuation
Election policies could reshape Australia's superannuation landscape, expert warns
Competing superannuation policies from Australia's major political parties could have significant implications for investors and retirees, according to a financial expert. Read more
Superannuation
Industry leaders weigh in on concessional super tax as Budget confirms $55bn investment
Changes to the taxation of superannuation earnings and contributions have drawn mixed responses from financial and payroll sector leaders, as the Federal Budget confirms over $55 billion in ...Read more
Superannuation
Call for indexation on super tax cap as $3m threshold draws criticism
A senior executive in the superannuation technology sector has criticised the Federal Government for failing to index the proposed $3 million superannuation tax cap, arguing the measure will unfairly ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest members back calls for fairer superannuation rules ahead of Federal Budget
Rest has called on the Federal Government to implement superannuation reforms aimed at improving fairness across the system, after member survey results showed strong support for a range of proposed ...Read more
