Retirement
‘Super is not to blame for rock-bottom wages’
“It is preposterous for the government to blame rock-bottom wage growth on the superannuation guarantee system,” an expert has said, after the government appeared to pin the blame for Australia’s non-existent wage growth on the relative super guarantee hike.
‘Super is not to blame for rock-bottom wages’
“It is preposterous for the government to blame rock-bottom wage growth on the superannuation guarantee system,” an expert has said, after the government appeared to pin the blame for Australia’s non-existent wage growth on the relative super guarantee hike.
The government has been pretty consistent in blaming the lack of wage growth on a lift in the superannuation guarantee, but Treasury Secretary Dr Stephen Kennedy has now gone a step further by providing new insights into how the federal government calculates its current expectation around wage growth.
At the most recent Senate estimates, Dr Kennedy noted that “we have upgraded our wage and inflation forecasts to reflect the stronger labour market and a stronger economy”, but acknowledged that “short-term wage expectations remain low”.
“All things considered, we have taken a relatively cautious view and forecast a pick-up in wages from 2022-23,” he said.
More interestingly, Dr Kennedy judged that without the upcoming super rate rise – from 9.5 per cent to 10 per cent on 1 July – Treasury estimates for wage growth would be higher.
Asked by senator Andrew Bragg whether the Treasury agreed with claims by the Grattan Institute and the Reserve Bank of Australia that the legislated super rate raise would have a suppressive impact on wage growth, Dr Kennedy conceded that this “is consistent with the approach we take.”
“Roughly speaking a 0.5 [per cent] increase in the super guarantee means wages are less by about 0.4 [per cent],” he said.
Following the estimates hearing, Grattan Institute called out Dr Kennedy’s comments.
In a blog post on their website, the policy think tank advocated for the abandonment of increases in compulsory super beyond 10 per cent.
According to the group, “It’s clear that increases in compulsory super reduced the pace of wages growth relative to where it otherwise would’ve been.
“And for Australian workers today, that’s the difference between seeing their wages rise faster than inflation next year, or go backwards.”
But The Australia Institute economist Jim Stanford completely disagreed.
Speaking to nestegg, Mr Stanford said, “There is absolutely no Australian historical evidence that workers could get stronger wage gains by giving up their super. All they would end up with is less of both: lower wages and less income in retirement.”
“Wage growth since 2013 has been consistently weaker than any time since the 1930s. In that time, the super guarantee hardly changed at all.”
According to Mr Stanford, “It is preposterous for the government to blame rock-bottom wage growth on the superannuation guarantee system”.
“The government’s own policies are the main culprit in wage stagnation: attacking unions and collective bargaining, freezing pay for public sector workers, and opposing minimum wage increases. On wages, this government lives in a glass house – it really shouldn’t throw stones.”
“Workers deserve both higher wages and stronger retirement incomes, and there is no economic reason why they can’t have both,” Mr Stanford argued.
He took particular issue with the Coalition’s suggestion that workers must give up wages if they want better super, calling this statement “a political assumption, not an economic reality”.
“By strengthening wage supports in our economy (through strong collective bargaining and higher minimum wages), we can lift wage growth back to normal levels at the same time as we strengthen superannuation. Workers deserve both – and employers can absolutely afford to pay both.”
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
50,000 super fund members impacted by data breach
Around 50,000 member records were impacted by the breach that took place earlier this month. ...Read more
Superannuation
Two super funds tipped to reach $1tn by 2040
KPMG has released the findings from a new review. ...Read more
Superannuation
Total value of Aussie super funds increases
KPMG has released the findings from a new review. ...Read more
Superannuation
Super returns fall into the red for FY22
Unless a recovery takes place in the coming weeks, super funds will experience their fifth negative financial year since the introduction of compulsory super. ...Read more
Superannuation
Could the Super Home Buyer Scheme ‘torpedo’ Aussie super savings?
Industry Super Australia has argued that the scheme would force funds to hold more cash. ...Read more
Superannuation
Super fund returns at risk of being negative for this financial year
With two months to go in the current financial year, super funds are only just in the black. ...Read more
Superannuation
Some Aussies are missing out on $17k in super every year
A report has found that hundreds of thousands of Aussies are at a significant financial disadvantage, foregoing $175,000 in super on average by retirement age. ...Read more
Superannuation
APRA chair says 'good enough isn't good enough' for super sector
Wayne Byres discussed the sector at a FINSIA event. ...Read more
Wrapping up an eventful 2021
Listen now
What Omicron means for property, and are units right for first-time buyers? What is equity crowdfunding? Are industry super funds tapping into member funds to save their skins?
Listen now
Will housing affordability improve in 2022? Will buy now, pay later become the norm? Why are Aussies staying in failing super products?
Listen now
Who really benefits from crypto ETFs? How will the RBA respond to rising inflation? Could a mandate help address unpaid super?
Listen now
Superannuation
50,000 super fund members impacted by data breach
Around 50,000 member records were impacted by the breach that took place earlier this month. ...Read more
Superannuation
Two super funds tipped to reach $1tn by 2040
KPMG has released the findings from a new review. ...Read more
Superannuation
Total value of Aussie super funds increases
KPMG has released the findings from a new review. ...Read more
Superannuation
Super returns fall into the red for FY22
Unless a recovery takes place in the coming weeks, super funds will experience their fifth negative financial year since the introduction of compulsory super. ...Read more
Superannuation
Could the Super Home Buyer Scheme ‘torpedo’ Aussie super savings?
Industry Super Australia has argued that the scheme would force funds to hold more cash. ...Read more
Superannuation
Super fund returns at risk of being negative for this financial year
With two months to go in the current financial year, super funds are only just in the black. ...Read more
Superannuation
Some Aussies are missing out on $17k in super every year
A report has found that hundreds of thousands of Aussies are at a significant financial disadvantage, foregoing $175,000 in super on average by retirement age. ...Read more
Superannuation
APRA chair says 'good enough isn't good enough' for super sector
Wayne Byres discussed the sector at a FINSIA event. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
