Retirement
Recent superannuation commentary ‘poor’, ‘without context’
Recent commentary surrounding the effectiveness of Australia’s superannuation system is poorly researched or presented without context, according to new analysis.
Recent superannuation commentary ‘poor’, ‘without context’
Recent commentary surrounding the effectiveness of Australia’s superannuation system is poorly researched or presented without context, according to new analysis.
Rice Warner has criticised research from a number of thinktanks in the presentation of its data around retirees and pension access.
While acknowledging that in some instances this was correct, it was not presented with the full context.
To provide an example, it said that while Challenger’s report noting that half of 67-year-olds are not accessing the pension was correct, it was incorrectly represented because 67-year-olds are still earning an income, so they are not actually self-funded retirees.
Rice Warner also questioned the Grattan Institute’s findings, which argued that an increase in the superannuation guarantee (SG) would see the government and the middle-class facing increased costs.
Rice Warner’s own modelling considered that superannuation will do its job in reducing reliance on the Age Pension.
It has argued that such an increase would reduce the expected burden of older Australians on the GDP from 2.6 per cent to 2.1 per cent by the end of the century.
It would also enable dependence on the Age Pension to fall in the foreseeable future.
To completely remove the Age Pension, Rice Warner has estimated that compulsory superannuation levels would need to be increased up to 15 to 20 per cent.
It flagged that at a rate of 10 to 12 per cent, it would shift the burden primarily to super with some support from the Age Pension, which Rice Warner argued would be an effective system.
The real-world reasoning for dependency levels
Rice Warner further noted that low levels of dependency at younger retirement ages is reflective of higher levels of workforce participation at these ages.
This is opposed to the impact of the means test alone, it said.
For example, of those aged 66, Rice Warner estimated that around 17 per cent are still in employment, while only 36 per cent are truly self-funded.
Looking to those five years older, at age 71, the proportion living independently of the pension is much lower.
According to Rice Warner, at this age, 5 per cent are employed and just 28 per cent are self-funded.
This is reportedly proof that consumption over time pushes some retirees onto part-pensions.
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Australia slips in global pension index
The Australian superannuation system has been rated at B, falling to fourth place, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Superannuation
Early super payments slow to under $200m
Less than $200 million was paid out of the super system in the second week of October, as the popularity of the government’s early release scheme looks to be slowing further following the release of...Read more
Superannuation
‘Impressive’ super erases most COVID-19 losses
Australian superannuation has erased most of the COVID-19 downturn following a positive September quarter, new research has shown. ...Read more
Superannuation
1.2m Australians lose in tax offset lag
The Treasury’s latest tax cuts will see more than 1.2 million low-income earners paying a higher rate of tax on their superannuation contributions, with funds arguing changing the tax rate could add...Read more
Superannuation
Could you be stuck in a poor-performing fund?
The government’s superannuation reforms to eliminate multiple superannuation accounts could have unintended consequences, with older Australians locked into financial decisions made by their teenage...Read more
Superannuation
Big super pushes for gender parity
One of Australia’s largest superannuation funds has launched an investor-led initiative that will see women fill at least 40 per cent of the executive roles in the ASX 200 over the next decade. ...Read more
Superannuation
Why it is ‘cruel’ and ‘embarrassing’ not to raise the SG
Australian workers, who are bearing the brunt of the public decision to shut down the economy, could be “cruelly rewarded” for their sacrifice with a less dignified retirement, industry experts ...Read more
Superannuation
A short-term fix: Lack of strategy behind super withdrawals
A large proportion of Australians who have withdrawn their super early as a result of financial hardship have not even stopped to consider how it will impact their savings at retirement. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australia slips in global pension index
The Australian superannuation system has been rated at B, falling to fourth place, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Superannuation
Early super payments slow to under $200m
Less than $200 million was paid out of the super system in the second week of October, as the popularity of the government’s early release scheme looks to be slowing further following the release of...Read more
Superannuation
‘Impressive’ super erases most COVID-19 losses
Australian superannuation has erased most of the COVID-19 downturn following a positive September quarter, new research has shown. ...Read more
Superannuation
1.2m Australians lose in tax offset lag
The Treasury’s latest tax cuts will see more than 1.2 million low-income earners paying a higher rate of tax on their superannuation contributions, with funds arguing changing the tax rate could add...Read more
Superannuation
Could you be stuck in a poor-performing fund?
The government’s superannuation reforms to eliminate multiple superannuation accounts could have unintended consequences, with older Australians locked into financial decisions made by their teenage...Read more
Superannuation
Big super pushes for gender parity
One of Australia’s largest superannuation funds has launched an investor-led initiative that will see women fill at least 40 per cent of the executive roles in the ASX 200 over the next decade. ...Read more
Superannuation
Why it is ‘cruel’ and ‘embarrassing’ not to raise the SG
Australian workers, who are bearing the brunt of the public decision to shut down the economy, could be “cruelly rewarded” for their sacrifice with a less dignified retirement, industry experts ...Read more
Superannuation
A short-term fix: Lack of strategy behind super withdrawals
A large proportion of Australians who have withdrawn their super early as a result of financial hardship have not even stopped to consider how it will impact their savings at retirement. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
