Retirement
Labor takes early access to super scheme to Auditor-General
The Morrison government’s early access to superannuation scheme has been referred to the Auditor-General as it has been revealed that the Tax Office did not check eligibility.
Labor takes early access to super scheme to Auditor-General
The Morrison government’s early access to superannuation scheme has been referred to the Auditor-General as it has been revealed that the Tax Office did not check eligibility.
The submission, which was published by shadow assistant treasurer and shadow minister for financial services Stephen Jones, points to fraud and theft in the early access to super scheme.
Mr Jones points to major problems within the scheme, including major theft and fraud issues, the lack of verification mechanisms for early access to superannuation, inaccurate and misleading promotion of the scheme and a $12 billion blowout in estimates of how much it would cost.
“The scheme was designed to provide financial relief for people experiencing income loss and hardship caused by the economic impact of COVID-19. This was the clear intent of Parliament in legislating for increased early access,” the submission reads.
“The government’s administration of the scheme appears to have departed from this legislated purpose.”
The early access to super scheme, which has now been extended to December this year, allows eligible members to take out $10,000 last financial year and a further $10,000 in this financial year if they are suffering hardships brought on by COVID-19.
When the program was announced, it was expected about 1.5 million people would withdraw up to $27 billion.
However, data published by APRA has revealed that almost $30 billion has so far been accessed by about 3 million people, with that figure expected to grow to $42 billion by yearend.
APRA’s data follows ATO’s statement last week that it was investigating hundreds of cases where people may have wrongly withdrawn from their superannuation, a figure which could grow as further inquiries are made.
The ATO has since launched a pilot examination that will see 130 ATO officers personally contacting people to confirm and prove they have met the eligibility requirements, including by having been made redundant or seeing their working hours reduced by 20 per cent or more.
ATO second commissioner Jeremy Hirschhorn said the scheme was designed on a self-assessment system, and a compliance program could not be enforced at the time of application because the ATO would not have live information of a person’s circumstances.
“It’s based on self-assessment. We work on the assumption that Australians are honest,” Mr Hirschhorn said.
“This is about getting emergency money to people. So, we will never have enough information to reject quickly. We will give people their money on the basis of their say-so.
“We don’t know yet whether, for example, they’ve been terminated, they’ve lost their job. We don’t know at the time they apply. We might have reasonable information a month later, when the next Single Touch Payroll comes in. So, that’s why it’s based on self-assessment.”
Mr Jones pointed out that the punishment for the administration failing could see taxpayers fined $12,600 tax liabilities on funds withdrawal and a disqualification of government support, including JobSeeker.
“Government ministers and senior public servants have acknowledged many of these failings but have not provided any details as to the government’s response.
“Despite these failings, the scheme is now being extended by the government for a further three months,” the statement concluded.
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Are super funds all talk when it comes to climate change?
Superannuation funds have pledged to be net zero by 2050, but activists question whether these funds will deliver. ...Read more
Superannuation
Funds continue bright start to financial year
Super funds have continued their strong start to the financial year following a weak last quarter due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new research. ...Read more
Superannuation
Coalition rules out ‘adverse tax changes to super’ in budget
While senator Jane Hume said the government will stand by its election promise of no adverse changes to taxes in super, there will continue to be “necessary tinkering” within the regulatory setti...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee estimated to save budget $17bn
Replacing the superannuation guarantee and means tested age pension with a more generous publicly funded age pension would see budget costs rise by $17.3 billion, according to a recent report. ...Read more
Superannuation
How to increase members’ balances without hurting small businesses
The small business ombudsman has proposed holding the rate of superannuation at 9.5 per cent while changing tax regulations to help members rebuild their balances post the early access to superannuati...Read more
Superannuation
How the super freeze will hurt the economic recovery
Industry Super Australia has warned that infrastructure spending will be lost if the government withdraws from its previously legislated increase to the superannuation guarantee. ...Read more
Superannuation
Should home ownership be part of superannuation?
Liberal MPs have discussed the idea of overhauling the retirement system, with home ownership becoming the cornerstone of retirement under their proposal. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australian super remains the envy of Wall Street billionaire
As Australia debates the superannuation guarantee, a Wall Street billionaire has pointed out how the system helps with inequality, urging the United States to adopt a similar model. ...Read more
Superannuation
Are super funds all talk when it comes to climate change?
Superannuation funds have pledged to be net zero by 2050, but activists question whether these funds will deliver. ...Read more
Superannuation
Funds continue bright start to financial year
Super funds have continued their strong start to the financial year following a weak last quarter due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new research. ...Read more
Superannuation
Coalition rules out ‘adverse tax changes to super’ in budget
While senator Jane Hume said the government will stand by its election promise of no adverse changes to taxes in super, there will continue to be “necessary tinkering” within the regulatory setti...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee estimated to save budget $17bn
Replacing the superannuation guarantee and means tested age pension with a more generous publicly funded age pension would see budget costs rise by $17.3 billion, according to a recent report. ...Read more
Superannuation
How to increase members’ balances without hurting small businesses
The small business ombudsman has proposed holding the rate of superannuation at 9.5 per cent while changing tax regulations to help members rebuild their balances post the early access to superannuati...Read more
Superannuation
How the super freeze will hurt the economic recovery
Industry Super Australia has warned that infrastructure spending will be lost if the government withdraws from its previously legislated increase to the superannuation guarantee. ...Read more
Superannuation
Should home ownership be part of superannuation?
Liberal MPs have discussed the idea of overhauling the retirement system, with home ownership becoming the cornerstone of retirement under their proposal. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australian super remains the envy of Wall Street billionaire
As Australia debates the superannuation guarantee, a Wall Street billionaire has pointed out how the system helps with inequality, urging the United States to adopt a similar model. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
