Retirement
Keating attacks super withdrawal as a burden on young Australians
Former prime minister Paul Keating has slammed the Morrison government’s controversial early access to superannuation scheme, saying it shifts the burden of economic stimulus onto younger Australians.
Keating attacks super withdrawal as a burden on young Australians
Former prime minister Paul Keating has slammed the Morrison government’s controversial early access to superannuation scheme, saying it shifts the burden of economic stimulus onto younger Australians.
During an Industry Super Australia event, the man who brought in superannuation highlighted that younger Australians shouldn’t need to stimulate the economy through superannuation, due to low government debt relative to GDP.
“Of the income support in Australia to date in this COVID emergency, $32 billion has been found and paid for by the most vulnerable and lowest paid people in the country. That is the people who have withdrawn the full $20,000.
“$30 billion has been provided by the Commonwealth under JobSeeker and JobKeeper.”
“Instead of JobKeeper and JobSeeker carrying the main burden of income support. What we are finding is the main burden of income support is people ratting their own savings,” Mr Keating said.
The former PM noted the ISA research, which has found that 600,000 younger people have completely withdrawn their superannuation savings under the government’s early access scheme.
Mr Keating also pointed out that younger Australians are getting the double whammy of being asked to support the country despite politicians looking to stop superannuation rising to 12 per cent.
“The same things were said when I introduced the superannuation guarantee in 1993. Remember it went up 7 percentage points, up 1 per cent a year out of the recession of 1990,” Mr Keating said.
“A lot of the so-called economic commentators were saying this is not the time, the nation can’t afford this.
“Of course, the SG was completely affordable. We had the profit share in the economy rising, as we did the wage share. We had strong growth in employment all through the 1990s.”
The former PM also pointed out that since 2013 there has been no real wage growth, while productivity growth has increased by 9.6 per cent.
“None of this has been distributed to wages. It all went to the balance sheet of companies. So, the proponents of the SG going to 12 per cent are saying there’s 10 per cent labour productivity banked, and we are asking for a quarter of it back,” Mr Keating said.
Mr Keating finally pointed to an ageing population, with the burden falling on younger Australians.
“I think the killer point is this. When I introduced the SG, six and half people between 15-65 [in the workforce] maintained one person aged over 65. It has fallen to 3.5 now and falling,” Mr Keating said.
“So, we will reach a point where three Australians will be carrying each retired person for the public pension and public health,” the former PM concluded.
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Are super funds all talk when it comes to climate change?
Superannuation funds have pledged to be net zero by 2050, but activists question whether these funds will deliver. ...Read more
Superannuation
Funds continue bright start to financial year
Super funds have continued their strong start to the financial year following a weak last quarter due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new research. ...Read more
Superannuation
Coalition rules out ‘adverse tax changes to super’ in budget
While senator Jane Hume said the government will stand by its election promise of no adverse changes to taxes in super, there will continue to be “necessary tinkering” within the regulatory setti...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee estimated to save budget $17bn
Replacing the superannuation guarantee and means tested age pension with a more generous publicly funded age pension would see budget costs rise by $17.3 billion, according to a recent report. ...Read more
Superannuation
How to increase members’ balances without hurting small businesses
The small business ombudsman has proposed holding the rate of superannuation at 9.5 per cent while changing tax regulations to help members rebuild their balances post the early access to superannuati...Read more
Superannuation
How the super freeze will hurt the economic recovery
Industry Super Australia has warned that infrastructure spending will be lost if the government withdraws from its previously legislated increase to the superannuation guarantee. ...Read more
Superannuation
Should home ownership be part of superannuation?
Liberal MPs have discussed the idea of overhauling the retirement system, with home ownership becoming the cornerstone of retirement under their proposal. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australian super remains the envy of Wall Street billionaire
As Australia debates the superannuation guarantee, a Wall Street billionaire has pointed out how the system helps with inequality, urging the United States to adopt a similar model. ...Read more
Superannuation
Are super funds all talk when it comes to climate change?
Superannuation funds have pledged to be net zero by 2050, but activists question whether these funds will deliver. ...Read more
Superannuation
Funds continue bright start to financial year
Super funds have continued their strong start to the financial year following a weak last quarter due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to new research. ...Read more
Superannuation
Coalition rules out ‘adverse tax changes to super’ in budget
While senator Jane Hume said the government will stand by its election promise of no adverse changes to taxes in super, there will continue to be “necessary tinkering” within the regulatory setti...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee estimated to save budget $17bn
Replacing the superannuation guarantee and means tested age pension with a more generous publicly funded age pension would see budget costs rise by $17.3 billion, according to a recent report. ...Read more
Superannuation
How to increase members’ balances without hurting small businesses
The small business ombudsman has proposed holding the rate of superannuation at 9.5 per cent while changing tax regulations to help members rebuild their balances post the early access to superannuati...Read more
Superannuation
How the super freeze will hurt the economic recovery
Industry Super Australia has warned that infrastructure spending will be lost if the government withdraws from its previously legislated increase to the superannuation guarantee. ...Read more
Superannuation
Should home ownership be part of superannuation?
Liberal MPs have discussed the idea of overhauling the retirement system, with home ownership becoming the cornerstone of retirement under their proposal. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australian super remains the envy of Wall Street billionaire
As Australia debates the superannuation guarantee, a Wall Street billionaire has pointed out how the system helps with inequality, urging the United States to adopt a similar model. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
