Retirement
How can we depoliticise the pension debate?
The average “Jane” won’t have enough money to maintain her lifestyle in retirement without either working longer, saving more or expecting less. So, how can governments depoliticise the pension debate?
How can we depoliticise the pension debate?
The average “Jane” won’t have enough money to maintain her lifestyle in retirement without either working longer, saving more or expecting less. So, how can governments depoliticise the pension debate?
That’s the question Swiss bank, UBS is asking.
In its international pension gap index, UBS compared the pension programs of 12 different countries and found that the average 50-year-old Jane would not be able to rely on any country’s mandatory pension system to fully fund her lifestyle in retirement.
The pension gap – the gap between Jane’s annual income and pension pay-out – is lowest in Switzerland (11 per cent) and highest in Taiwan (157 per cent) while in Australia the gap is 37 per cent.
This means that in order to sustain her lifestyle, Aussie Jane needs to put away 37 per cent of her salary each month in her remaining 10 years or so until retirement.
The bank explained that it used a single woman for its study because women generally live longer and earn less while single retirees have greater expenses than coupled retirees. As such, UBS was modelling a worst-case scenario.
“Overall, substantial progress has been made all over the world to increase universal mandatory pension insurance coverage during the past few decades,” UBS said.
“But as many countries face substantial demographic challenges and an extremely low interest rate environment, further adjustments and in some cases substantial reforms are necessary. Contribution rates need to be carefully calibrated to ensure sufficient pension income in old age.”
Pointing out that since 1950 the rate of workers to retirees in the EU has fallen from nearly seven to just 3.5, UBS said the growing number of older people worldwide, coupled with longer life expectancies means “flexible retirement ages” needs to be considered.
However: “This is only sensible if older generations can be kept in the workforce. This could be facilitated by a flexible or step-wise transition from working to retirement, avoiding the usual full stop.”
UBS explained that when governments and pension plans use life expectancies that are lower than the reality, the resulting “overly generous” payments can deplete funds faster.
“As the number of people leaving the workforce or the ratio between workers and retirees is not constant, one could also think of a dynamic adjustment process,” it proposed.
“Generations that are larger in number could either contribute more, receive less pension or work longer compared to smaller cohorts. Such an auto mechanism would also depoliticise the pension debate.”
The Swiss bank put politicians worldwide on blast for making “promises that can’t be kept”. It said that as politics has a “paramount role” in the way pension systems are regulated, when politicians use the debate “for their own purposes, particularly during elections”, it can add another layer of complexity to the issue.
Such behaviour “makes necessary reforms, such as raising the statutory retirement age or worker contributions, a delicate undertaking”, UBS warned.
Further: “High public debt and the already large outlays governments make to provide pensions reduce their scope to manoeuvre.”
Spotlight on Australia
Aussie Jane can expect about 72 per cent of her income to be replaced by the mandatory pension scheme, made up of both the means-tested age pension and compulsory superannuation system.
Retiring at 67 and with a life expectancy of 88, Jane needs to additionally save about 37 per cent of her salary to fund a retirement lifestyle of a similar quality to her working one.
“This is due to higher living costs relative to wages and higher expected inflation in Sydney,” UBS explained, adding that these factors are mitigated by the “relatively high investment return expected in Australia”.
In Australia, the ratio of working to retired Australians has fallen from more than 7:1 to 4:1 in the last 60 years. Noting this, UBS argued: “It appears the Australian system is more sustainable than others.
“Despite the government-sponsored age pension, public pension spending is fairly low. Given its modest debt-to-GDP ratio, the government has room to manoeuvre.”
At the same time, however, the Australian economy’s dependency on natural resources renders it “vulnerable to price shocks”.
“Further, future superannuation funds might have concentrated positions in the Australian market and could be exposed to domestic shocks, especially in the housing market,” UBS warned.
“It is important to mitigate those risks with an internationally diversified investment approach for private savings.”
Superannuation
Super reforms to save members thousands but should go further
The “Your Future, Your Super” reforms announced during the federal budget are heading in the right direction, with members potentially benefiting, an industry expert has said. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australia slips in global pension index
The Australian superannuation system has been rated at B, falling to fourth place, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Superannuation
Early super payments slow to under $200m
Less than $200 million was paid out of the super system in the second week of October, as the popularity of the government’s early release scheme looks to be slowing further following the release of...Read more
Superannuation
‘Impressive’ super erases most COVID-19 losses
Australian superannuation has erased most of the COVID-19 downturn following a positive September quarter, new research has shown. ...Read more
Superannuation
1.2m Australians lose in tax offset lag
The Treasury’s latest tax cuts will see more than 1.2 million low-income earners paying a higher rate of tax on their superannuation contributions, with funds arguing changing the tax rate could add...Read more
Superannuation
Could you be stuck in a poor-performing fund?
The government’s superannuation reforms to eliminate multiple superannuation accounts could have unintended consequences, with older Australians locked into financial decisions made by their teenage...Read more
Superannuation
Big super pushes for gender parity
One of Australia’s largest superannuation funds has launched an investor-led initiative that will see women fill at least 40 per cent of the executive roles in the ASX 200 over the next decade. ...Read more
Superannuation
Why it is ‘cruel’ and ‘embarrassing’ not to raise the SG
Australian workers, who are bearing the brunt of the public decision to shut down the economy, could be “cruelly rewarded” for their sacrifice with a less dignified retirement, industry experts ...Read more
Superannuation
Super reforms to save members thousands but should go further
The “Your Future, Your Super” reforms announced during the federal budget are heading in the right direction, with members potentially benefiting, an industry expert has said. ...Read more
Superannuation
Australia slips in global pension index
The Australian superannuation system has been rated at B, falling to fourth place, new research has revealed. ...Read more
Superannuation
Early super payments slow to under $200m
Less than $200 million was paid out of the super system in the second week of October, as the popularity of the government’s early release scheme looks to be slowing further following the release of...Read more
Superannuation
‘Impressive’ super erases most COVID-19 losses
Australian superannuation has erased most of the COVID-19 downturn following a positive September quarter, new research has shown. ...Read more
Superannuation
1.2m Australians lose in tax offset lag
The Treasury’s latest tax cuts will see more than 1.2 million low-income earners paying a higher rate of tax on their superannuation contributions, with funds arguing changing the tax rate could add...Read more
Superannuation
Could you be stuck in a poor-performing fund?
The government’s superannuation reforms to eliminate multiple superannuation accounts could have unintended consequences, with older Australians locked into financial decisions made by their teenage...Read more
Superannuation
Big super pushes for gender parity
One of Australia’s largest superannuation funds has launched an investor-led initiative that will see women fill at least 40 per cent of the executive roles in the ASX 200 over the next decade. ...Read more
Superannuation
Why it is ‘cruel’ and ‘embarrassing’ not to raise the SG
Australian workers, who are bearing the brunt of the public decision to shut down the economy, could be “cruelly rewarded” for their sacrifice with a less dignified retirement, industry experts ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
