Retirement
Ethical super funds accused of misleading members
Two ethical superannuation funds have come under scrutiny for sharing similar investment options, despite having different outcome objectives for members.
Ethical super funds accused of misleading members
Two ethical superannuation funds have come under scrutiny for sharing similar investment options, despite having different outcome objectives for members.
The House of Representatives standing committee on economics has accused Future Super and Verve of misleading consumers, after it was revealed the bulk of their members’ money is in similar products.
Additionally, the argument was put forward that consumers aren’t privy to the funds’ relationship with Diversa Trustees – a shared trustee that has been accused of creating a “giant SMSF” style investment for members.
“It seems to me consumers are being misled,” Liberal MP and committee chair Tim Wilson said during questioning.
Mr Wilson asked why at least 60 per cent of their funds under management are allocated to three BetaShares ETFs, with the environmental impact of these investments also called into question.
“Despite the headline of what you’re seeking to achieve, most of your investment is outsourced effectively by buying products from BetaShares, into passive low-cost products,” Mr Wilson questioned.
‘Future Super actively working with ETF providers’
In response, Future Super governance and regulatory lead Fahmi Hosain defended the fund’s position, arguing that the fund had “actively worked” with ETF providers, with 12 staff members tasked with screening each individual company Future Super is exposed to.
“The investment into ETFs is part of our strategy. We’ve done this consciously to reduce our costs, but we have also innovated in this area,” Mr Hosain said.
“We are essentially active managers of these ETFs because we constantly look at the underlying assets and they have to meet our screens. So, it’s not a passive investment.”
The questioning then extended to Diversa’s business model, with MP Dr Andrew Leigh probing Future Super’s and Verve’s involvement in Diversa’s marketing.
“It does smell to me that you’ve set up a model which is reminiscent of some of the more problematic practices that we saw during the banking royal commission in which you have high cost promoters out there that are selling a pretty similar product,” Dr Leigh said.
The Labor MP also questioned whether the funds are simply targeting different subsections of the market, while providing similar services.
“Yet, when I look at the website, Future Super tells me your super has the power to combat climate change; Verve Super tells me it’s Australia’s first ethical super fund for women by women, yet I see very little difference in the actual investment strategies of these funds,” Dr Leigh said.
‘Achieving members’ outcomes in different ways’
However, Verve Super CEO Christina Hobbs said both funds are achieving members’ outcomes in different ways.
“From Verve’s perspective, we have three key points of differentiation. The services we provide and financial coaching is a part of this,” she said.
Ms Hobbs said that while it is important to consider the similarities in investments, the alternatives are just as important as they are providing impacts for members.
“From an investment perspective, this is certainly where the bulk of effort and costs goes. This includes from Future Super perspective significant investment in renewable energy,” she said.
“Verve Super also has this form of impact investing but also other forms of impact investing. For example, the vision bond.
“The vision bond is an investment in a world vision product that was deemed to be a good investment. This is an investment using our members superannuation balances to invest in the micro refinement projects of women, rural farmers in developing countries, providing a hopeful stable return to our members while also providing a benefit to the communities.
“So, there are differentiation in how we invest and the services we are providing,” Ms Hobbs concluded.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee rate rises to 12 per cent as parental leave changes take effect
The superannuation guarantee rate has increased from 11.5 per cent to 12 per cent from Tuesday, with super contributions also being added to Commonwealth Parental Leave Pay for the first time. Read more
Superannuation
Rest's Sustainable Growth option achieves highest sustainability classification
Rest superannuation fund has achieved the highest sustainability classification for its Sustainable Growth investment option from the Responsible Investment Association Australasia. Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super slashes admin fees for retirees by up to 25 per cent
Aware Super has reduced administration fees for members with a retirement income account by up to 25 per cent and lowered the maximum annual fee. Read more
Superannuation
SuperAPI co-founder criticises Labor's superannuation tax as 'sneaky tax on young people'
The co-founder of SuperAPI has labelled Labor's proposed tax on superannuation balances above $3 million as a "sneaky tax on young people, tomorrow" disguised as a policy targeting wealthy retirees ...Read more
Superannuation
Election policies could reshape Australia's superannuation landscape, expert warns
Competing superannuation policies from Australia's major political parties could have significant implications for investors and retirees, according to a financial expert. Read more
Superannuation
Industry leaders weigh in on concessional super tax as Budget confirms $55bn investment
Changes to the taxation of superannuation earnings and contributions have drawn mixed responses from financial and payroll sector leaders, as the Federal Budget confirms over $55 billion in ...Read more
Superannuation
Call for indexation on super tax cap as $3m threshold draws criticism
A senior executive in the superannuation technology sector has criticised the Federal Government for failing to index the proposed $3 million superannuation tax cap, arguing the measure will unfairly ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest members back calls for fairer superannuation rules ahead of Federal Budget
Rest has called on the Federal Government to implement superannuation reforms aimed at improving fairness across the system, after member survey results showed strong support for a range of proposed ...Read more
Superannuation
Superannuation guarantee rate rises to 12 per cent as parental leave changes take effect
The superannuation guarantee rate has increased from 11.5 per cent to 12 per cent from Tuesday, with super contributions also being added to Commonwealth Parental Leave Pay for the first time. Read more
Superannuation
Rest's Sustainable Growth option achieves highest sustainability classification
Rest superannuation fund has achieved the highest sustainability classification for its Sustainable Growth investment option from the Responsible Investment Association Australasia. Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super slashes admin fees for retirees by up to 25 per cent
Aware Super has reduced administration fees for members with a retirement income account by up to 25 per cent and lowered the maximum annual fee. Read more
Superannuation
SuperAPI co-founder criticises Labor's superannuation tax as 'sneaky tax on young people'
The co-founder of SuperAPI has labelled Labor's proposed tax on superannuation balances above $3 million as a "sneaky tax on young people, tomorrow" disguised as a policy targeting wealthy retirees ...Read more
Superannuation
Election policies could reshape Australia's superannuation landscape, expert warns
Competing superannuation policies from Australia's major political parties could have significant implications for investors and retirees, according to a financial expert. Read more
Superannuation
Industry leaders weigh in on concessional super tax as Budget confirms $55bn investment
Changes to the taxation of superannuation earnings and contributions have drawn mixed responses from financial and payroll sector leaders, as the Federal Budget confirms over $55 billion in ...Read more
Superannuation
Call for indexation on super tax cap as $3m threshold draws criticism
A senior executive in the superannuation technology sector has criticised the Federal Government for failing to index the proposed $3 million superannuation tax cap, arguing the measure will unfairly ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest members back calls for fairer superannuation rules ahead of Federal Budget
Rest has called on the Federal Government to implement superannuation reforms aimed at improving fairness across the system, after member survey results showed strong support for a range of proposed ...Read more
