Retirement
Are managed funds a lucky dip for SMSFs?
Over half of the most popular managed funds owned by SMSF members have underperformed benchmarks over the past five years, despite charging investors higher investment fees for this inferior performance, research has shown.
Are managed funds a lucky dip for SMSFs?
Over half of the most popular managed funds owned by SMSF members have underperformed benchmarks over the past five years, despite charging investors higher investment fees for this inferior performance, research has shown.
Online investment adviser and fund manager Stockspot has analysed the returns of the most popular actively managed funds invested in by SMSFs based on the Class Benchmark Survey.
Stockspot said out of the 1.1 million Australians who have an SMSF, 32 per cent are invested in managed funds. The majority of SMSF investors use 20 funds, of which 18 are actively managed.
According to the research, over half of these popular funds owned by SMSFs have underperformed Morningstar benchmarks for the past five years. The findings indicated a huge variance in the returns for these actively managed funds.
The research also found that the fees charged for some of these funds were high relative to performance. On average, the active funds analysed achieved before-fee returns that were only 0.90 [of a percentage point] per annum over market benchmarks.
“The returns made over market benchmarks weren’t passed on to investors. Instead, the ‘excess’ amount — and then some — was retained by the funds, who kept 1.04 per cent per annum for themselves,” said Stockspot chief executive Chris Brycki.
“This means that investors paid active fund managers $731 million in fees per annum over five years, despite the fact that these funds only beat the market by around $629 million each year. This left investors underwater by approximately $102 million per annum.”
Mr Brycki said SMSF investors should also be aware that star fund managers one year can very quickly become low-performing the next.
“Essentially, managed funds are a ‘lucky dip’ for SMSFs and there are risks of significant underperformance if you get the fund or timing wrong,” he warned.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Self managed super fund
Industry leaders launch SMSF Innovation Council to drive digital transformation
A consortium of finance industry leaders has launched an SMSF Innovation Council to help Australia's $1.02 trillion self-managed superannuation fund industry navigate digital transformation. Read more
Self managed super fund
Superannuation guarantee to be paid on government paid parental leave, says ASFA
The Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia (ASFA) has hailed the government's decision to include Superannuation Guarantee payments with its Paid Parental Leave policy as a critical step ...Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF experts advise against hasty reactions to potential super tax changes
As the Australian Government proposes a new tax measure on superannuation earnings for balances exceeding $3 million, experts from the self-managed super funds (SMSF) sector are urging members not to ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Federal government announces changes to superannuation contribution caps
The Federal Government has announced changes to the superannuation contribution caps, impacting self-managed super funds (SMSFs) and their members from 1 July 2024. Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF Association calls for joint effort to tackle early super access
The SMSF Association is calling on a collaborative approach including the Government, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Rest Super members file class action over alleged insurance premium deductions
Shine Lawyers has initiated a class action lawsuit against Rest Superannuation (Rest), alleging the unlawful deduction of income protection insurance premiums from members' superannuation accounts. Read more
Self managed super fund
Debunking a superannuation tax myth: SMSF Association clarifies the impact on Aussie farms
In the ongoing debate about a proposed new tax targeting superannuation funds exceeding $3 million, the SMSF Association has stepped in to challenge claims from the Association of Superannuation Funds ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Is an SMSF right for you?
When it comes to planning for retirement, one of the most significant decisions Australians have to make is how to manage their superannuation. Read more
Self managed super fund
Industry leaders launch SMSF Innovation Council to drive digital transformation
A consortium of finance industry leaders has launched an SMSF Innovation Council to help Australia's $1.02 trillion self-managed superannuation fund industry navigate digital transformation. Read more
Self managed super fund
Superannuation guarantee to be paid on government paid parental leave, says ASFA
The Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia (ASFA) has hailed the government's decision to include Superannuation Guarantee payments with its Paid Parental Leave policy as a critical step ...Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF experts advise against hasty reactions to potential super tax changes
As the Australian Government proposes a new tax measure on superannuation earnings for balances exceeding $3 million, experts from the self-managed super funds (SMSF) sector are urging members not to ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Federal government announces changes to superannuation contribution caps
The Federal Government has announced changes to the superannuation contribution caps, impacting self-managed super funds (SMSFs) and their members from 1 July 2024. Read more
Self managed super fund
SMSF Association calls for joint effort to tackle early super access
The SMSF Association is calling on a collaborative approach including the Government, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Rest Super members file class action over alleged insurance premium deductions
Shine Lawyers has initiated a class action lawsuit against Rest Superannuation (Rest), alleging the unlawful deduction of income protection insurance premiums from members' superannuation accounts. Read more
Self managed super fund
Debunking a superannuation tax myth: SMSF Association clarifies the impact on Aussie farms
In the ongoing debate about a proposed new tax targeting superannuation funds exceeding $3 million, the SMSF Association has stepped in to challenge claims from the Association of Superannuation Funds ...Read more
Self managed super fund
Is an SMSF right for you?
When it comes to planning for retirement, one of the most significant decisions Australians have to make is how to manage their superannuation. Read more
