Invest
Why passive funds outperform active managers amid COVID-19 pandemic
Active managers have underperformed passive funds by its largest margin since 2016 as the mass market sell-off left active investors underweight in China and technology stocks, new research has found.
Why passive funds outperform active managers amid COVID-19 pandemic
Active managers have underperformed passive funds by its largest margin since 2016 as the mass market sell-off left active investors underweight in China and technology stocks, new research has found.
Copley Fund research has found that US active funds posted their biggest underperformance relative to passive funds since Q1 2016, at 1.44 per cent worse than benchmark indexes.
Active Global Emerging Markets fund returns fell 1.36 per cent short of indexes, while Asia funds were 1.04 per cent below passive peers, the worst underperformance since Q3 2018.
The problem for most active investors is they underweighted China, even for active fund managers with aggressive growth strategies, the research found.
“The outperformance of China was costly for active managers, who have been increasing underweight bets over the last 18 months,” said Steven Holden, CEO of Copley Fund Research Global.
Emerging Markets and Asia Ex-Japan funds were all close to record underweight in Chinese equities going into the crisis.
Since the start of 2020, aggressive growth strategies, in which investors buy stocks with higher valuations and growth expectations, have outperformed value portfolios by the most since 2017, Copley’s data showed.
While all investment categories are deep in the red, aggressive growth strategies outperformed those favouring cheaper stocks by 14.3 per cent in the US funds category, 9.62 per cent for global funds and 4.5 per cent for Emerging Market active funds
“Active strategies focussed on aggressive growth stocks are performing well in the downturn. No one could have anticipated the scale of this market rout, and yet these strategies are adding relative performance despite the overall ugliness of the market,” Mr Holden continued.
The research also showed that active managers underweighted US tech giants, with Microsoft, Apple and Amazon accounting for nearly 15 per cent of the growth for the S&P 500, which contributed to 0.51 per cent of the underperformance for active US and 0.31 per cent for global funds.
Even so, all is not lost for active managers – if the recovery from the global financial crisis is anything to go by. Copley Fund Research analysis showed that, historically, US and GEM active managers recorded their biggest outperformance against indexes in 2009.
“Price distortions caused by high levels of volatility, forced selling and passive outflows will create opportunities for long-term active managers to buy into favoured stocks at attractive valuations,” Mr Holden concluded.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Stock market
Portfolio reviews as an operating discipline: turning volatility into a competitive edge
In a higher-rate, higher-volatility world, portfolio reviews are no longer an annual hygiene task; they’re a core operating rhythm that protects cash flow, unlocks tax alpha, and sharpens risk ...Read more
Stock market
Fee war on the ASX: Global X’s A300 turns up the heat on core Aussie equity ETFs
Global X has lobbed a 0.04% management fee into Australia’s core equity sandbox, launching the Australia 300 ETF (A300) to take on entrenched giants. Read more
Stock market
Challenger IM shakes up the ASX with private credit note and a side of risk
Challenger Investment Management has taken private credit mainstream with an ASX-listed note structure—LiFTs—that secured roughly $100 million in cornerstone commitments within a day of launch. Read more
Stock market
International stocks: Diversifying your portfolio beyond Australia
In an increasingly globalized market, Australian investors have the opportunity to enhance their investment portfolio by incorporating international stocks. Diversifying your investments globally can ...Read more
Stock market
Stock market rally likely to continue regardless of Fed minutes tone, says deVere CEO
The bull run that has propelled Wall Street's major indexes to record highs this month is expected to continue regardless of the tone of the upcoming Federal Reserve minutes, according to Nigel Green, ...Read more
Stock market
US stock rally driven more by valuation growth than earnings, leaving tech names vulnerable: Innova
The strong gains in US stocks over the past year, particularly in the technology sector, have been driven more by expanding valuations than underlying earnings growth, leaving them exposed to a ...Read more
Stock market
Sun Silver to make its ASX debut with a $13 million IPO
Sun Silver Limited (proposed ASX Code: "SS1") has announced the opening of its Initial Public Offering (IPO) today, aiming to raise a minimum of $10 million and a maximum of $13 million (before costs)Read more
Stock market
Nasdaq hits record high, underscores the value of tech in investment portfolios
The Nasdaq Composite's surge to an all-time high last Friday highlights the importance of incorporating technology into investment strategies. Read more
Stock market
Portfolio reviews as an operating discipline: turning volatility into a competitive edge
In a higher-rate, higher-volatility world, portfolio reviews are no longer an annual hygiene task; they’re a core operating rhythm that protects cash flow, unlocks tax alpha, and sharpens risk ...Read more
Stock market
Fee war on the ASX: Global X’s A300 turns up the heat on core Aussie equity ETFs
Global X has lobbed a 0.04% management fee into Australia’s core equity sandbox, launching the Australia 300 ETF (A300) to take on entrenched giants. Read more
Stock market
Challenger IM shakes up the ASX with private credit note and a side of risk
Challenger Investment Management has taken private credit mainstream with an ASX-listed note structure—LiFTs—that secured roughly $100 million in cornerstone commitments within a day of launch. Read more
Stock market
International stocks: Diversifying your portfolio beyond Australia
In an increasingly globalized market, Australian investors have the opportunity to enhance their investment portfolio by incorporating international stocks. Diversifying your investments globally can ...Read more
Stock market
Stock market rally likely to continue regardless of Fed minutes tone, says deVere CEO
The bull run that has propelled Wall Street's major indexes to record highs this month is expected to continue regardless of the tone of the upcoming Federal Reserve minutes, according to Nigel Green, ...Read more
Stock market
US stock rally driven more by valuation growth than earnings, leaving tech names vulnerable: Innova
The strong gains in US stocks over the past year, particularly in the technology sector, have been driven more by expanding valuations than underlying earnings growth, leaving them exposed to a ...Read more
Stock market
Sun Silver to make its ASX debut with a $13 million IPO
Sun Silver Limited (proposed ASX Code: "SS1") has announced the opening of its Initial Public Offering (IPO) today, aiming to raise a minimum of $10 million and a maximum of $13 million (before costs)Read more
Stock market
Nasdaq hits record high, underscores the value of tech in investment portfolios
The Nasdaq Composite's surge to an all-time high last Friday highlights the importance of incorporating technology into investment strategies. Read more
