Invest
Investing v gambling: Is there a difference?
Investing money into the stock market and trying to pick a winner at today’s Melbourne Cup aren’t as different as you might expect, according to a mathematician.
Investing v gambling: Is there a difference?
Investing money into the stock market and trying to pick a winner at today’s Melbourne Cup aren’t as different as you might expect, according to a mathematician.
In conversation with nestegg, University of Melbourne’s Professor Peter Taylor said “unstructured gambling”, which incorporates complicated games, such as sports betting and horse racing, have similar mathematical outcomes to investing in the sharemarket.
Similarities
Diversification
Like any fund manager will tell you, putting all of your eggs in one basket is a recipe for disaster.
Much like shareholders who invest their money into multiple different shares in a variety of sectors, bookies do the same thing.
Professor Taylor outlined how “if they have a lot of people betting on one horse, they might lower the odds on the horse or take the money themselves and bet with another bookie on the horse, just so they get some money back if the horse happens to win”.
Past performance
Much like picking shares, choosing a horse is not a precise decision based on mathematics – various factors can change the outcome.
Investors in shares are relying on previous performance to predict the future of a share price, while punters rely on the same knowledge with horses.
In both situation, institutions and bookies, as well as retail investors and punters are both trying to gain an edge at potentially the other’s expense.
“All the random things that happen with 24 horses, jockeys, different conditions, different parts of the track and random events, if you put them all together, nobody can possibly have a model that comes up with anything remotely of an assessment of real possibilities,” Professor Taylor said.
He added that in order to choose a horse, punters predict a result based on past performances, including a horse form in set conditions, much like choosing a stock.
Both are gambling
The professor said that due to a concept in mathematics known as random events, both sharemarkets and horse racing are really a form of gambling.
“People might not think of it that way. The math has a concept called a random event. Nobody knows what is going to happen. We might have an assessment of what is going to happen, but nobody knows what is going to happen,” he outlined.
“Nobody knows what the price of a particular stock tomorrow, much like the Melbourne Cup – even though we might have an assessment of probabilities.”
Differences
Zero sum game
While both gambling on unstructured games and investing money into the stock market have similarities, only one has a zero-sum game.
A zero-sum game is a mathematical representation that shows participants either gain or lose in equal balances.
In gambling, the outcome is black and white, with participants either winning or losing.
However, movement in shares is gradual and investors could see themselves going slightly up or down.
“If you buy some shares, it might go up a bit, therefore you’ve won a bit. Or it might go down a bit, therefore you’ve lost a bit, but you still have some value.”
“What you are really betting there is the margin. If you buy a ticket on a horse in a Melbourne Cup, it could be ‘each way’, which might have some intermittent outcomes as well,” the academic said.
Time factor
Another key difference between the two activities has to do with time. Gambling is a time-bound event, while investing in a company can last theoretically much longer.
With gambling, once the race or game has begun, the opportunity for an investor to make a gain or loss is gone.
With stocks, investors can be rewarded for spending time in the market through dividends – meaning that over the longer term, an investor can get in front.
Access to data
While both horse racing and investing rely on past information in order to gain information that might predict future performance, only shares have information available at all times.
“The bookies have a subjective assessment, and the punters have subjective assessments,” Professor Taylor said.
On the other hand, investors are able to look up the code for any company and see relevant financial data.
He gave the examples of a casino or a bookmaker not needing to inform punters of previous cards dealt or the reasoning behind their odds for a particular horse.
The subjective access to data allows both the punter and the bookie to make an educated guess based on their knowledge, while investors in sharemarkets are all theoretically presented with the same information.
It allows educated punters to possibly gain an advantage, according to the scholar.
“Your assessment of probabilities if you’re a bookie is probably pretty good, but it might be the case that a punter knows better,” the professor concluded.
About the author
About the author
Stock market
Super fund investors bid to acquire Sydney Airport
A group of super fund investors has lodged a non-binding takeover bid for Sydney Airport, valuing the company at over $22 billion. ...Read more
Stock market
10 most globally held stocks revealed
Australian investors remain bullish on electric vehicles and technology stocks, according to their long-term held positions, new research has shown. ...Read more
Stock market
How ‘gamer investors’ are pushing a new wave of social responsibility
A new generation of younger retail investors are pushing a new social movement, yielding a distributive impact on the markets, most notably through the GameStop saga, two researchers have revealed. ...Read more
Stock market
ASX tipped for record high despite inflation fears
The market is tipped to shake off fears of rising inflation, with the ASX 200 now tipped to close the year at a new record high, an economist has revealed. ...Read more
Stock market
‘Commission-free propaganda’: Warning issued for retail investors
The phrase “if you’re not paying for it, you’re the product” applies just as much to stock trading apps as it does to social media networks. ...Read more
Stock market
Is the tech sell-off creating opportunities for investors?
A tech sell-off sparked by inflation concerns has seen world markets crash. But is it creating an opportunity for investors to ‘buy the dip’? ...Read more
Stock market
Government opens arms to Wall Street
In its bid to maintain Australia’s global competitiveness, albeit its firmly shut borders, the Australian government has included a measure in its recent budget to allow foreign financial services p...Read more
Stock market
Aussie market falls on US inflation
The Australian sharemarket has fallen on the bell after Wall Street experienced sharp sell-offs overnight due to hotter than expected inflation data. ...Read more
Do lockdowns boost property prices? Are short-sellers levelling the playing field? Did you lodge your tax returns early?
Listen now
Will lockdowns halt the housing boom? Is the metaverse taking over? And the cons of lodging your tax returns early
Listen now
Are you being priced out of the market? Have you got the Tuesday blues? And are you ready for the upcoming super changes?
Listen now
Are property prices set to crash? Should you jump on board the fintok craze? And how to prepare for this tax time
Listen now
Stock market
Super fund investors bid to acquire Sydney Airport
A group of super fund investors has lodged a non-binding takeover bid for Sydney Airport, valuing the company at over $22 billion. ...Read more
Stock market
10 most globally held stocks revealed
Australian investors remain bullish on electric vehicles and technology stocks, according to their long-term held positions, new research has shown. ...Read more
Stock market
How ‘gamer investors’ are pushing a new wave of social responsibility
A new generation of younger retail investors are pushing a new social movement, yielding a distributive impact on the markets, most notably through the GameStop saga, two researchers have revealed. ...Read more
Stock market
ASX tipped for record high despite inflation fears
The market is tipped to shake off fears of rising inflation, with the ASX 200 now tipped to close the year at a new record high, an economist has revealed. ...Read more
Stock market
‘Commission-free propaganda’: Warning issued for retail investors
The phrase “if you’re not paying for it, you’re the product” applies just as much to stock trading apps as it does to social media networks. ...Read more
Stock market
Is the tech sell-off creating opportunities for investors?
A tech sell-off sparked by inflation concerns has seen world markets crash. But is it creating an opportunity for investors to ‘buy the dip’? ...Read more
Stock market
Government opens arms to Wall Street
In its bid to maintain Australia’s global competitiveness, albeit its firmly shut borders, the Australian government has included a measure in its recent budget to allow foreign financial services p...Read more
Stock market
Aussie market falls on US inflation
The Australian sharemarket has fallen on the bell after Wall Street experienced sharp sell-offs overnight due to hotter than expected inflation data. ...Read more
More articles
Website Notifications
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
