Invest
ESG investors beat the market
Investors who are following strong environmental, social and governance principles are outperforming the market through the COVID-19 pandemic, a fund manager has announced.

ESG investors beat the market
Investors who are following strong environmental, social and governance principles are outperforming the market through the COVID-19 pandemic, a fund manager has announced.

AXA investment managers showed that ESG leaders outperformed ESG laggards by 16.8 per cent in the first quarter of 2020.
According to Yo Takatsuki, head of ESG research and active ownership, AXA IM, COVID-19 has presented the first major test for ESG investing, the rise of which over the last decade has largely coincided with the longest stock market bull run in history.
“The COVID-19 pandemic is the first real ‘acid test’ of ESG investment theory,” said Mr Takatsuki.
“There is no surprise that the pandemic is having a huge impact on the rapid stock market decline. Some of the world’s major equity indices, such as the S&P 500 and FTSE 100, have experienced their worst quarter since 1987. The MSCI All Country World Index, an index of equities from developed and emerging markets, fell by a third from its peak in early February to its quarterly low in late March.
Fidelity reaffirmed this through its own study, which compared across more than 2,600 companies, using its proprietary sustainability rating system. The forward-looking ratings are derived from direct engagement with companies, aggregating approximately 15,000 individual company meetings per year.
The data found that a company’s market performance and ESG rating are positively correlated, even in a crisis. The equity and fixed income securities issued by companies at the top of Fidelity’s sustainability rating scale (A and B) on average outperformed those with average (C) and weaker ratings (D and E) in this short period, with a remarkably strong linear relationship.
In the 36 days between 19 February and 26 March, the S&P 500 fell 26.9 per cent. Meanwhile, the price of a share in companies with a high (A or B) Fidelity ESG rating dropped less than that on average, while those rated C to E fell more than the benchmark. A-rated companies performed on average 3.8 percentage points better, while E-rated companies performed on average 7.4 percentage points worse than the S&P 500 during the period examined.
Jenn-Hui Tan, global head of stewardship and sustainable investing, Fidelity International, commented: “Our thesis, when starting the research, was that the companies with good sustainability characteristics have better management teams and so should outperform the market, even in a crisis. The data that came back supported this view.
“While some caveats remain, including adjustments for beta, credit quality and the sudden market recovery, we are encouraged by evidence of an overall relationship between strong sustainability factors and returns, lending further credence to the importance of analysing ESG factors as part of a fundamental research approach.”
About the author

About the author


Stock market
Beware the reversal of the sharemarket rally, expert says
The companies that offer the greatest risk for investors in 2021 are somewhat ironically many of the same companies that have provided the greatest return to investors in 2020, an expert has warned. ...Read more

Stock market
Is climate change the next big investment theme?
Investors looking to outperform the market are being urged to look at structural growth, with climate change likely to create the biggest investment opportunity since the internet, an industry expert ...Read more

Stock market
All Ords set for new record by February, analyst predicts
The Australian market is likely to reach a new record in the early months of the year, with a win on the health front likely to offset geopolitical issues, an analyst has stated. ...Read more

Stock market
Aussies flock to fixed interest and ETP products for stable returns
Investors seeking stability during the COVID-19 pandemic have turned to fixed interest and cash exchange-traded products, new research has revealed. ...Read more

Stock market
Emerging market equities gain traction in post-pandemic world
Emerging market equities are making a comeback as technology-savvy consumers flock to capitalise on new opportunities that the 2020 pandemic may have made too attractive to ignore. ...Read more

Stock market
Is it too late to start investing in market index ETFs?
With the Australian market recovering its losses since the pandemic began, nestegg asked an industry expert if it was too late for investors to begin their investing journey. ...Read more

Stock market
Is it time to buy reopening stocks?
Investors are being advised to look into stocks that could benefit from markets reopening, an analyst has stated. ...Read more

Stock market
Stocks to watch in 2021
Easing political uncertainty, new vaccine hopes, central bank’s willingness to do all it takes and more, and new stimulus packages are likely to act as tailwinds for investors, an analyst has said. ...Read more

Stock market
Beware the reversal of the sharemarket rally, expert says
The companies that offer the greatest risk for investors in 2021 are somewhat ironically many of the same companies that have provided the greatest return to investors in 2020, an expert has warned. ...Read more

Stock market
Is climate change the next big investment theme?
Investors looking to outperform the market are being urged to look at structural growth, with climate change likely to create the biggest investment opportunity since the internet, an industry expert ...Read more

Stock market
All Ords set for new record by February, analyst predicts
The Australian market is likely to reach a new record in the early months of the year, with a win on the health front likely to offset geopolitical issues, an analyst has stated. ...Read more

Stock market
Aussies flock to fixed interest and ETP products for stable returns
Investors seeking stability during the COVID-19 pandemic have turned to fixed interest and cash exchange-traded products, new research has revealed. ...Read more

Stock market
Emerging market equities gain traction in post-pandemic world
Emerging market equities are making a comeback as technology-savvy consumers flock to capitalise on new opportunities that the 2020 pandemic may have made too attractive to ignore. ...Read more

Stock market
Is it too late to start investing in market index ETFs?
With the Australian market recovering its losses since the pandemic began, nestegg asked an industry expert if it was too late for investors to begin their investing journey. ...Read more

Stock market
Is it time to buy reopening stocks?
Investors are being advised to look into stocks that could benefit from markets reopening, an analyst has stated. ...Read more

Stock market
Stocks to watch in 2021
Easing political uncertainty, new vaccine hopes, central bank’s willingness to do all it takes and more, and new stimulus packages are likely to act as tailwinds for investors, an analyst has said. ...Read more